How would you nerf Cloud?
First and foremost, I am NOT suggesting Cloud NEEDS to be nerfed at all. Moreover this is not a discussion about WHETHER he needs to be nerfed. I am a Cloud main, so of course I do not want to see him get hit. Really I just want to know what aspects of Cloud are particularly broken, rather than just people complaining about him in general. Second, a wall of text is incoming.
I'm relatively new to the game (started playing in tourneys 3-4 months ago), and can tell you that while Cloud is good, I haven't been able to just pick him up and win tournaments. He is definitely one of the best characters, if not the best, but I feel people really underplay just how exploitable his weaknesses are. His recovery is predictable and doesn't snap to ledge, which is what most people talk about, but what I'm surprised most people don't mention is his terrible grab game. He has pretty much no guarantees out of grab, its slow, his pummel is slow and weak, making staying in shield a very safe option against him. And although he can capitalize on unsafe opponents quite well, he has very few true combos or guaranteed kills when compared to most of the top tier.
I feel it is also not quite as clear cut exactly how to hit him, as it was with Bayonetta where the goal was simply to stop the guaranteed 0-death combos (o got hit with dtilt? nice stock u had there).
All that being said, I feel there are several ways to hit him that would bring him down to a more fair level. These include reducing the power of his ridiculous aerial game or hitting Limit in some fashion:
1) Nair hit - this move is pretty insane. The range, the speed, the safety all make it really appealing and a go to move for Clouds. Could be nerfed a number of ways, making it come out a few frames later, have more ending lag, reduce the hitbox.
2) Dair hit - this move is great at punishing opponents, and has many many follow-ups from a FH AC weak hit of dair. Getting hit by a weak hit of dair can easily lead to 30-40% damage, if not outright getting killed. Dair stays out for a very long time and covers a good amount of space (although it does leave Cloud exposed from the sides). One way to nerf it would be actually increase the knockback off the weak hit so Cloud doesn't have as many follow-ups. Other ways would be to reduce damage output, decrease its range or decrease the amount of time it stays out.
3) Uair - One of Cloud's best juggling tools, this move can link into itself at low percents, kill off the top relatively early, and has a large, long lasting hitbox. Probably would reduce the hitbox and decrease the amount of time its active. Possibly change so it doesn't link into itself a low percentage on pretty much every character.
4) Limit Charge - Many people complain about having to deal with Limit so much. Cloud can easily put Limit on deck multiple times per stock, and camp out on platforms especially vs slower characters. Limit helps eliminate his glaring recovery weakness, while pressuring the opponent to play safer. I think the most logical thing here would be to substantially increase the time to charge limit, maybe like 10 seconds instead of 7.
5) Limit Cross Slash - Cloud's go to Limit move. The initial hitbox that comes out for this move is pretty huge, and touch the first two hitboxes traps you. Probably the simplest way to deal with this move would be decreasing the hitbox and damage output.
6) Hits to his dash speed, weight, etc - He is quite heavy considering he is a skinny, relatively small dude. I guess its that's buster sword grounding him, but I could see a few weight points actually being taken off. He also is one of the fastest dashers in the game, and making him slower would definitely hurt his mobility and punishes.
I am sure there are more ways you could go about nerfing Cloud. If you have other suggestions for nerfs I would like to hear them. More than anything I want to generate discussion about what people find unfair about him. I want to implement these things in a tournament setting to better me as a player. I want to do more of the broken things while its still guaranteed I can and understand why he is truly the best in the game (if he is).
TL;DR Cloud is an amazing character with a lot, possibly too many great tools at his disposal. Which of those tools make Cloud a notch above the rest (if he is)? What is unfair about him? And how would you go about making him more balanced?
Posted Jul 13, 2016, 6:33 PM UTC · edited