ELI5: Republican/Democratic national convention, and the 2016 US presidential election process FAQ

Official

Please help ELI5 answer some common questions. Keep in mind, we are an international community, and not everyone has studied or remembers their US civics.

  1. What happens at a national convention? What happens if the presumptive nominee doesn't get sufficient votes?

  2. How are the delegates picked? Do they have to vote for candidate they were assigned? What happens if they change their vote?

  3. Who are super delegates, and why are they chosen?

  4. Why does the presidential candidate have to nominate their VP?

  5. Why do we have an electoral college? What about the general election?

  6. What happens if there is a tie at the electoral college?

Posted Jun 14, 2016, 11:17 PM UTC

6145
AnghellicKarma•

I'll give it a stab:

1) What happens at a national convention? What happens if the presumptive nominee doesn't get sufficient votes?
At a national convention, delegates from each state gather together to vote for the candidate that won in their respective state. Most of the time, these delegates are pledged to vote for whomever the winner was in that state, regardless of how they personally feel.
If the presumptive nominee does not get enough votes, however, then they move into new rounds of voting (called ballots), with each subsequent round releasing more delegates from pledged status.

2) How are the delegates picked? Do they have to vote for candidate they were assigned? What happens if they change their vote?
Delegates are picked at statewide conventions (process varies at each state). Most times, they are committing to vote at the national convention for whomever wins the primary in their state, at least for the first ballot. I'm not sure there's technically any punishment for changing their vote before this, though.

3) Who are super delegates, and why are they chosen?
Super delegates are exclusive to the Democratic party. They are made up of people pre-selected that are not bound by any voting that takes place, but can vote for whomever they wish right off the bat. According to the Democratic Party Chairman, they exist to protect against grassroots activists.

4) Why does the presidential candidate have to nominate their VP?
Those rules are set by each party. For example, the Libertarian party does not have the nominee pre-select a running mate, but has the delegates at their convention vote for them the same way as the presidential candidate. Republicans and Democrats, however, do not.

5) Why do we have an electoral college? What about the general election?
The electoral college exists to give equal representation to states proportionate to their population and Congressional representatives. For example, without the electoral college, a candidate need only visit NYC, Los Angeles, and any other very high-populated cities. The electoral college makes it so they must reach across broad spectrums of Americana instead of just the very most populous.

In the general election, each state has an electoral count to it. The winning presidential candidate must accrue at least 270 electoral votes to secure victory.

6) What happens if there is a tie at the electoral college?
If there is either a tie in the electoral college (the name for the tallying up of these electoral votes), or no candidate hits 270, then the House of Representatives then votes on who the president will be. Each state gets one vote, determined by the majority. So a state with 5 Representatives would have whichever emerges from those 5 as the winner put forth as that state's vote.
Example: Tim, Tom, Mary, Mike, and Alex are the 5 representatives of the fictional US state of AnghellicKarma. Mary and Mike vote for Candidate A and Alex, Tim, and Tom vote for Candidate B. In the voting done by the House of Representatives, the state of AnghellicKarma puts forth a vote for Candidate B.

The Senate would choose the Vice President with votes cast by the individual Senators (two per state).

Further reading:

27
Exentrick•

For example, without the electoral college, a candidate need only visit NYC, Los Angeles, and any other very high-populated cities.

This is rather misleading. Those cities alone could not win you the election in a popular vote, not by a long shot.

CGP grey on the electoral college:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUS9mM8Xbbw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wC42HgLA4k

8
The_Petunia•

It has been a bit since I last saw that idea and I can't quite watch it now but that video is one of CGP's most misleading. On the point of balancing for population: when he talks about which cities candidates currently visit most he (also leaving out context such as which cities are in a swing state and such is a glaring omission to me). Also unless I am mistaken it is more to balance against candidates prioritizing policy that would work well for well cities in general but suck for rural areas in general.

That being said I do think the current way the electoral college is being used is criminally wrong. I think a much better compromise would be if every state gave the winning candidate the 2 senate electoral votes and a proportional number of house electoral votes.

3
Exentrick•

(also leaving out context such as which cities are in a swing state and such is a glaring omission to me)

Ya, that's part of the problem. If the idea is to make small states more important, or to keep attention from the non-big cities, it doesn't matter. It's a spectacular fail. All our system does is encourage a ridiculous amount of attention to be given to any swing state, and for the rest to be ignored. The whole system is FUBAR.

4
The_Petunia•

Oh right swing states are part of why i dont like what we are doing now but they are still part of the context of his argument. I think proportional electoral votes everywhere wpuld undo swing states a bit without going all the way to a completely popular vote.

2
lossyvibrations•

The canonical example of how screwed up this is, is the embargo on Cuba. There aren't that many Cuban "refugees" in the US (I put refugees in quotes; the ones pushing the embargo were mostly wealthy Cubans who are simply mad that their little aristrocracy and plantation system under Batista got overthrown.) But they almost exclusively live in a swing state - Florida. A state where presidential elections come down less than a percent usually, and sometimes a few hundred votes. Any candidate who ran and did not support the embargo was guaranteed to lose that voting bloc. On a national scale, that bloc doesn't matter - but the EC magnifies their power.

1
JustinianImp•

Correction to 1)

1) What happens at a national convention? What happens if the presumptive nominee doesn't get sufficient votes? At a national convention, delegates from each state and territory gather together to vote for candidates for President and Vice President. Most of these delegates are bound to vote for a particular candidate on the first ballot, regardless of how they personally feel. How this works varies by party and by state. In the Democratic Party, delegates are assigned to candidates based on the percentage of the votes each candidate got in the state's primary or caucus. (Example: if a state has 100 delegates, and Candidate A won 55 percent of the vote, she gets 55 delegates bound to vote for her.) In the Republican Party, the rules are more flexible and a state party can decide to assign all the delegates to the candidate who won the most votes in the primary; to assign them proportionally, like the Democrats; or to use some other method.

To win the nomination, a candidate (in either party) must receive a majority of the total number of delegates. If no one gets enough votes on the first ballot, then they move into new rounds of voting (called ballots). Most delegates are only committed to a particular candidate for the first ballot (although this also depends on party rules), and after that they can vote for whomever they want.

2
JustinianImp•

4) Why does the presidential candidate have to nominate their VP? Those rules are set by each party. For example, the Libertarian party does not have the nominee pre-select a running mate, but has the delegates at their convention vote for them the same way as the presidential candidate. Republicans and Democrats, however, do not.

Correct answer: They don't have to, but it is a tradition (at least in the Republican and Democratic Parties) that the presidential nominee "recommends" a vice-presidential nominee, whom the convention invariably nominates. Technically, the process of nominating a vice-presidential candidate follows the same rules as the presidential nomination, except that delegates are not officially bound or pledged. There have been a few cases, most recently at the 1956 Democratic convention, when the nominee declined to make any recommendation, and the delegates themselves chose the nominee (which took two ballots).

2
Bergkoe•

At 3), how do superdelegates protect against grassroot activists?

1
EIephants•

this is a Bernie fan way of putting it. Super delegates were established in the 1960s to protect the party against Trump-like candidates that had the potential to destroy the party. It is not "the establishment's" way of shitting on the little guys even though it may seem that way. I bet we all wish the republicans had super delegates right about now.

13
pTangents•

Superdelegates weren't implemented until the 80s, on the heels of the grassroots candidate George McGovern losing the general election by one of the largest landslides in history. The intent is less focused on someone who will "destroy the party" and more someone who is unelectable.

5
AnghellicKarma•

this is a Bernie fan way of putting it.

I'm not a fan of Bernie, actually. I merely linked and used the very words of the Democrat Party Chairwoman.

1
Cliffy73•

Democratic, please.

3
bantership•

Democrat Party

Democratic Party.

Debbie Wasserman Schultz is a very poor leader and not a great resource to quote in regards to a Democratic Party policy that has been in place since the 1980s.

-1
BananaDependency•

15% of Democratic delegates are unpledged. 19% of Republicans are as well, they're just not called "superdelegates."

1
oliver_babish•

It's actually the opposite, and the framing wholly distorts what DWS said: the existence of SDs means that grassroots activists don't have to run against elected officials (and their built-in name recognition) in seeking delegate slots; otherwise, activists would be squeezed out of the process. This way, electeds are guaranteed slots (and votes), and the elected delegate slots are freed up.

1
AnghellicKarma•

wholly distorts what DWS said

I quoted her.

1
oliver_babish•

Not accurately. Via the CNN transcript:

WASSERMAN SCHULTZ: Well, let me just make sure that I can clarify exactly what was available during the primaries in Iowa and in New Hampshire.

The unpledged delegates are a separate category. The only thing available on the ballot in a primary and a caucus is the pledged delegates, those that are tied to the candidate that they are pledged to support. And they receive a proportional number of delegates going into the -- going into our convention.

Unpledged delegates exist really to make sure that party leaders and elected officials don't have to be in a position where they are running against grassroots activists. We are, as a Democratic Party, really highlight and emphasize inclusiveness and diversity at our convention, and so we want to give every opportunity to grassroots activists and diverse committed Democrats to be able to participate, attend and be a delegate at the convention.

And so we separate out those unpledged delegates to make sure that there isn't competition between them.

4
darexinfinity•

activists would be squeezed out of the process

How would not having super-delegates exist put them in a worse position?

1
oliver_babish•

Because then members of Congress and Governors would have to run for district delegate positions in order to be on the floor of the Convention and have full access. Because of superior name recognition, they'd consistently beat grassroots activists in the elections without having to lift a finger.

1
zachdolton•

Also the republicans do have super delegates but a lot less than the democrats

1
darexinfinity•

They're forced to vote in the direction that their state does, in terms of functionality they're more like the Democrat PDs.

0
atohitotsu•

If there is either a tie in the electoral college (the name for the tallying up of these electoral votes), or no candidate hits 270, then the House of Representatives then votes on who the president will be.

There are 50 states - what if there is a 25-25 tie?

Each state gets one vote, determined by the majority. So a state with 5 Representatives would have whichever emerges from those 5 as the winner put forth as that state's vote.

What happens if the state's representatives are tied? For example, New Jersey currently has 6 Democrat and 6 Republican representatives.

1
zipzopzoobitybop•

There are 50 states - what if there is a 25-25 tie?

If they haven't reached a decision by Jan 20 (Inauguration Day), the vice president (as chosen by the Senate) becomes acting president. If a Vice President hasn't been chosen then the Speaker of the House resigns from Congress and becomes acting president. But the House vote keeps going until they reach a decision. There's no time limit so theoretically they could go a full term without choosing a president.

What happens if the state's representatives are tied? For example, New Jersey currently has 6 Democrat and 6 Republican representatives.

That state loses its vote.

2
pokerback•

Thanks for explaining. A little question though.

I hope you watch House of Cards. In the 4th season of the TV Series, during the open convention for the VP pick, the state of Louisiana votes for Catherine Durant for the President of US.

The presidential primaries and caucuses are already over by this time which means the state of Louisiana already voted for either Dunbar or Francis. So, every pledged delegate must be bound to vote to either Dunbar or Francis.

But, how come all the delegates of Louisiana vote to Durant for President though she was not even on ballot during the primaries?

TIA

1
JustinianImp•

Because it's fiction?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
metssuck•

The Electoral College also ensures that a President is elected with "50%" of the vote, I put 50% in quotes because it's 50% of the required votes to become President. One of it's biggest advantages is that it, generally, prevents a person from winning 20% of the vote but becoming President because 20% happens to be enough. Now this is also a disadvantage as it's encouraged (after the first 50-100 years or so) us to move to a 2 party system.

1
Weep2D2•

If I am a delegate, is my job only to vote for candidates? I do nothing else?

Could we get more info how how delegates are chosen?

How is the state/delegate count worked out?

2
Cliffy73•

The primary job of delegates to the conventions is to vote on the nominee. However, conventions also vote on the Party platform, that official statement about what the Party believes and hopes to achieve. This is functionally not terribly important, because the platform doesn't bind anyone -- candidates, office holders, or voters -- to follow it, but it is a document that reflects the spirit of the Party, and there is frequently a lot of horse trading around it.

Conventions also set their own rules, which means that functionally the delegates get to decide (within certain broad strokes) how the nominating process will work four years later. This year, for instance, the GOP establishment has grudgingly recognized that Trump is their pony, but I would not at all be surprised to see some rule changes come out of their Convention to give the old heads more control at the expense of the popular will. (Typically a nominee will have a lot of power in these rule-setting discussions because he will have a lot of delegates, but Trump has done a poor job of getting delegates selected that like him -- they will vote for him as the nominee because they're obligated, but they aren't necessarily his political allies.)

The Democratic rules may change as well, but it's harder to product, because Sanders will have a large number of his delegates there, but not as many as Clinton. So you would guess that they will be small enough that they won't get big structural changes made but large enough that they could stop the establishment from tightening up the process against insurgents (if Clinton even cares about that -- she might not want to insulate the establishment now that she has already won; four years from now she will either be not running or the sitting president, so she has no need to game out her 2020 strategy).

Picking delegates is pretty arcane, and it varies state to state. In general, local party leaders send delegates to a state convention, and the state convention decides who to send. There can be parliamentary fights about this. Some states have rules about who gets picked based on the popular vote (Maryland, for instance, elects delegates directly, and it tells you on the ballot what candidate they support). Delegates are required by Party rules and in some cases state law to follow the outcomes of the popular vote, and usually delegates are people who support the person they're sent there to vote for, but it doesn't have to be the case in most states. As noted above, Trump has done a bad job of this, so you shouldn't necessarily expect the delegates who vote for him to support him on rules or platform questions.

Delegate counts are based on the population of Democrats/Republicans in each state. In some states the GOP delegates are all assigned to the winner of the state. In most, and for all states on the Dem side, delegates in a given state are allocated to each candidate in proportion to the results of the primary or caucus. However, after the race is over losing candidates often release their delegates to vote for whoever they want, or direct them to vote for someone else, which is why floor votes for nominees are often unanimous.

4
Weep2D2•

Thank you, kindly.

1
WRSaunders•
  1. Super delegates are democratic politicians who get to vote at the convention as an ex-officio duty (a part of their elected job).
1
WRSaunders•
  1. If the electoral college is unable to choose a winner, the newly elected House of Representatives gets to pick the president. The newly elected Senate gets to pick the vice-president. From the 12th amendment:

The person having the greatest Number of votes for President, shall be the President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of Electors appointed; and if no person have such majority, then from the persons having the highest numbers not exceeding three on the list of those voted for as President, the House of Representatives shall choose immediately, by ballot, the President. But in choosing the President, the votes shall be taken by states, the representation from each state having one vote; a quorum for this purpose shall consist of a member or members from two-thirds of the states, and a majority of all the states shall be necessary to a choice. And if the House of Representatives shall not choose a President whenever the right of choice shall devolve upon them, before the fourth day of March next following, then the Vice-President shall act as President, as in the case of the death or other constitutional disability of the President.

The person having the greatest number of votes as Vice-President, shall be the Vice-President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of Electors appointed, and if no person have a majority, then from the two highest numbers on the list, the Senate shall choose the Vice-President; a quorum for the purpose shall consist of two-thirds of the whole number of Senators, and a majority of the whole number shall be necessary to a choice. But no person constitutionally ineligible to the office of President shall be eligible to that of Vice-President of the United States.

1
sharkbait76•

At a national convention is where the parties officially pick who will represent them in the national election. It is also when the nominees pick their Vice President. If a nominee is unable to get sufficient votes during the first ballot the delegates will continue to vote until someone gets the vote of half of the total number of delegates.

The delegates are people who've gone to their state convention and voted to be delegates at the national convention. Most delegates are bound to vote for the person who won in their state for at least the first round of votes. If it goes to more than one round most delegates will then be able to vote for whoever they want. This is why picking the delegate is so important. If you can force a contested convention and get most of the delegates to be supporters your in a good position to win.

Super delegates are mostly democrat party insiders. Only the democratic party has super delegates. They are chosen so the party has a chance to have a say in the nominee.

Technically the VP candidate is voted on by the delegates at the convention, just like the Presidential candidate. In reality the presidential candidate usually gets to chose their VP. Since the presidential candidate has already gotten the support of half of the delegates and will represent the party in the general election they usually have the support to pick the VP. It's not good to have a presidential candidate and VP dislike each other as they need to draw people in together. A bad VP candidate can hurt your chances come election time.

The electoral college was supposed to prevent presidential candidates from only visiting large towns. It's supposed to get the candidates to visit all the states. In reality if ends up favoring some states over others. Ohio is a great example of this. It also means that in theory someone could win around 22% of the popular vote and win the election.

If there is a tie in the electoral college the president and VP are chosen by the House and Senate respectively. If this happens the House members for each state get together and decide who their state wants to cast their for. Each state gets only one vote for president and D.C doesn't get a vote. With the VP each Senator receives one vote.

1
cpast•

Question 2: Both major parties have affiliated state parties in all 50 states, as well as affiliates in DC and the territories. These state parties get allocated a certain number of delegates to send to the national convention, along with constraints on how they can have the delegates picked. For both parties, the idea is that state parties should basically select their delegates based on some sort of popular vote process (either a state-run primary or a party-run caucus).

The Democrats do this by specifying in a fair amount of detail how delegates are to be chosen. State party-selected delegates are all pledged to vote for one of the candidates; the delegates themselves are distributed based on the primary or caucus vote in proportion to the percent of people who support each candidate. Actual selection of individual delegates varies somewhat, but to ensure that delegates are not faking their allegiance, anyone trying to become a delegate for a candidate must be approved by their campaign. That's important because the national Democratic rules don't bind delegates to vote for their candidate. They're expected to vote for their pledged candidate on the first convention ballot, but if they decide otherwise, their vote is tallied based on how they actually cast it.

On the Republican side, state parties have more leeway in choosing delegates. Most delegates are bound: they must vote for the candidate they're assigned to on the first ballot (which is based on the popular vote in the state), and even if they don't, it's recorded as if they did. Some state parties don't bind any delegates, though; they can vote however they want.


Superdelegates really exist only on the Democratic side. They're delegates who are not chosen by state parties; they're senior party members who are chosen on the basis of some party or governmental position they hold. State governors who are Democrats are superdelegates; so are current and former Presidents; so are all members of Congress; so are members of the Democratic National Committee (the main national coordinating body between conventions).

Superdelegates aren't just unbound, they're unpledged. They can vote for whoever they want, without the stigma of disregarding a pledge. They aren't chosen based on who they support, they're chosen because they're senior party members and the party wants to give them more weight in the decision. Before 1972, most delegates were unpledged, and the party rank-and-file had little ability to sway the nominee. In 1972 (the first year of the modern primary system), the Democratic rank-and-file nominated a candidate who was far too liberal to do well in an election. He was crushed by Nixon. In the next two elections, senior party people were again unhappy with how the process went. So, they added superdelegates to swing back towards pre-1972 a bit.

Republicans have some unbound delegates where state parties decided to not have bound delegates, but they're not a major factor.


Electoral college: This is mostly a historical oddity. It has only gone differently from the popular vote four times in US history. It's not a huge factor in elections.

That said, here's what it is: There are no nationwide popular elections in the US. The presidential election is no exception. The actual election has just 538 voters, appointed by the states and by DC, roughly in proportion to their population (102 electors are evenly distributed, with 2 per state/DC; 436 are based on population). State governments decide how to appoint their electors.

Every state has decided to use a popular vote to appoint electors. Each candidate (including minor party candidates) submits a list of proposed electors (pledged to that candidate) to the state. In almost all states plus DC, the candidate with the most votes has their full list of proposed electors appointed. These electors are technically able to vote for a candidate other than the one they pledged to. In practice, this has never affected an election in US history. You can in practice ignore that part of the electoral college; even though technically the popular vote doesn't bind the electors, in practice it does.

The effect of the EC is twofold: First, it doesn't matter how much you win a state by. An 80-20 win and a 51-49 win both get you all the electors. Second, because of how they're distributed, smaller states get more electoral votes per person than bigger states. However, in practice this very, very rarely matters.


An absolute majority of the electors are needed to win the Presidency. If there's a tie in the EC, then the lower house of Congress decides. They can only choose from the top three candidates who got electoral votes, and each state gets one vote (regardless of size; California gets the same number of votes as Rhode Island).

1
socially_bereaved•

Someone ELI5 why this wouldn't work:

The Millenial Party Primary.

Primary voting is done on the internet, authenticated by registered voter rolls.

Simple countrywide vote counting system with a deadline.

Top 3 vote getters are vetted to be sure they are elligible for the presidency. Uneligible winners are culled and the next place finisher is vetted.

Once top 3 is settled, there is one YouTube debate. Each candidate gets as much or as little time as needed to answer the top 5 questions, voted on by the party. It is uploaded to You Tube so any person can watch anytime.

Nationwide nomination vote in lieu of party convention or delegates.

Winner goes on the ballot.

1
JustinianImp•

Why it wouldn't work: The last sentence ("Winner goes on the ballot").

Getting someone on the ballot who is not the nominee of an established political party is hard. It's not impossible, but it takes a lot of time, organization, and money. A brand-new party without either an organization or a bunch of money would probably not be able to pull it off.

Now, if you could get someone to pony up a big sum of money to start up this new party for the 2020 election, and spend a couple of years getting state organizations in place so that you'd be able to get on the ballot, well, great. A political party is technically a private club; you can organize your primaries and your nominating process any way the majority of the membership likes. (Well, that's the ELI5 version, anyway; the real answer is more complicated. To take just an obvious example, you couldn't have a primary where only white people or men could vote.)

2
ReddTest314•

Could someone explain how Trump stands any chance of winning this election? Both him and Hillary have rather low approval ratings, but Hillary's are still a lot higher than him. So, with so many people hating his guts and never even considering voting for him compared to Hillary, in what scenario could he arguably win the general election? For that he would need to sway voters to his side, but it looks rather polarized between either loving him or hating him, with very little in between. So unless he already has close to 50% support, how could he gather enough votes to defeat Hillary?

Sorry if this is stupid, I don't live in the US.

1
darexinfinity•

All I can say is that's it's too early to tell. Romney back in 2012 had a real chance of defeating Obama. Not long before the election the "I don't give a shit about half-ish of the people" video came out and he pretty much tanked his chances. A bunch of republicans and some Bernie-bros say that Hillary should be indicted for her e-mail scandal. Some Bernie-bros are turning to Trump, 3rd parties, writing in Bernie in the polls (I hope they're not serious) or not voting at all, which hurts Clinton's numbers.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
mstrd8btr•

These few questions don't pertain to the election process itself, but more of the intricacies.

(1) What do the sponsors do for the Republican/Democratic Convention?

(2) What's the big deal that many major companies, e.g. Wells Fargo, Walgreens, declined to sponsor the RNC?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jameskoss•

So all political questions are banned? That's fucked up seeing as I wasn't asking about politics at all and my question was removed just because I had politics in the writing.

1