[Arc] Why is the base commodity sell limit 20k when the best methods are 1-1.2k/hr?

Seems like it would take 16-20 hours just to hit this arbitrary cap, making it basically unnecessary (and the upgrade even more so). Plus the comp req is about 20k chimes in total, so the only thing it's limiting is making bonk chimes (somehow) for long voyages?

Maybe this has already been addressed elsewhere, or there's something I'm just not seeing. Someone enlighten me?

Posted Jul 28, 2016, 4:59 AM UTC · edited

3925
TheRealXlXl•

Because jagex cant balance shit l8ly.

49
DemonScarf•

honestly chimes need to be at least 3k an hour and voyages need to be better.

25
Hello_ChariOPRSN: Charizards, Shaymin•

Yea, with the amount of fishing this is taking me, it's basically the aquarium comp req all over again. And the uncharted isle rewards are whelming. I don't really have incentives to go on long voyages more than once either, since I can only claim 1 island and it costs 1250 chimes to get there.

8
Lumos_Ninja•

whelming

"Can you ever just be whelmed?"

10
CON3ZRSN: Zachar y Ironman: Crota (98k Terracotta)•

Maybe, but can you Crash the Mode?

3
unburntmotherofdrags2534/2595•

Such a shame that show got cancelled.

2
getstabbedRSN: Armour•

One thought I had is that there's warriors wearing port gear on these islands. Why not give them a chance to drop plates etc? That would give a reason to explore more islands and a reward that doesn't only apply to the arc. It's not like it's low level content so it should be reasonably easy to balance.

5 supply islands should have a low chance at finding these warriors and 25 supply islands should have a very high chance.

2
voltsigo•

I had a few ideas for Uncharted Isles.

  1. Give them the rare chance to drop relevant port resources.
  • Tormented Souls = Ancient Bones (plus excavate the bone "plot" for 1 more?)
  • Gu Ronin = Tetsu Armor Piece --> Processed into Plate (new merchant?)
  • Death Lotus Rogue = DL Patch --> Processed into Lacquer
  • Flying Jellyfish = Jelly Oil? New rare Waiko resource perhaps (not ports)?
  • Crassian Scout/Warrior = Pearls + Koi Scales
  • Eastern Soldier = Spices?
  • Seasinger Priestess = Seasinger Patch --> Processed into Chi Globes
  1. Guarantee a certain minimum size. My first large island is smaller than my first small island ....
  2. Add guaranteed (standard) fishing locations on all islands.

I feel like this would make Uncharted Isles a bit more attractive.

5
getstabbedRSN: Armour•

Exactly. It's a perfect opportunity that they somehow completely ignored. At current there's literally no reason to go to these islands except XP rates that are either below the best or complete outright terrible and chimes. This is level 90+ content so it's a pretty big deal.

2
dfbpurcell•

it all comes down to "how can we trick people into thinking they are working towards something which is actually nothing so they keep paying for membership"

5
Shadow_Drive85M/120M•

To be honest i don't understand the chime lock myself the rates are so abysmal you aren't going to hit 20k in a day.

4
dankdees•

they're balancing for future content

of course, maybe they should just do that when the future content gets here

4
IceTheChilledRoad to 5.4b•

They weren't given enough time to properly QA test everything so they put that in as a precaution in case somebody finds a bug to get tons of chimes.

Which did, in fact, happen. People found a bug that allowed them to cap their 20k chimes in a couple of hours. It's been patched since and those people will be banned.

3
Hello_ChariOPRSN: Charizards, Shaymin•

Bug abuse aside, you hit your 20k cap and you're already able to afford everything for the comp req. Once you hit the daily cap, you don't need any more chimes. It's like setting a limit on elder chronicles to 100/day.

1
ponkyol•

I'm hoping that they intended the best method to be discovering islands at like, 3 or 4x the chime rates of mainland stuff.

Earning chimes right now is like going on holiday and spending your time watching tv in your hotel room.

3
NeadimFate and Control•

Because this is batch one of a multi layer update and that there are more regions to follow which in theory will have better chimes rate

Assuming we ever get them after all the complaining we've done... doubt the community would vote for 'arc part 2'

2
viperxkFinal Boss and MQC•

Maybe they should focus on releasing competent/satisfying content instead of empty promises that later batches will give us what we really wanted (remember invention batches?)

5
TehBlairRSN: Teh Blair (Ex-Comp Keeping the Flair)•

This is likely just preparing for future updates with the Arc region. Note this update was just introducing it to the game - it is far from finished. :)

2
Slayy35•

Are you trying to nerf this already extremely shit piece of underpowered content?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Viinan•

This is a good question.

1
AgonyofRegretRSN: Buried•

I feel like the current prices on everything is with keeping in mind the 2nd batch of islands. Maybe we'll get better rates in the future where having a sell limit will actually be met.

1
zaroswillcurseyoupainzzz•

Livid farm all over again

0
SweatyMudFlaps200m•

Livid farm takes less time, and is actually engaging (for me, at least), while Im sitting here on reddit or playing GTA while I recomp

3
HashTagDeeperinoIGN Runy•

Cap -> unexpectedly insane OP methods don't result in players wracking up (too) insane an amounts of chimes before they can handle it.

They also are going to be buffing chime rates for some of the best methods. IIRC mining alaea dudes was a tad under 1K chimes/hours for me with rune pick / 99 mining and nothing else, so with the upcoming buff and decked out gear I can easily see chime rates being much higher.

Plus when batch 2 comes out (or even stuff beyond that, one day) we may once again see better chime/hour methods. Not to mention when the new pickaxes hit the game they'll presumably be better than any we've had before, once again buffing alaea doodles.

-1
Hello_ChariOPRSN: Charizards, Shaymin•

I agree, I figured the cap was precautionary but since the comp req basically requires that much, it would've only limited people hoarding chimes for the future I suppose.

It also encourages you to sell your stuff as you go rather than stockpile, but again with the cap being so high, I'm not really sure it's effective at doing that.

This post was just me trying to make sense of an incomplete content release.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3†