[Suggestion] Simple way to make Brandia relevant and improve Rakan

Turn her 3rd skill into an AoE.

She'd need changes to the multiplier, of course, but that solves 2 issues: makes Brandia useful in the current meta and adds another fire AoE DD to the game since there are not many of those (Rica and Zaiross are the only really viable ones atm, iirc. Maybe jun counts but that's a big maybe. Adding Okeanos here as u/GalatiaX mentioned and Clara to the maybe list).

I think the something similar could be done to Rakan: make his 3rd an AoE, adjusting the multiplier as needed, and either have the current debuff affecting only a target unit (similar to how Taor's AoE works) or with the debuff affecting all but being reduced to 25% Atb and\or 1 turn slow only or something of the sort. Of course we'd all want him to either be full atk or HP scaling or at least have some logic in having both scalings (like Chow, for example), but that's a different battle XD.

What are your thoughts?

Posted Jun 6, 2016, 6:14 PM UTC · edited

112
stacyburns88chilltown•

Making Brandia's 3rd AoE (and therefore lowering the multiplier) actually hurts her kit, IMO. This would debuff strip the entire enemy party. It makes her even less raid-viable (not that she was to begin with) because it nerfs her boss damage, and she immediately becomes useless for Arena because who doesn't use Galleon these days?

If they insist on her 3rd removing debuffs, there is no option but to keep this skill single target. It's her 2nd skill, IMO, that needs to be tweaked if she is to become a meta pick DD.

2
TimodarOPNow you see me. Now you don't.•

spd tune her to go last in galleon comp, win.

My point is that there are already tons on viable raid DDs while not many fire AoE. removing debuffs is easily worked around. I remember people saying that tiana was useless because she removed your buffs. People learned about spd tuning, galleon came along and boom, Tiana is now top tier.

PS:at that same time brandia was being praised for her 100k+ nukes.

2
stacyburns88chilltown•

Then what's the point? Why not just run a better (and safer) AoE nuke if you can kill the entire enemy team in one rotation?

1
TimodarOPNow you see me. Now you don't.•

Just wrote a bit more above but the point is having an option of where to use her. Sure, there are tons of other viable ways to make her useful, this is just a simple one that doesn't mess with other PQs.

She'd still have the extra damage from removing buffs, so she'd be 'safe' nuke wise (as in terminating the enemy team).

1
stacyburns88chilltown•

I dunno, I don't see this bringing her out of storage.

Her niche right now is GW, and she actually does pretty well there. She requires a specific team setup, but if you can make it work, it works. Lowering her nuke and making it AoE will hurt her in GW without helping her in Arena in the way she needs to be helped.

I just don't see it, sorry.

2
GalatiaX•

You forgot Okeanos (fire sea emperor) as fire aoe dd, then there's also Clara but dunno how viable she is.

I would like to see a rework on Brandia as her kit doesn't really match, and removing debuffs on the opponent isn't really popular among players.

For Rakan, I actually haven't seen many showcases of him after the buff, but I do think he's good for gw as single target nuker. I would rather want to see a small tweak on his second skill to buff like cr and immunity instead of atk buff n immunity to make him more viable and maybe make his 3rd skill purely scale on hp and not both atk n hp. But I wouldn't want him to be an aoe dd.

1
TimodarOPNow you see me. Now you don't.•

Clara's base atk is very low, but she has the advantage of not needing CR for her 3rd.

For the debuff removal, I really don't mind it if the enemy is gone along with them xD

As for Rakan, it could have a bit power removed and being changed to half AoE as it is with Taor. Honestly he could have that just added to the skill as it's not really poweful as it is right now.

1
Discosuittget banged•

Swapping her and Tiana's second skill could help.

1
drmashi•

Help Tiana becoming an even more OP support? For sure. It's such a bad idea that Com2Us can actually really consider doing that. Because overbuffing good monsters it's their speciality

2
TimodarOPNow you see me. Now you don't.•

tbh no one uses Tiana for her second skill and having it changed to a support type as it should be since she is a support monster after all would not really change that much.

On the other hand, brandia is next to useless in the current meta and this would indeed help her kit.

1
drmashi•

One thing is asking to switch skill 2 with let's say Lydia who is another unit who needs a buff, another is giving a free buff to an already strong unit.

Nobody uses Tiana for her 2nd because her third is already strong enough to make fights last 1 turn (when coupled with galleon and a couple of aoe nukers). With Brandia's second she will be useable in prolonged fights too and basically she would have no weak points. You failed to nuke them first round? No problem, here take aoe shield + aoe atk break, this way you can clean them up without a risk.

Switching with the dark one wont break any monster, they basically already need to rework Lydia into a support because she is useless as a nuker, she was maybe somewhat decent when she was the only one with brand but now even dark harpy is basically an upgrade over her.

1
That_damn_brute•

If she regained a turn after using her second skill she could be more viable. Would tie in nicely with her third.

1