Lanterns

For PC edition

I know that Mojang has tested these out before and decided against them, but I feel that this would be a nice little addition to the game. These lanterns would be small, handheld items that emit light not only when placed but also when in either hand. I have thought of two different crafting recipes, either of which (or both) could be used.

The first recipe is: An iron ingot in both the top middle and bottom middle of the crafting grid, a torch in the center, and iron bars or glass panes (any color) on either side of the torch.

The second recipe is: An iron ingot in both the top middle and bottom middle of the crafting grid and a redstone lamp in the center.

Both recipes would yield 4 lanterns, and could be placed anywhere torches can be placed plus the ceiling. Additionally, the redstone version could work the same way as a regular redstone lamp.

Posted Jul 20, 2016, 10:52 PM UTC

65
BlackEyedGhost•

It would be nice to have a light-emitting item of any kind for map makers even if it's only accessible with commands or in creative. I think they decided against it because it causes the lighting to update constantly for a number of blocks, and that's just bad news on multiplayer servers.

3
576875•

though they would have to solve the problem of adding in dynamic lighting. It would cause lots of issues for players who don't have the latest and greatest PCs

1
s0i5l3a1sEnderman•

this is why /light needs to be added. but lighting updates could mess it up

1
The_Dragonn_29•

They've tested dynamic lighting with torches, and didn't like the effect. Portable light sources aren't going to be added.

1
IceMetalPunkSpider•

As mentioned, having light sources at fractional coordinates is impossible in the current lighting engine, and having ones that move with an entity cause so many lighting updates that they're far too laggy. Even the new Optifine option for dynamic lighting is only client-side because it's just not practical to make it work genuinely.

1