Using both a race and a standard descriptor, balance?
Hi all, I'm just now getting into Numenera, and have been perusing the corebook. One thing that bothers me a little is the way races are handled in the game. The racial descriptions even point out that personality and such can vary on an individual basis, so why can't a Varjellen be strong, or clever?
Of course, straight-up taking both a non-human race and a regular descriptor could be a bit overpowered.
So I'm thinking, if you want to take both an alternate race and a regular descriptor, you would have to subtract 1 point from each of your type's base stats~~, and remove 1 or 2 of your freely assignable stat points. Instead of having 6 freely assignable stat points, you would have only 4. Or, if you're a Varjellen, you would only have 1 extra point, instead of 3~~.
If you want to be, say, a mutant Varjellen, but do not want to also use a standard descriptor, that would be treated the same way as above. But if you want to be a mutant Varjellen and also use a standard descriptor, then you would need to balance out all of your beneficial mutations with harmful ones.
Does that sound like a good balanced way to handle it? And should Lattimors get separate descriptors for each state, or just a single descriptor?
I'm not even planning to play an alternate race for my first character, but I like the idea of them, and may wish to play one in the future.
Edit: Misremembered how many stats regular descriptors affect, so I crossed out a section of the above. I was thinking descriptors added +4 to a stat, but it's just +2.
Posted Jul 24, 2016, 6:24 AM UTC · edited
Honestly, I would sperate rp and mechanics. The games character building rules are a great jumping off point for rp, but just because you're varjellen doesn't mean you are or aren't clever. Do you need the in game bonuses to accomplish a character concept? I would probably lean to no.
I would say a descriptor would be the most obvious thing about you that seperate you from a farmer. If you aren't human than that is going to be the first thing that comes to mind.
If you need a descriptor for everything you want your character to be than you could easily attack half of them on most characters. Anything you get from a descriptor you can probably get from skills or in game rewards. I would let your gm know your priorities and let them get it to you.
Not trying to go negative, but adding something like this to one character, meaning everyone getting double descriptors is a far reaching change and sounds a bit like meta-gaming.
This. The descriptors are meant to help enable RP, but they aren't the be all, end all. Just like having a low Intellect score doesn't mean you're an idiot, not having the "clever" description doesn't mean you're not clever.