Is it better to stick to one professor for two years for research, or is doing work with multiple professors in various subfields good as well?

This is in mathematics. I'm a rising junior doing research this summer. My advisor has already recommended that we present at a conference and publish our results. I was wondering if when it comes to grad school apps, it's better to continue on with the same professor as long as possible or if it's just as good to diversify and do work in several subfields. I was hoping this would show a wide breadth of knowledge and adaptability, as well as a good deal of experience and experimentation with possible interests, though in truth I really just want to do work in all kinds of things.

Posted Jul 3, 2016, 6:54 AM UTC

812
dweed4PhD* Immunology/Infectious Diseases•

If you are productive in one place I would not leave for another. Getting presentations/publications are way more important than multiple labs.

6
0102030405•

I agree with the other commenters, that you need to learn enough to get more responsibility and that often comes with staying in the same lab. For example, I started working in a lab right before my second year and I became the lab manager the year later, went to multiple international conferences, and I'm working on a publication on top of mentoring other students in that lab. I worked in other labs during this time, but I never reached the same level of responsibility and understanding as the lab I had been in for the longest.

You can demonstrate a breadth of knowledge and adaptability through other things like classes, or with a small stint in another lab alongside this one (like in the summer when you might have more time). With a good lab experience and a great mentor, you should be able to work on multiple projects, so that might satisfy your interest in working on multiple topics.

6
SpddinPhD Student Cancer Bio•

Personally, I think the depth of knowledge you get from one lab is more valuable than having multiple experiences. This comes with presentations and publications, but you also tend to get more productive the more time you spend on a project.

3
uzbyte•

Depth and Breadth is always the dream. If you have to choose between the two, ask yourself if you're 100% behind your current research subfield. If you want to stay in that area, don't leave. If you hate what you're doing and know you want to venture out into different areas, breadth will probably enable you to do that more easily.

2
VioletCrowOP•

I don't hate what I'm doing right now, I'm having fun. But I do think there's a good chance I would enjoy other subfields more.

1
uzbyte•

Some people will disagree with me, but I'd say getting some broad experience is a good idea if that's the case. Undergraduate is where (at least hypothetically) you're supposed to figure out what you want to study in grad school. You can't do that unless you try several things. The upside is that you can point that out on your SoP down the line, e.g. "I gained a lot of valuable experience working in group theory but ultimately found that my talent and interest lies with information theory".

My disclaimer-- if you're deciding between an exclusive [OR]: publishing OR varied experience, any responsible person will tell you to publish. This is true even if you know you're going to apply to Art History PhD programs in a year. It's always better to have a publication under your belt, esp in pure math where the funding is sadly non-existent. If you can publish with this person and then move on for a year after that though, that would be my advice (as an applied math PhD).

2
VioletCrowOP•

Well we're already working on a manuscript, so publishing isn't a problem. I really like working with this guy though, so if I work with someone else, I'll probably be planning to come back to him once I'm finished. Does that seem like a good plan?

1
uzbyte•

To be honest that sounds like a perfect situation. You have concrete research locked down with this guy, get to explore some different interests for awhile but don't shut the door on him forever. This is the epitome of a "good" application: exploratory yet published. Adcoms (depending on the program) will usually smile on someone who admits they wanted to try several things. It helps convince them that you know what you want to do in grad school and aren't a "I came to grad school to find myself" applicant. Good luck! :)

2
Childplz112•

You should have at least one experience in another lab. I say this because it shows that you can function in different environments. Additionally you will have another recommendation from a PI. I had two PI and my cell bio teacher when I applied. I am now a first year PhD student at my number one institution.

It's not necessary but it adds to your profile as opposed to harming you. I agree that if you can get publications and present in your current lab you should be fine when it come time to apply. Also publications arent necessary.

2
VioletCrowOP•

Yeah I'm thinking I'll do some work with another professor for a bit in the future, and then return to working with my professor now. He goes out of town quite a bit, so there might even be a time where I have to do so :P.

1