Akerlof•

Can you explain what you mean by " big enough to explain a lot of our increasingly dire circumstances today"? Both how the debate explains today's circumstances and how today's circumstances are dire?

Modern macroeconomics practiced by those who advise policy makers is mostly either DSGE or atheoretical statistical models. (That's a link to a pdf download from the Philadelphia Federal Reserve Bank.) The Solow growth model and Cobb-Douglas production function (in macro, at least) are primarily used for illustrating basic principles to undergraduates anymore. There is debate around the value of DSGE models, especially since a lot of them don't include a financial sector, but right now they do a better job of describing the economy and trying to forecast the effects of changes than the alternatives.

As for the Marxian critique of profits as extraction of value by those with power rather than the neo classical view that profits are effectively the wages paid to capital rather than to labor... That's a complex subject. For example, one of the issues is the capital share of income, which is the amount of income that goes to capital owners. In the US this has been increasing for 20 or so years, rising from 28% to about 40%. This would comport with the Marxist critique that capital owners have power to extract rents from workers. On the other hand, it turns out that most of that increase is due to how the capital share is counted: Increases in housing prices are counted as capital income for homeowners. So the increase in the capital share of income is due pretty much entirely to the value of homes increasing, while the ratio of income going to labor and the people who own the means of production is pretty steady. This supports the neoclassical view.

2