If honeybees are non-native to North America, won't the original (or other) pollinators flourish and fill in the gaps left behind by the decreasing population?

Earth Sciences

I'm assuming the original pollinators weren't completely displaced by the invasive european honeybee, but even then the other pollinators' populations will expand without competition from those bees. I haven't been able to find any articles addressing this whenever bee population articles come up.

Posted Jul 27, 2016, 9:28 PM UTC

2315
phaseoptics•

Apparently it's a bit of a myth that honey bees are non-native. But that could just be a red herring and I get your point.

This online handbook on insect pollination of cultivated crops mentions the loss of native pollinating insects. So does this article. So it's not just honey bees that we are losing, but all insect pollinators. It's a "pollination crisis" not just a honey bee crisis.

12
svarogteuse•

14-million-old fossil

Honey bees (and neararctica is not identical to what most people think of the Western honey bee) died out in North America just like camels and horses. Both of those originated on the continent but by the time European settlers arrived had vanished.

2
CheeseFace81•

Do you have any ideas for a solution to this crisis? How can this be reversed? No pollinators = no people

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
spondyloOP•

the second link is ~850 pages and I couldn't find anything about native pollinators decreasing with my search terms other than about blueberries in maine in the 1960's. The 3rd article is very informative but contradicts the non-native part of the 1st. After reading the 3rd article a good argument could be made that large commercial beekeeping operations resulting in proliferation of disease and mites and africanization are the major hurdles here. GMO and pesticides seems like kind of a scapegoat since we've been doing that for so long it is unlikely changes in pesticide use is going to put a dent in the problem.

I can see that the european honeybee was introduced in the first place because native pollinators were inadequate for non-staple crops (we aren't going to starve to death, just less diversity in food as they become unaffordable).

We get so much of our insect pollinated fruit from Mexico, chile and other central/south american countries who have much less oversight than the US, I wonder how they have overcome the fact they have been africanized since the 90's and use a lot more pesticide? Something isn't adding up (unless the US is patient 0 for diseases from commercial beekeeping operations).

edit: in the 3rd article it seems the US is patient 0 for the mites which africanized bees are immune to. So africanization may actually be the reason central and south america lacks the problems we have despite using GMO and more pesticides.

1
svarogteuse•

large commercial beekeeping operations resulting in proliferation of disease and mites

Some 80% of the managed beehives in America congregate in California for almond every year then disperse across the country only to return again the next year. They are not responsible so much for Africanization. Commercial beekeepers do a good job keeping European stock and queens. Africanization is spread by feral populations.

that the european honeybee was introduced in the first place because native pollinators were inadequate for non-staple crops

They were first introduced for the wax particularly in candles for the church, secondarily for honey. Using bees directly for pollination purposes did not become a thing until the 1800s. Most stable crops for the early settlers which were grains do not require bees for pollination they are wind pollinated.

have overcome the fact they have been africanized since the 90's

Africanized bees can be just as effective as European ones at pollination. They just have to be managed differently, hives isolated on separate stands, lots more smoke, kept further away from the general public. Other countries are not operating on Americas migratory beekeeping model. The model is still a local small apiary that pollinates everything in the area year round as it was here back before the 50s or so.

and use a lot more pesticide

Pesticide is not the problem for honey bees.

it seems the US is patient 0 for diseaes from commercial operations

No it isn't. Varroa first crossed from apis cerana to apis mellifera in East Asia among Russian bees. The spread west across Russia into Europe by the 60s, Western Europe by the early 80s and the US in 1987.

Honey bee diseases and pests that have become a problem in recent times (Tracheal mites, Varroa and the dozen or so accompanying virus they carry, Small Hive Beetles, Nosema Cerana) have all come from overseas.

Africanized bees are not immune. They do handle varroa better than European colonies for a number of reasons. They are more aggressive in grooming removing mites from adult bees. They tend to have a shorter pupal stage which limits mites growth (50-90% of the mites in a hive are in capped pupal cells), the tend to swarm more often producing broodless periods which the mites are less tolerant of.

Again as I stated before the number of managed bee colonies are not not the decline. The State of Florida is recording 32 new colonies for ever 30 that it loses as of the last talk I saw from Dr. Ellis (UF honey bee lab). GMO crops are in no way harming bees, if any thing they are beneficial since they genes target specific non-hymenoptera insects which means less general purpose insecticide being sprayed that harms bees. We may be using more pesticide but that is also because we grow more food. Much of that pesticide is on non-pollinated crops (wheat, corn, some soybeans) and is not harming bees, its harming native pollinators by killing them directly or eliminating the weeds that they feed on.

seems like kind of a scapegoat since we've been doing that for so long it is unlikely changes in pesticide use is going to put a dent in the problem

Yes they are. The scientists in the industry are not blaming either for the problems with managed bees.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
phaseoptics•

On the second link, do a find on "native pollinating insects". It's on page 7.

You are totally right I think. The European honey bee is able to effectively pollinate the food crops that we now almost exclusively grow in near mono-culture. The native pollinators, even if they too weren't in decline, couldn't keep up with agricultural demand.

Mites alone? I think nothing really happens so simply in biology. A systemic response to so many parameters probably. What can be done? Maybe controlling the mite parameter could put the system back into quasi-stable equilibrium.

1
spondyloOP•

thanks for your posts

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

Bee populations are decreasing but so are the number of what we consider "weeds" that support their population. It's not as simple as a species in decline. There are additional factors that contribute to the problem.

1
w_spark•

I recall hearing a piece on the NPR radio show Radiolab about how Chinese apple growers found that when they hired humans to pollinate their trees (using paint brushes to spread pollen around), yields substantially increased. Honeybees are cheap, but relatively inefficient. So it was determined that the added cost was washed out by the boost in yield, and human-pollinated apples were no more expensive than bee-pollinated apples.

But that's China, where labor is inexpensive.

1
DesignDevolution•

Its possible they would, but it might take a while for species to adjust to the new gap in the ecosystem and to start harvesting the pollen and pollinating. I wonder if they will adapt(if bees really do die out) but after we have come up with another solution or lots of people have died. There was a drama recently about it on the radio where they were developing little drones too pollinate the plants but Atm this wouldn't work at all.

1