How hard is it for DC to get a well reputed director like Nolan for upcoming DCU movies?
Posted Aug 5, 2016, 2:39 AM UTC
Posted Aug 5, 2016, 2:39 AM UTC
They should get Matthew Vaughn to direct the DC movies.
This is where I quietly point out that X-Men First Class is the least profitable film in the franchise right behind X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
I guess I'll point out that First Class was the first X-Men movie after two consecutive entries in the franchise that were despised by fans and critics alike, so that couldn't have helped its box office performance. Profitability aside, First Class is arguably the best in the series, and with it Vaughn demonstrates the exact skillset a director would need to build up the struggling DC Cinematic Universe.
Yeah, but Days of Future Past didn't do that well at the box office, either, certainly not when compared to the MCU and what DC expects from their cinematic universe.
I just don't think audiences care that much about X-Men.
I'll have to disagree with you on that one. The first 2 X-Men and DoFP are far better, imo. First Class has annoying teens with stupid powers and a joke villain.
One of the reasons I think First Class shows off how good Vaughn would be for DC is the creativity of how he portrays the variety of powers his characters have, even the "stupid" ones.
I think the first two X-men benefit from the low expectations audiences had at the time and the nostalgia they have now. Their casts are mostly wasted, their plots are convoluted, their action ranges from boring to corny, and overall they just aren't very good. DOFP is solid, but it's dragged down by Bryan Singer's continued disinterest in developing the ensemble beyond a handful of characters, so of course it's all about Wolverine, Magneto, Xavier, and (oddly enough) Mystique.
Personally, I prefer First Class's teens because they aren't stuck moping all the time like they do in Singer's movies. Vaughn's young mutants actually have a little fun too.
I'm curious why you consider Shaw a "joke villain." I think he's pretty solid, and certainly more compelling than Stryker in X2.
Gosh X-Men First Class doesn't get enough love...I would love to see his take on one of their movies.
What are you talking about? Everyone here always mentions how good First Class is. I don't really get it, it's mediocre at best, imo. Replaced beloved mutants that have sweet powers with shitty kids who have shitty powers and the villain is a borderline parody.
Also worth noting that a name-brand director is not a guarantee at anything. The best of Marvel came from two brothers whose most notable prior work was an exceptional episode of a TV series. In fact, Marvel frequently employs—to great success—the directorial vision of people without name-brand recognition. Whedon and Favreau are exceptions to the norm (and, outside of Favreau's Iron Man 1 and Whedon's fortune roll at being the director of The First One to Bring Them Together, two people who directed two of the worst offerings from the MCU).
Honestly, I like Nolan but I do not want him to direct upcoming DCEU movies because his vision is not fit with DCEU Vision.
He will 100% not do it. He's moved on. He seems like a very creative guy with lots of ideas and doubt he wants to stay tied down to one franchise where the studio basically decides everything.
[deleted]
What they need are great writers. They have decent directors. BvS was gorgeous and the action was better than anything in the Nolan trilogy, it's just that the story sucked.
Better writers and people that actually care about adapting the characters properly. There's so much good material to draw from and they still couldn't make it work. Defending Batman killing etc when you could just faithfully adapt the most important characteristics of the characters baffles me.
Nolan really wasn't as "reputed" as he is now when they drafted him in for Begins...
I think it is incredibly hard because right now it is the movie genre that studios wants to meddle with. The directors have to navigate that very carefully.
I genuinely think D.C. slate is not hot enough that any director will want to risk it. It is pretty toxic at this point.
The issue most people have with the Suicide Squad movie isn't that it's badly directed. Most of the criticism is targeting the pace of the movie, lack of character development, and the storyline. These things have to do with the writer, not the director.
However, to your point about Christopher Nolan, he did co-write The Dark Knight trilogy, so he does hold major weight in those films being critical and box office successes.
On that note though, I think people would have issues with his style of directing being applied to the entire DCEU.
Because real directors want to make their own movies, and don't want to get roped into a massive albatross where they're beholden to so many interests from so many different sides.
For directors who are legitimate artists and want to craft their own vision, getting involved in any kind of a franchise, especially DC, is the last thing they'd want to do. The studio needs you to do this and that, the movie star's people don't want him to say this line or do this action, the marketing people need a certain type of action scene for the trailer, etc. etc.
I know Nolan did the DK trilogy, but he was nothing more than an up & comer at the time, and he knew if his Batman stuff was successful he'd have a blank check for the foreseeable future, and that was indeed the case.
Nolan is not a good director for these kinda movies.
Yeah... You're right... Snyder is killing it.
Nolan and Snyder are not interconnected, you know.
Don't know why you're being down voted, for the type of movies this universe is going for, Nolan's style which uses a lot of practical effects and looks to have movies be more self contained wouldn't work well.
Not that hard. They roped him in for three movies that helped pave the way for the modern superhero scene, one of which is widely regarded as a masterpiece. And then he moved on, because that's what adult-ass people with creative itches do.