Why do people think Richard Dawkins is smart?
Posted Aug 1, 2016, 7:08 PM UTC
Posted Aug 1, 2016, 7:08 PM UTC
Why wouldn't they? He's well educated, authored multiple books and has been formally recognized for academic accomplishments on several occasions.
I think he's actually a ridgy didge biologist ay. He gives me the shits too, but I think he's switched on.
He's smart enough to get himself into a position that prompted you to ask this question. Are people asking questions like this about you?
Question: Would your answer be the same if the question were about Dr. Oz, or anyone at all who had gotten themselves "into a position" that is provocative?
Dr. Oz? Sure. While I may not agree with everything Dr. Oz has to say, or everything he's done, I think it's pretty clear that he didn't get to his position because he wasn't smart, much like Dawkins.
Follow up: Do you deem anyone who has the attention of multitudes to be smart? And in this light, what value does being smart have, in your view? Sorry for the interrogation; I'm curious.
I mean, someone who has a degree like a Ph.D or an MD that also makes themselves known in a public way like both of the people we're talking about generally don't attain those positions by being extraordinarily stupid. That doesn't make everything they say is correct, but it seems like a reasonable basis to consider them "smart."
Be cause he is "smart" he's a very accomplished scientist.
If you're talking about his views on religion. Well he doesn't really have a background in philosophy, history, or religion, so there I think people think because he's smart everything he's done must be well-informed and unbiased.
Because people often equate arrogance with being 'correct'. Also people are generally lazy and would rather accept the thoughts of a person that's done all the thinking for them than come up with opinions of their own. Regardless this man is talented and broadcasting and defending his views.
[deleted]
You see, it has to do with his extraordinarily high metatrollian count.
Because he does have quite good Understanding in a few specialized subjects (if not more). But he can be pretty rude at times, but overall i find him Rational enough.