[Arc] "Upgrades" are a very bad deal

Commodity Sell Per Day Increase: 1500 chimes, allows you to sell +5000 chimes' worth of goods daily before you hit your cap.

  • Useless unless you nolife Arc skilling all day, every day. I've talked about this in another post. This upgrade would be nice if you could hit your cap within a reasonable time, but even with the best methods, it would take you ~15 hours to do. And once you hit your daily cap, you can buy everything related to the comp req. so why are you grinding chimes in the first place? The graphics?

Supplies cap increase: 2000 chimes, +100 to the amount of supplies you can hold.

  • Useless currently since the longest voyage you can pursue is 25 supplies.

Contracts per day increase: 2500 chimes, +1 to your daily contract cap.

  • OK if you do contracts for xp, though pre-existing training methods are universally better xp and have lower level reqs. The chime rewards are pitiful, and sometimes you get a skilling contract that requires a resource you need a voyage for, which is luck-based and costs you supplies → chimes, so these don't really benefit you in terms of progress in the Arc.

Supplies cost reduction: 3000 chimes, -2 chime cost on supplies.

  • Useless unless you plan to go on a million voyages and farm tons of chimes. You'd have to buy 1500 supplies (costing 72k chimes) to reach the point that you've broken even. And at that point, why would you need to go on 300 short or 60 long voyages?

Commodity sell price increase: 12000 (changing to 8000) chimes, +11% sell price on commodities to NPC shops.

  • Useless unless you farm 72,728 chimes' worth of goods (likely more, due to roundoff), at which point you break even with the +11% boost.

I get that the reward system is laid out anticipating future content and these numbers ^^(might) make sense when faster chime methods are introduced. But aside from the miniquests, there's nothing else to do aside from finishing off these unlocks right now. Slayer target loot is junk, other NPCs drop nothing, the uncharted isles are expensive to journey to plus not really advantageous chime-wise, and the skilling only produces a couple food items which are comparable to existing foods.

I guess my point is that players want to play the new update when it's new, not wait for a 2nd batch to make the 1st batch actually make sense. I'd rather the update just take longer and come all at once. I jumped in trying to enjoy the new content which turned out to be a painful grind, a heavily imbalanced rewards system, and very little strategy at all.

Posted Jul 29, 2016, 6:52 AM UTC · edited

227
ExecutioneerBest Helping Hand of 2015 | HCIM murderer•

In other news, water is wet. Everyone knows that upgrades are useless.

Even if they balance them, my biggest problem is upgrades working like this:

grind chimes -> buy upgrades so you can grind chimes faster -> grind even more chimes for more upgrades -> repeat??

And for what? Apart from 2 cosmetics and a spear hilt, if you get one from the dragons. This is a fucked up cycle. The Arc needs more rewards that you can actually use.

11
DovahSpyDovahBros•

I think this whole batch system can fuck right off. Stop balancing shit rewards around some theoretical second batch that's barely off the drawing board, balance it around the stuff that exists NOW. I'd much rather the entire Arc update have been delayed to next year like the smithing update, but be complete when it comes out, because until then it's a dead content update that will stay dead until batch 2 comes out, so just hold it back until batch 2 and prevent it from being dead content in the first place.

6
MrAlazAlaz the Reputable•

these numbers might make sense when faster chime methods are introduced

I can't help but feel the upgrades were indeed put in place in anticipation for the expansion later this year, or even later. Instead, they should have just been left off and added in as they made more sense. Right now, the upgrade to supply maximum and commodity sell increase literally don't even make sense. It's one thing to not be worth it, but there's no reason to think anyone would benefit from them. I can't even fathom how these upgrades made sense for development. (Again - maybe it'll make sense later. But that only means the upgrades shouldn't have all been released now.)

5
-StarlitStarlit•

Everything about the Arc is useless. If the Arc didn't have comp reqs it would literally be dead content.

3
HashTagDeeperinoIGN Runy•

They've justified the lofty costs of the commodity / supply rewards with the idea that they may release more stuff beyond the arc's batch 2, I dislike it but can accept it.

I think the major issue right now is that there's not many big things to work towards with the chimes, I'd love to see some more impactful rewards that aren't heavily tied to the arc in batch 2.

For example, the fang (or whatever you need to buy to finish the spear)? That's great. It's a meaningful reason to do the arc besides the arc it's self or the EXP. The pet / armour? Same thing. It's not just chimes for EXP lamps or to make getting chimes more efficient, it's stuff that's a proper end goal that you can't get elsewhere (well you could buy the spear but if you kill the dragon doodles and get a drop you need the reward to complete it).

So it'd be great to see more stuff like that.

I'd love to see some kind of skilling technique scroll(s) available in chests on uncharted islands to justify repeatedly exploring new islands, or just in the shop for a large amount of chimes. One that can be good for the arc and outside of it.

We just need more stuff that basically says, "Yeah. You want to grind out tens of thousands of chimes anyway, so buy those upgrades if you're in it for the long haul!"

Other random ideas:

  • Buyable trinkets for those spirit dragon dudes to avoid the annoyance of grinding the not spirit dragon dudes, great for people on the hunt for a spear.

  • Prefer certain contracts. Similar to slayer but bocking would probably be too OP because the pool is so small. Lets players focus on the EXP they really want, great for players with many 99s and no interest training past them that still want to do contracts. Actually maybe flat out block would be a good idea if you're already 99, like dailies but with an added one-time chime cost to allow you to toggle them on or off.

  • Learn how to make a high tier fishing rod with a variety of materials from the arc + high crafting. Gives you a reason to do things on the arc you might not have otherwise, as well as a big chime goal to work towards and ultimately gives you something useful on and off the arc.

  • Special knife obtainable from chests on uncharted islands that fletches faster. Encourages exploring many islands to make use of the supply cost reward and ultimately gives something useful outside of the arc. Plus always getting tai is totally boring and sad.

2
Drakath1000•

Ideally a good reward would be degradable and only repairable with chimes/ stuff bought with chimes/ resources from the Arc effectively forcing people to stay there if they want to get this reward. The time taken to get the chimes/resources to recharge it shouldn't be that long in comparison to the time before it degrades, maybe like 5-10%.

The idea I had would be an upgrade to existing superior scrimshaws which adds an additional effect to whichever one you upgrade.

2
VegetableFoe•

Your post is implying that the Arc is 20 hours of content and that's it, when Jagex's intention (be it a reality or not) is otherwise

0