Why the GRE doesn't matter as much as you think
howtogetintograduateschool.com/gre/grad-schoo...Posted Jun 20, 2016, 5:26 AM UTC
Posted Jun 20, 2016, 5:26 AM UTC
I think this is true but in a limited extent. Many of the good/best programs do for the mostpart only want students with very good gre scores, and then there are a few sort of remainders who may get in with poor scores.
Wharton and Harvard aren't admitting 155V/155Q applicants.
Now, are there programs that just list the GRE as a requirement because their department or graduate school necessitates it, even if the scores aren't reported to people outside the program? 100% true.
But it is misleading to suggest that they aren't pretty important or that they won't help you, especially if you are suggesting that to students who have the ability to perform better on the test than they've done in the past.
The quality/exclusiveness of graduate programs is often tied to income and employment outcomes (see: law school, as well as http://www.slate.com/articles/life/education/2015/02/university_hiring_if_you_didn_t_get_your_ph_d_at_an_elite_university_good.html) . Thus, I think based on larger social trends (social inequality, cliquishness, pedigree), I think good GRE scores are really vital.
Going to a disreputable school in lieu of a state school, or going to a state school when you could've gone to an elite state school like University of Michigan is a really foolhardy choice .
You are being sorted in life by your gpa and GRE, and since by the time most people take the GRE it is too late to fix your GPA, it is important to do your best on the GRE .Doing better than average cannot hurt, and is better than having it be a factor that detracts from your profile .Also, some schools use the score for scholarships or TA preference, so in theory it can benefit you financially.
Those admissions stories aren't broadly representative, and I would wager that students with better scores, all other factors being the same, would place into better programs.
Scores can in theory be more important if you went to a less known undergrad institution, so in those cases it is more critical to do well .If you had a 4.0 from some unknown/disreputable school, a really solid score validates your narrative that you're worth your salt.
It is true that if you're an average applicant applying at an average state school that pretty much lets many/most applicants in who have above a 3.0 then yeah, but if you're trying to go to a competitive school, scores severely below average will get you a below average chance of success.
It is pretty axiomatic (in programs that both care about gre and have high scores).
The article gives examples in several places that this doesn't apply across the board and that many programs (economics, physics, etc) along with different degree types (masters, MBA, law, PhD) can have very high requisites as far as the GRE is concerned. I'm guessing that you didn't read the article in its entirety. To be fair, in academia the term "graduate school" is usually used exclusively for PhD or masters programs, law and business school are usually referred to as professional programs. Because the professional programs have such higher application rates, the GRE/GMAT/LSAT acts as a very strict cut off and usually determines a lot of financial aid. This doesn't necessary translate to most academic degrees.
The axiom that better anything is...well...better, is taken for granted I think. The point was more about letting other applicants know that an average score doesn't guarantee you a rejection to all top programs, that's all. No where does it say it doesn't matter at all. I think after taking a step back I can see why it might be ill advised to spend months on the GRE and then blow through the rest of the application materials in a couple weeks.
After this I read through a bunch of journal articles that did studies showing how the GRE is a weak indicator of academic performance and graduate success. While it still matters to try your best, clearly not everyone thinks it's the most important element to an application--and many don't seem to care at all. Being aware of that can really help test anxiety and keep students from picking programs based on their GRE results alone.
Again this is mostly applicable to academics, not really business school or law which operates more like medical school.
Good read, this will hopefully help my test anxiety on test day.