Is dropping out of med school for a less secure job a bad idea?

I posted this on the front page thread asking what people needed to get off their chest, but it occurred to me that I might be able to get some advice on reddit and I found career guidance. Apologies in advance that this is super long. It started because I just wanted to get it out.

Basically I'm lost. I'm torn between totally changing career paths and sticking with the one I'm on which is meh. Right now I'm a medical student in one of the to 5 med schools. I worked hard, ivy league undergrad blah blah and all that. It was a lot of work to get here. Its like I've climbed a ladder but I think I may have climbed the wrong one.

Before starting med school I took a year off to work and had an amazing time doing research full time at NASA. Science is fun, not only is it a way for a single person to contribute to society at large in a lasting/permanent way, but also every day progress is made. Even if its slow there is a finish line, a result, a publication - and that is great motivation to come in to work. I told myself though that going to med school doesn't mean giving up research. There's plenty of physicians who do both clinic (see patients) and biomedical research, and maybe I could even come back to NASA someday. Ok great. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized clinical medicine kinda isn't for me. Its like running on a treadmill. People come in, you treat them, the next person comes in. There isn't progress, it's more like a list of tasks. In that case the motivation to come in every day is just to knock down that list and take your sweet paycheck. Realistically that is a factor for some people, and I should in theory be thankful for the chance to make a good living, many people aren't so lucky. But at the same time, I feel like I want my work to not feel like work- even if the pay is good. I'd rather my job feel like a hobby because in the end you spend 30 years doing it and giving up that much of my life for good pay seems like a steep deal. Maybe I'm looking at it the wrong way. But, add onto that 60k tuition/year all as a loan and I'm feeling pretty trapped. With undergrad and my first year of med school I have 100k in debt right now. I feel like the only real way to pay that off is to finish the next 3 years of med school (60k each) then residency (+4 years with 55k stipend and 80 hrs/week) then become an attending and make the big bucks (250k ish) just to pay off my debt. It sounds stupid but the only way to pay it off is to get more debt. And who knows, maybe I do find a way to balance medicine and research. Here we have docs doing work on nanotechnology, stem cells, and all kinds of cool stuff. I spoke with one (MD only, not MD/PhD) who does 90% research 10% clinic. He got tired of writing endless notes, rounding, and running on that treadmill.

If I were to pick right now though, I would just go straight into science - and the more I think about it, I wouldn't even pick biomedical science. Although that is my background from undergrad and I enjoyed the biophysics research I did at NASA, if I were to just truly say "fuck it I'm going to be a scientist", I might as well go with what I'm most interested in, and that is space. I'm currently volunteering in an Astrophysics lab part time and it's pretty awesome. Identifying elements in far away stars doesn't add value to anyone's life but fuck me its cool to just think about the vast distances, crazy physics, and all that... So maybe I drop out of med school and do this. Get an astronomy PhD, do a postdoc for 3 years, do another post doc, then hopefully get tenure some place. Except post doc pay is shit, and the job market for tenure is pretty terrible. Plus- just like with medicine maybe in a few years my bright eyed amazement with astronomy turns into the same bored disinterest I feel towards clinical medicine, then I'd just be doubly fucked because I still have all these loans, got a shit paying job, and don't even like it anymore. Maybe I'm too far into my head but anyway that's my rant. It felt good to get off my chest in that other post and maybe someone has some wise words after reading all that mess.

Posted Jul 25, 2016, 5:10 AM UTC

57
Loading comments…