Will you tip less once the new minimum wage is in full effect?

Part of the justification for having low minimum wages for servers has always been that they receive tips to top up their earnings. Under the new system, all servers will eventually make $15/hr. This will naturally lead to increases in food costs to account for the higher labour cost.

I'm wondering if people are planning on reducing their tipping amounts in light of the change? If so, what percent will you tip on average?

Posted Aug 6, 2016, 5:32 PM UTC

2779
SoulShaker•

Absolutely. The tipping culture has to go.

It makes no sense that some service people are tipped and others aren't. A girl who serves you a drink deserves a tip but the guy who pumps your gas at a full service station doesn't?

Also, is it fair that servers with little or no post-secondary education who are working at expensive bars/restaurants are making more money because of tips than someone with a degree and working in a necessary field, but not necessarily a high paying field?

Sorry, but if minimum wage is a livable wage, there is no reason to tip.

[edit] missed a word.

32
chmilz•

Some people: "But but what if the service is good??"

Me: "Then I guess you get to have a job??"

16
SexualPredat0r•

If the service is good, then I will keep coming back to that restaurant.

18
monalisa_lgp•

"Sorry, but if minimum wage is a livable wage, there is no reason to tip."

According to this report:

http://www.livingwagecanada.ca/index.php/living-wage-communities/alberta/

The living wage in Alberta is:

$16.69 in Edmonton

$18.15 in Calgary

$17.35 in Grand Prairie

$13 in Medicine Hat

$13.11 to $17.38 in Red Deer and Central Alberta

For most of the minimum wage workers in Alberta (and specially those living in Edmonton, Calgary and Grand Prairie) the increase to $15/hour is still below what's considered a living wage in those respective cities; minimum wage is not always a livable wage depending in which part of the Province you live...

13
TheRealKozi•

And youre you're any kind if decent server, you should still be able to come out ahead. 15 an hour, even in Calgary simply means you need another 12-32 dollars to match living wage depending on schedule length.

For those in restaurants it's pretty easy to do given you don't hate your job and are capable at it

3
MoragX•

These numbers have to be taken with a grain of salt. Most of these living wage comparisons are generous to put it nicely. For example, this one accounts for one parent taking evening classes at college, which is a significant expense (and it doesn't account for any scholarships or things like that). If we use a site like this, I think we would need to make another division, like 'living wage' vs 'comfortable wage'.

-2†
TheGurw•

A living wage is not the same as a "I can just barely survive on this" wage. A living wage allows for a few creature comforts (like, oh, a phone and internet, both of which are stupidly expensive in this country) and the ability to further your education or career via education/training not paid for by your current employer.

9
twisted451•

You must not be from alberta if you think 16-17 an hour is enough to live plus a few creature comforts like a cell phone and internet. Rent is ridiculously high in most places in alberta for one thing, and a lot of places you still have to pay power if not all utilities. At 16.70 an hour your check every 2 weeks after taxes is around 900 dollars, good luck supporting yourself on 1800 a month.

-5
monalisa_lgp•

I work 2 minimum wage jobs, 1 full-time and 1 part-time (in industries where tipping is not a practice) and for the past year I've been completing a post-graduation. I had to take the 2nd job to have enough money to pay the tuition (in addition to all my living expenses of course) and I don't have any scholarship. Is it a 'comfortable wage'? Of course not. Is it a 'living wage'? No. For the past year I've been stretching every dollar earned and limiting my expenses to the maximum making sacrifices on things that you probably have and take for granted. And yes, there were times I didn't had enough money to buy groceries, as all my money went to tuition, rent, bus pass and electricity (even working 2 jobs...).

Several of my co-workers are UofA students who also get paid minimum wage on that part-time job (and they also don't have any scholarships to help pay for their college education).

My point is that working a minimum wage job and studying at a post-secondary institution is not that uncommon or far-fetched as you might think... It's not out of reality for a report on living wage to include minimum wage workers who are enrolled in post-secondary institutions, as not only me but several of my co-workers and many other people are in that situation.

The UofA has a Campus food bank for students who had to use the money intended for groceries to pay their tuition and other expenses. Do you think that UofA students, many of whom work part-time jobs, often in minimum wage positions,make a living wage if they have to resort to a food bank?

Poverty exists among minimum wage workers.So why are so many people (who earn a lot more than the minimum wage so they're not affected by this change) so upset that part of the population will see an increase in their wages and maybe finally live above the poverty line?!...

A lot of people are saying they will stop tipping servers because of this minimum wage increase (when many minimum wage workers work in industries where tipping is not a practice at all, anyway... - not to mention that not all servers work in high-end bars and restaurants to earn a lot of money in tips-) Why a good thing happening to some people upsets the rest of the population so much to the point there's this long discussions about it?

2
MoragX•

It's naive to suggest that this change only affects minimum wage earners. The money has to come from somewhere and that likely means increased costs for everyone else. That being said, I'd be happy to pay an extra $5 at a restaurant so that my server didn't have to rely on unpredictable tipping to make ends meet.

You're also completely ignoring student loans. I don't expect anyone to be able to cover post-secondary education on minimum wage, because we have specific loans (not to mention scholarships) to help with that. And given how affordable education is here compared to our southern neighbors, taking loans to get a more sustainable future career isn't that unreasonable.

I think every Canadian should have access to basic services, but I don't believe minimum wage is the best tool to get there.

1
atka•

Well it does effect everybody. I am not getting a raise but minium wage is increasing. My buying power is most likely going to decrease as things go up to cover the businesses increased costs.

1
uttplug•

Check your privelage asstwad

-2
MoragX•

Did.. did you really just say 'check your privilege' seriously? Can people even do that?

1
[deleted]•

Hang on... People DONT tip service attendants that pump your gas? :S. Please tell me I'm not the only one who tips?? Those guys/girls work in bad weather, it's kind of slap in the face not to.

2
ZanThraxEdmonton•

If full serve gas stations still existed I'd consider it.

4
el_muerte17•

I worked as a pump jockey back in high school... got tipped maybe twice in the eight months or so I worked there.

4
BCTripster•

Did that job in the 80's/90's .. tipping was extremely rare .. like almost non-existent rare. It was always a sore point because we were attached to a restaurant where even the worst waitstaff would be tipped. Meanwhile they're inside a nice comfortable heated building and I would be outside cold, damp, dirty but nobody tipped us, and we would be making the same minimum wage that person inside the restaurant would make, oh and they didn't even tip out the backend staff either.

Seriously, we'd be lucky to see a tip every few months.

It was a 24/7 truckstop, I recall one female trucker drive up next to our air hose, asked me to check her tires while she went in for some grub, ok sure .. she comes back out, asks how they were (I topped up a few), says thanks and drives off ... Last time I did that request for anyone .. but I'm sure she tipped the waitress in the restaurant.

3
Syzygye•

Back when i was a pump jockey I only got tipped on xmas/new years.

And usually only once or twice. Sometimes in the $50/$100 range.

3
SketchySeaBeast•

When I was a pump jockey we had one lady who tipped. She always got the best service. People jumped to the pump to serve her, that's for sure.

3
ellequoi•

The Domos I've been to don't have that as an option on the card reader, when so many places do these days, so it doesn't seem like tips are expected.

3
Trucidar•

I worked at one of the few places with service attendants. We were not allowed to take tips. I mean we took them cause people are nice and won't take no for an answer... but we would have got in trouble if discovered.

2
anotheronedown•

I went to co-op this morning and got my gas pumped for me for the first time. Wasn't sure what the protocol was so I gave him $5.

2
TheRealKozi•

I'm able to pump my own gas. If you do need someone else to pump if for you, you shouldn't be driving.

-2
robot_invader•

I will definitely tailor my tipping to the quality of food and service.

17
chmilz•

Good service should be the basis of having that job in the first place. I don't get paid to show up to work, and extra for not sucking at it.

18
Trucidar•

Tipping is like CEO bonuses... it's somehow expected even if they suck.

6
oreotoastGrande Prairie•

This. If I get really good service I will reward it appropriately.

5
Anabiotic•

If service is average/as expected, would you still tip?

3
robot_invader•

Hmm. Ideally not. It would feel weird for a while, but I'd like to see tipping be denormalized as living wages become normalized. Ideally, my night out would cost the same but the servers would get a reasonable, and fairly taxed, living wage.

2
RcNorth•

Yes, I will change my tipping practice, and possibly eliminate it.

If tipping continues, it should be based on the number of people not the cost of the food. Why does a server bringing me a steak and wine get paid more than someone bringing me a burger, fries and pop in the same restaurant?

17
iamlogris•

Tips are usually shared with the people making your food.

-1
RcNorth•

I don't see how that has anything to do with my comments. There is a chance everyone will be getting a raise, and if they are already over $15 an hour they don't need tip money.

Also, just because tips are shared it doesn't explain why a tip is based on the cost of the meal.

In most of Europe tipping is not a thing, and a person can live off of a servers salary. The US introduced tipping to North America because several states don't have a minimum wage so servers are paid $2-$3 an hour. There is no reason to tip in Canada.

5
uttplug•

I agree Albertan fiscal practices often seem like mimicry of those of the states. It's a fuck in joke. However, I'm pretty sure $15 per hour even at 40 hours per week is "livable" with any standard of quality of living in most places in Alberta rn - I also add that quality of living MUST be measured ultimately by self-report.

-2
iamlogris•

I don't see how that has anything to do with my comments.

That's because you're not the brightest bulb in the fixture.

You asked "why does a server bringing me a steak and wine get paid more than someone bringing me a burger, fries and pop in the same restaurant," and I pointed out that the tips are usually shared with the people in the back, cooking the food. Having worked in a kitchen, cooking a steak takes more skill and attention (since I'm 100% positive that you're a picky motherfucker who will send back his steak if it's even a degree off of medium rare, based on your general stupid attitude to service in general) than cooking a burger.

But yeah, you don't see how it has anything to do with what you were saying.

-5
breadedtaco•

You sound like a bent out of shape cook. I think is comment is totally reasonable.

3
RcNorth•

First, you are 100% wrong, I am not "a picky motherfucker", I haven't sent anything back to the kitchen in years. I am someone who wants value for my money and wants to know where it goes so I have more for my family.

Second, a cook who can make a really good steak is probably a chef and will most likely make more than then manager so they don't need any tip money.

I could order pasta and water or pasta with meat sauce and a glass of wine. The effort to prepare and serve is the same but the second meal will cost more resulting in a hire tip.

There are a lot of jobs that provides service to their customer, why do only restaurants get tips? Do you tip the guy helping you in the plumbing dept at Rona, he may only make min wage too?

2
elect_rick_lettis•

I'm definitely going to stop tipping all together for sub par service.

14
Avengerr•

Hard to say.

As a rule already, if I am not getting my food served to me/delivered, then I won't tip. I've been to a few establishments where I make my order, pay, and then am expected to tip. I have yet to even receive my food, and in some instances they are doing nothing more than calling my name so I can pick it up myself. Why would I ever tip in that scenario?

Minimum wage increase would decrease the likelihood of me tipping slightly... Maybe if food service is exceptional, or if the person cutting my hair is super nice, talkative, etc I would tip.

14
haxcess•

Edo Japan does this. Like... no I'm not tipping, you didn't do anything.

But I suspect the corporation files the staff as tip-earners in order to exploit them out of deserved wages. (pure speculation).

I've stopped eating at those kind of places.

2
Arcandus•

At least in alberta, earning tips or not doesn't matter. You have to serve alcohol to get the reduced minimum wage.

1
beardedbast3rd•

No. I still appreciate good service.

No matter what you do, and how much you make, you have two choices, do your job, or do your job WELL. When people do their job well, I will show that gratitude. I have never tipped "because they make little per hour". I have always tipped because I was treated well, and serviced well. There are many times I do not tip.

13
saikoshocker•

I don't see why not. Half of the entire premise for the change is the customers shouldn't be subsidizing employees wages. The government has determined that said amount is an adequate wage to live on. Why should the practice continue?

6
SexualPredat0r•

Well, I never tipped in the past so I could help support the waitress. I tipped in the past to show gratitude to good service. If the service was not good, I didn't tip. If the service was good, I did.

2
saikoshocker•

Do you tip people who pump gas? Cashiers who ring in your items? Guy at best buy who helps you look for a TV?(no commission at best buy)

If yes, then it makes sense.

3
SexualPredat0r•

I really comes down to what the person does. If that individuals job is to pump gas, will I tip him for doing that? No. If he also gets our and washes my windshield, and maybe cleans my headlights? Most likely I will send a couple bucks his way.

I have always seen a tip as a grstituity for extra effort put in. I don't blame anyone for jsut doing theor job, as that is what they are paid for, but if someone goes above and beyond, then I will tip. It shows my appreciation. That along with returning to the establishment.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
mrmpr•

and if costs go up at the same rate that your wage goes up?

1
Ketchupkitty•

Tipping is silly to begin with.

Employers should pay a living wage to begin with and employee's shouldn't be so accepting of a system that could leave them working for nothing.

6
TheRealKozi•

Yes.

I know to a lot it sounds harsh but $15 an hour is pretty fair for serving. I know servers in the states making $5 an hour. Those are the people who need a liveable wage increase. Making $10-13 plus tips is more than adequate right now. A $15/hr minimum only serves to hurt the province in the long run.

5
Goetzerious•

I want to think that I would change my habits. Tipping is a terrible practice that I would prefer to go away. However, change is hard. I will likely tip just as much as before.

3
beachbbqlover•

I don't plan on tipping at all. The whole point of tipping was lost when everyone expected them all the time. From there it was just stop-gapping the shit wage.

3
bristow84•

Absolutely. I'll only tip if the service is above ordinary, but otherwise fuck that

3
redplanetlover•

I would still tip the same (+/- 20%)

2
iamlogris•

Yeah, I think me too.

2
Silenceaux•

I probably won't change my tipping just yet. Probably I'll drop to 5% once (if?) next year's changes roll out that boost the minimum to $13.60.

I'm not a fan of tipping, conceptually, but I absolutely do not want to be That Guy who has to explain the deleterious effects of tipping on culture / economic systems / business practices whenever I go out. So I'm waiting for the changes to be a little more drastic.

2
MoragX•

Will servers also be paid $15/hour? I know occasionally the rules are different for them in terms of what minimum is. If they are, then yes, I will likely reduce or eliminate tipping.

1
RightOnEh•

Yes, they're phasing out the two-tier system

8
Selmanella•

I've already stopped.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Masaioh•

Most likely I will not tip at most places. There are a couple restaurants I have eaten at in the past 6-odd months where I would have tipped even if they made $15+ an hour because the service was fucking exemplary.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1