Classic Comics ROTJ Question

Discussion

Maybe it's just me misunderstanding the transmissions, but I thought none of the parallels would sell out until the combined total opened reaches 7,500. If you look at Comic #3 in All Cards, Grade 10 is Sold Out. Between the three grades the total card count is just under 7,000. What gives, Topps!?

Posted Jun 16, 2016, 2:15 PM UTC

316
loststarwarsLostStarWars•

At first, I thought the same thing, but reading a bit more closely, the wording of the transmission does actually allow for the parallels to sell out at different times and counts as long as Grade 2 is most common and 10 is rarest.

Between the 3 grades, there will be a total of 7500 copies! Grade 10 will always be the rarest, Grade 5 will be more common, and Grade 2 will be the most common.

3
Numitor453OPZAGYG•

I can't argue with your logic. Still, it's sad that we have to pore over every word like Old Testament scholars to figure out what's going on.

3
loststarwarsLostStarWars•

In all fairness, this particular transmission is one where I think we were reading more into it than was actually there. And of all the miscommunications lately, this one is actually not that bad in my opinion.

Still, I hear you: clarity is definitely not a strong point in this app.

3
Numitor453OPZAGYG•

With their recent history of sloppiness and Topps-ing us, it's easy to jump to conclusions.

I actually really like this set. It reminds me of the fun I had collecting the first series last summer, and the way the parallels are distinguished by condition grades is a great concept. I'm looking forward to the next drop, which is why I was poking around in All Cards.

1
loststarwarsLostStarWars•

Totally, I love the fact that these are hitting just as summer is beginning. It's weird that there's almost a nostalgia already for something that has only been around for a year.

1
nortonindexTheTopTom•

topps cant do math?

1
Numitor453OPZAGYG•

The weird part is that Grade 2 and Grade 5 are not sold out, just the rarest parallel. And it's sold out at 44.

1
piffle213BROKENNAME•

I think you interpreted it correctly, but as they say ... #Toppsed

1
Numitor453OPZAGYG•

My interest in what happens to Grade 10 is purely academic anyway....I'm collecting the bottom parallel. I only checked because I wanted to see how close #3 was to selling out so that Topps can drop the next one.

1
Bluecrakr•

Yeah it's like the grade 10 odds are not as bad as stated.

1
shuajwRandallPinkFlyd•

Did they really need to release RoTJ comic book #2 as the first card, then comic book #4, as the 2nd card, comic book #3 as the third card? Seems unnecessarily confusing.

But as the kids say, YOU'VE BEEN TOPPS'D!!

1
Numitor453OPZAGYG•

At least they show up in All Cards in the correct order.....Classic Comics Series 1 starts with #1, then #10 through #19, then #2, 3, etc.

2
riborsRIBORS•

Yeah, that's a problem with a lot of sets. ESB Illustrated was like that and eventually they fixed it...except for card #100, which follows #10. But good luck in getting them to ever fix Classic Comics S1.

1
riborsRIBORS•

It boggles my mind that they create on the one hand an interesting way to produce a new variant with the different Grades (so clearly someone there had an original idea), but then are so inept that they aren't bothered to announce anything about the set length or if there will be an award. And then there's the releasing of ROTJ out of order :(

2
Anthro_the_HuttHUTTERITE•

My guess is that the whole set would sell out faster if the most valuable version was still pullable. Don't know why Topps would just expire it like that, but they are an inscrutable bunch.

1