r/DnD•
-MM-

Wanted - ideas how to encourage and hook a less than classical party of goody-two-shoes

Hi guys! First time posting, first time DMing.

My new party of PCs is about to come into contact with the skeleton-of-a-campaign I've prepared. I purposefully didn't flesh out the story - rather, I prepared a world and populated it with power struggle by making several organizations (mostly evil and selfish ranging from world-ending ambitions to mundane power and greed). Some of these evil and "evil" organizations are at odds, others synergize.

I did also prepare some hierarchies of power on the lawful / good side of human society.

So there's an overarching political theme of a power-vacuum and waves rushing from each side to fill it, with the mundane rat-killing, cow-fetching party of new players in the middle.

The challenge is that my new players didn't roll an exactly typical party. While they luckily didn't get hung up on alignments, it's descriptive enough for my question when I say that my party consists of :

  • 1x Chaotic Good

  • 2x Chaotic Neutral

  • 1x True Neutral

  • 1x Lawful Evil (Paladin)

While not exactly murderhobos (luckily - or yet), they've not been averse to strong-arm tactics and manipulation in quests that were about doing good and helping people.

I don't think I've a problem at my hands, just a challenge.

The idea is/was that each organization in the world will do one thing or another depending on whether players interfere, but I would do well to accommodate for more grey in-between options.

How would I go about incorporating grey-area plot hooks alongside the good-natured ordinary folk requesting the adventurers aid? There's a redeeming quality to the party in that they do still want to help people and can be classically motivated, as well. They're just picky about who is deserving of their help and at what price. Orphans and kittens be damned.

So how to plan for the possibility that players might want to help thieves or insurgents or guerrillas or foreign agents that were originally planned to be opponents? (Orcs and world-eating dragons they naturally oppose - at least.)

TL:DR: How to efficiently prepare for the possibility that players want to help rather than oppose a certain force and vice versa?

Posted Jul 5, 2016, 10:17 AM UTC · edited

16
ElvenoobWarlock•

Well, the simplest idea I have for subverting it, or at least giving yourself time to see the hints of this developing in some of the PCs, and which faction these hints is directed towards, is to have one of your mid-level assholes piss them off by, say, hiring them for a job and then double-crossing them, he's an asshole so the CG guy won't object to all the neutrals or the evil lopping off his head to call it quits, and so you let them work towards killing him for the first 5 or so levels and then see how things are going then...

Not to mention, this guy who pisses them off can be a representative, of moderately high rank, in one faction, so when the PCs kill the first antagonist, that pits this one faction directly against the PCs...

4
-MM-OP•

Good idea. They're low level now and new-arrivals - nobodies in nowhere. But certainly as soon as they step on a plots accidentally I can have someone take notice and show up to test them / double-cross them.

They've got a good nose for deus- and devil-ex-machina, but sure it won't be too obvious to put them face to face with a personality they reaaally probably won't like and use it put them on at least one sort-of-planned feud.

Thanks!

3
Euphorbus11•

I have a few ideas, but they all centre around getting the players to care about a personality then discover their organisations ties. Something like these:

Adreana - Professional Thief and robin hood character

A female thief who steals from the rich and feeds urchins who have been orphaned by the law (sons and daughters of criminals and the executed) the rest of her organisation may not be as good as her, but to help her keep these children safe and healthy they must align themselves (at least to some degree) with this criminal underground. The children will not willingly go with the lawful good side, blaming them for their parents situations and the poverty of the slums they seem to be unable to help.

Sentient rats!

Here me out on this, awaken one giant rat on their "rat killing" mission and call him the rat king. He is striving to awaken his people and create a safe haven away from the harsh life of being hunted and killed. A member of one of the evil organisations awakened him in a hope that he would make the sewers more dangerous for the good population and a few of the good factions want to kill them because of the real danger to young children the still wild giant rats pose. It's a grey area as a) you don't know who to trust b) there have already been casualties from the giant rats and c) they are striving to live a different life but more are not awakened and moving them from the sewers would be a mammoth (or at least giant rat) task.

Hope these help or at least spark some ideas :)

2
-MM-OP•

Definitely! Mind if I steal Adreana? What an awesome idea!

The rats are a thing of the past for my party, but I can definitely use the same inversion later where a brutish race has been employed by a pretty-face evil.

Most of all you, too, gave me the kick I've known I need to receive: I need to stop fussing about and create more prominent and memorable NPCs and give them enough stage time for the party to care for then.

1
Euphorbus11•

Sure may Adreana give you many sessions of material! :D

Glad I could help.

2
jaggededge13•

Have a noble offer them money to do such and such. "Make it worth their while" so to speak. Thats the best way to get a mostly chaotic mostly neutral party to work.

With true neutral it can be hard to find hooks. Depends on how they play it. Ive played it once and i was an agent of balance. If i saw too much evil (massive assault on a city and a city being overrun) i would strike the assaulters. But if the city then wanted to strike back and wipe out their aggressor, i would switch sides. If they're playing and "i don't care" approach, then idk. Its probably tough.

2