r/TheSilphRoad•
02m

Which Snorlax to focus on, need help

Hey There.

I have two Snorlax from 10km eggs, and I would like to get some advice on which one to fill with candy.

Snorlax 1:

IV's:

LVLATTDEFSTMRANK
18.514151495.6%
18.515131493.3%

Moves: Lick + Earthquake

Snorlax 2:

IV's:

LVLATTDEFSTMRANK
20.010141177.8%
20.011121175.6%
20.012101173.3%
20.01381171.1%

Moves: Lick + Bodyslam

Snorlax 1 has much better IVs, but Snorlax 2 has the better 2nd attack. Which one is better overall in your opinion?

In advance, thanks for your time!

Posted Jul 24, 2016, 5:51 PM UTC

011
The_Desert_RainProfessor Hickory•

My opinion: focus on snorlax 1. Why? Because he has Lick. Snorlax with Lick is amazing. Yes his second attack isn't optimal, however your second attack is not used nearly as much as your fast attack. Many attackers don't use it at all. Focusing on that snorlax will also help you to reach better cp levels that the other one couldn't hit. But that's my personal opinion.

1
02mOP•

Thank you very much for your reply! That was also my conclusion. I rarely use special attacks (only if super-effective). The biggest reason I am concerned with Snorlax 1, is his role as a gym-defender, where he will be using his special, whether i like it or not.

1
Maverickmp•

Body slam is better. Plus you get +stab. Lick=20dps body slam is 34dps+STAB. Snorlax 2 will beat snorlax 1 given equal CP.

1
wasniahC•

Yeah, but snorlax 1 might beat it with equal level, with equal dust/candy spent on upgrading it, and at max level.

I'm not sure though. Might be close.

1
Maverickmp•

okay let me revise this a bit, both snorlax's at max CP, snorlax 2 should still win because of body slam even though snorlax 1 will have a higher CP due to it's better IV's.

1
wasniahC•

I think the body slam one is better too, especially after running the numbers a bit myself - I agree with that. I disagree with the "given equal CP" part though - the fact is, one's CP is less limited than the other, so that's a misleading point :P

But yeah, just to clarify, I do agree with the conclusion

1
wasniahC•

My personal calculations bring the overall dps of lick+eathquake to 20.11 on snorlax, and the lick+body slam combo's dps is at 26.07.

So.. snorlax's base stats are 320/180/180. You can either add an extra 5 or so to each of those, or you can get moves that do 30% more dps.

I'd take snorlax number 2, easy. The higher a pokemon's base stats are, the less relative difference the IVs make, and snorlax has very high base stats. You're at 75% or so IVs anyway, that is still high above average. Body slam makes a very big difference.

Earthquake takes 100 energy, has 60 power, and has a cast time of 4.2s.

Body slam takes 50 energy, has 50 power, and has a cast time of 1.56s. And gets STAB. I don't know why everybody focuses on the DPS gain of lick and ignores how ridiculously strong body slam is.

1
Maverickmp•

body slam is one of the best special attacks in the game, one of the few that actually do more DPS than lick.

1
wasniahC•

I will say one thing - all of snorlax's specials do have at least a slight DPS increase over lick. Earthquake and the other one I can't remember the name of right now are both significantly less than body slam though, yes

1
Maverickmp•

http://www.pokemongodb.net/2016/05/snorlax.html

the only one that does more DPS than lick is body slam.. its not worth it to use the others over lick. Even Hyper beam + STAB (x1.25) does not do more unfortunately. Its kind of sad that the game is so poorly balanced atm.

1
wasniahC•

Doublechecked my spreadsheets and why my numbers were showing something a bit different

Looks like essentially, hyper beam can at times be useful depending on the type of the enemy, but yes, in a typical matchup, it's always better to spam lick. And earthquake is indeed always worse, my bad.

Your DPS against average enemy spamming lick is 20.11. Using hyper beam against enemies lick is bad against, you go up to 20.2 DPS against average enemy, and using body slam, 26.07.

1