Game Theory Redux: Vault Breaking and Reinforcements
My post yesterday garnered a fair degree of controversy, which was of course my intention.
To all the people who responded to how it wasn't 'at all' like the Prisoners Dilemma, you focused on the wrong thing. It wasn't supposed to be a direct analogy.
Let me phrase this differently: The purpose of reinforcing your stuff is to protect it from raiders or people on the other side of a war. The best possible protection for this is the 'Best' reinforcement type. However, as ShadedJon pointed out, due to maturation whoever starts breaking a vault or raiding a town will instantly win and get your stuff, unless you can fight them off.
The difference between Best and Good reinforcement types is 500 breaks, or a 33% increase in time spent from Good to Best. However, the cost of said upgrade is 300% or more. Good reinforcements take 4 strong miner and 4 strong hunter components. Best reinforcements take 12 of each, plus a bunch of XP. Obviously, these costs are intended to be cut over time, but regardless, there is a decrease in the marginal utility that one would receive from said upgrade. And in particular, fights are more determined by PvP skill than ever. If you cannot defend yourself in the first place, you are doomed regardless.
*So why would you spend the inordinate amount of time that it would take to get the 'Best' reinforcement tier if you are going to be destroyed anyways? To buy time? Irrelevant. Time doesn't matter if no matter what you do, you're screwed. At best, it's a little bit of insurance if your community is just relatively inactive and can defend itself, but it just isn't around when the raid is occurring. But even still, the raiders can just pull back and continue raiding when you go offline next, because of maturation. *
"But bg, people worked together to make XP!"
Yes, but individual groups were also capable of doing this. Chanada produced XP by itself, as did /pol/ynesia and that was without the heavy use of bots by the end. In 2.0, there were lots of botters who had tons and tons of surplus materials that could easily be traded. They didn't need to cooperate, it was just slightly more efficient to do so and so they did. They had infinite wealth and infinite supplies due to their bots, they had no actual need to cooperate, it just gave them an edge in utility due to mass production. That won't apply here, without bots.
"But bg, those who cooperate would get an advantage over those who don't cooperate!"
Yes, but as I said before, the PvP and XP changes ensure that the biggest groups are also the largest PvP powers (mostly). This means that the only people capable of producing the large amounts of materials necessary to even start cooperating on reinforcements are also the people most likely to be your rivals. The United States didn't cooperate with the USSR and China to go to the moon. England didn't cooperate with France to build it's navy. If you can't do it yourself, why would you help your main rivals to both get to the same position you were before? The little nations aren't a threat anyways and if you can't do it yourself, why do it at all if doing it would only ensure that you and your main rivals would end up on the same level yet again?
"Oh, but people will still do it as raid insurance! What about an invasion?"
Not when the marginal utility drops off so quickly. Why would you put in literally three times the work, three times the hours, three times the player base to upgrade from Good to Best reinforcement levels of production, just to have your vault broken in 6 hours instead of 4? ShadedJon has done the numbers, any vault can be busted in six hours. So why would you put in three times the effort just to have a product that is better by 1/3? That is a dramatic decrease in the marginal utility of the upgrade, especially when a vault break means doom for those who can't defend themselves anyways.
tl;dr: Disregarding game theory, marginal utility and increasing grinding ensures that it is (almost) never worth it to upgrade, beyond giving a little bit of insurance. The only groups who it would be worth it for are groups of small but good PvPers who can actually defend their stuff, but aren't always online to do so.
Posted Jul 24, 2016, 3:31 PM UTC
Looking at the vault costs, you wouldn't build an entire vault out of 'best' reinforcements. You'd have a few layers of 'best', a couple layers of 'good' and a shitetone of bracers.
Also the point of a large vault is so that you will have time to rally. If the HCF WB vault in 1.0 was only 8 layers someone would definitely have been able to break it while the HCF'ers were in kindergarten during the day.
Furthemore vaults are a symbol of your e-penis. Cubic costs in 2.0 didn't stop anyone from building 50 layer vaults despite there being close to zero marginal utility.
^ well said
Ah yes, the Minecraft phenomenon where people will waste time and resources for the sole purpose of increasing the size of their e-peen. I call it the "Factions Phenomenon".
Looking a a 2.0 upload recently I was impressed at 3k,3ks e-peen, only a 30 layer but stunningly autistic scale of nerd rings.
Rings in vaults now do the job of giving you time better than a large vault could.