Cover letter or no cover letter... That is the question
I haven't been including a cover letter with my submissions, but I'm wondering if I should be... Thoughts?
Posted Aug 14, 2016, 12:48 PM UTC
I haven't been including a cover letter with my submissions, but I'm wondering if I should be... Thoughts?
Posted Aug 14, 2016, 12:48 PM UTC
Nope.
Only if asked for. Otherwise one page that's easy on the eyes and to the point will work.
Can confirm: had multiple interviews until I got an engineering jerb.
With the volume of resumes that many hiring managers get I honestly am rather cynical of them unless they request one. The problem I see is that generally cover letters are simply redundant and don't tell you anything one couldn't get from reading the resume.
This is what I've seen as well. In the past 4 jobs that I targeted I didn't include a cover letter and each one of my bosses we've had the discussion when someone submits their resume with a 5 page cover letter (It happens I guess) about how awesome they are and how they can solve all of the companies issues. All said they never read cover letters. With the time involved to weed out applicants they would rather look at a resume and see if they can find a reason to include or exclude them within 30 seconds. If they cannot exclude them they'll take a deeper look when they compare to the ones in the "yes" pile.
5 page cover letter (It happens I guess) about how awesome they are and how they can solve all of the companies issues.
5 pages? Nobody has time for that.
Unless it is to laugh over someone who can talk about themselves that much.
Yeah... maybe if it were really funny maybe I could see reading it and then showing somebody else at how much this person thought of themselves, but could I see anybody treating that person seriously? Nope.
It all comes down to what the employer asks for. If they don't ask for a cover letter, there's a reasonable chance it won't get read even if you include one.
Even if they don't explicitly ask for it, why not include it? No employer would ever say "ha, this nerd included a cover letter. THROW THE APPLICATION AWAY NOW!"
At worst, they'll say "jeez, this is the only guy that didn't include one... guess that's an easy out!"
Even if they don't explicitly ask for it, why not include it? No employer would ever say "ha, this nerd included a cover letter. THROW THE APPLICATION AWAY NOW!"
YMMV, but it depends upon what you submit for a cover letter a cover letter may hurt you. Someone else here mentioned some guy submitting a 5 page cover letter. If I saw that crazy long cover I honestly would likely take a moment to laugh and probably throw it the junk pile regardless of their resume because they don't know how to be efficient with business communications. Nobody wants an employee who is going to take a page to write an email that can be done in a 4 line paragraph. Unless your technical skills sound highly compelling compared to the competition you may be eliminated even before a phone screen. To suggest that a cover letter is always better than no cover letter I have to disagree with. A well done cover letter might help, but most cover letters don't add much.
At worst, they'll say "jeez, this is the only guy that didn't include one... guess that's an easy out!"
Generally, unless they explicitly require a cover letter they won't trash your resume simply for not offering a cover letter. Generally an employer who demands something that they won't mention that they require something probably isn't an boss you would want to work for anyways.
I mean, let's be honest - if someone's submitting a 5-page cover letter, their resume is probably full of fuck-ups anyways. They clearly didn't have the forethought necessary to go online and even ask "should I include a cover letter?", so that already doesn't apply to OP or anyone coming to find this post later on. My statement of "it never hurts to include one" clearly only applies to people who're taking the time to do a little research and already know that a cover letter never goes over a single page. In the case that they've taken even a few moments to think about what they're going to turn in, I think it's safe to say a cover letter is always better than no cover letter. If nothing else, it'll show you're the kind of person that understands and follows the commonly-accepted status quo in a completely unknown situation, which is what any employer should hope for.
Anyways, as I mentioned in another post, Dell's policy (at least a few years ago) was that anyone that didn't submit one was automatically ruled out. They didn't explicitly ask for one, but it was an easy way to rule out tons of people when they were getting hundreds of applications for a position.
Say what you want to the guy, but not including one can hurt you, but a standard, carefully edited cover letter is very unlikely to hurt, and might even help.
I mean, let's be honest - if someone's submitting a 5-page cover letter, their resume is probably full of fuck-ups anyways.
That's an extreme example, but hardly the only case where no cover letter would be better than some of the cover letters people write. If you are relocating sure, give us a story upon why, but some letter about how your experience is so awesome is more likely to come off arrogant than useful.
If nothing else, it'll show you're the kind of person that understands and follows the commonly-accepted status quo in a completely unknown situation, which is what any employer should hope for.
That was certainly the status quo in 1986 before the internet, but in 2016 I would question that cover letters are the status quo anymore. There are many hiring managers that don't bother reading them anymore even if you include one and I have seen many surveys of recruiters that say the same thing. It is like putting your address on your resume used to be the norm back in the days where mailing paper resumes was the norm, but once most companies shifted exclusively towards using email for contacting applicants putting your home address became antiquated and now many recommend not including it as it may indicate that the applicant themselves is behind the times as well. You will get a lot of different answers depending upon who you ask about cover letters, but most of the people I see still recommending them seem out of touch with how most modern recruiting works. i.e. their advice seems to be behind the times. In 2016 you are probably better off using your time trying to find someone in your network that has connections to the target company on LinkedIn that you can use as a reference than writing a cover letter that in most cases will never be read. I can remember back in college a prof mentioning that back in the pre-internet days that they kept applying for a job where they crossed their Ts and dotted their Is with all the stuff that you are supposed to do and got no response, but managed to find a friend that knew somebody that worked there that got his resume seen by a hiring manager and got an interview and finally the job offer. In the modern era where due to volume of scattershot applicants your resume gets junked for missing some trivial keyword even if everything else about your application looks awesome who you know that can get you recognized above the background noise is valuable.
Anyways, as I mentioned in another post, Dell's policy (at least a few years ago) was that anyone that didn't submit one was automatically ruled out. They didn't explicitly ask for one, but it was an easy way to rule out tons of people when they were getting hundreds of applications for a position.
If they were automatically junking resumes without reading them for excluding a cover letter that they didn't request then that is probably a good thing to not waste your time with that company.
The way I go about it is - How much do I care about this job? Do I feel I'd enjoy this job/company enough they deserve the time of me writing a cover letter?
Statically speaking I'd take a huge guess that cover letters do help. All job offers I've ever gotten I've had one attached. Research the company and write something brief if anything. It shows you actually took the time to give some form of investment towards them. Don't make it generic, or if you do, don't make it easily recognizable as generic.
I recently converted my applications from including a cover letter/résumé to having just a résumé. Both never exceeded 3 pages or 5yrs of work history. My career has evolved from help desk tech to tech/project management over 10yrs. My thinking about the resume changed as the content and experience changed. If it's a project position, the employer listings on my résumé are quantified in terms of a project brief. If it's tech management position, I use my narrative of technology and people.
ALWAYS include a cover letter. I spoke with the Dell CFO once, and he said company policy (as far as he knew) was to immediately discard any resume that doesn't include one. They don't look at it or request it, but they always remove the ones that failed to include it.
Is there any reason not to throw it in? At worst, it gets ignored. At best, it keeps you in the applicant pool.
They don't look at it or request it, but they always remove the ones that failed to include it.
That's not someone I would want to work for anyway.
That's fine; plenty of people want those really high-paying jobs, lol
and then they get shit canned for not including something that was a requirement, but they were never told they had to include.
and then they get shit canned for not including something that was a requirement, but they were never told they had to include.
This is my philosophy as well. If you can't be bothered to request something that many companies don't care about anymore and think it is a non-hirable offense then you are likely to get fired down the road for something else that they don't bother to mention.
Never heard anybody saying they loved working for Dell. Contrary, I've heard quite many stories of people not being too happy there. I wonder if their hiring policies reflect the environment inside the company.
Agreed. Every time I get a call from a recruiter about Dell positions they always ask me if I can do the needful. No, no I cannot do the needful.
I wrote a cover letter for my first round of resumes out of school. Never have since.
I feel quite the opposite. Cover letters show you care more than just throwing your resume every where. You need to tailor the cover letter to the specific company or job and that shows you actually want to work there.
It's also a good place to briefly explain why your address is Minnesota but you're applying to a place in Florida. "...relocating to the Orlando, FL area...".
Even if they don't read it fully, it shows the applicant gave more than a half a second thought to applying to the company.
Yes, I do agree it is unnecessary and another random piece of paper that is a waste of time, however, for reasons listed above, it does make sense.
For relocations I could see an obvious benefit as a manager would logically wonder why do you want to apply to a job 1000s of miles away? That being said I have also seen cases where recruiters are outright doing searches across the country and managers didn't think much of it as long as you were aware that the job required you to relocate. I have gotten phone interviews for jobs 3000 miles away without writing any cover letter so even if you were looking to relocate a cover letter isn't an absolute must have if you have a recruiter do the introduction for you.
That being said a cover letter only shows that you gave more than half a second attention if it shows clear attention to detail about the job posting otherwise it shows no more attention than a resume without a cover letter does.
So the answer being, actually write a cover letter to the job/company.
Pretty much every job that I have applied for has asked for a cover letter. The ones I hate are the ones asking for the salary you are expecting to receive.
YMMV, but in my experience it has been nearly the opposite that few jobs request cover letters anymore. Outside of a few very conservative type companies (e.g. law firms) most companies make no mention of wanting a cover letter.
I will agree with you that I don't care for jobs demanding salary history. It comes off as a company that is fishing for someone that they think that they can lowball on salary.
As long as you write a good cover letter, it's only going to help. I've seen cover letters with spelling and grammar mistakes, inconsistencies, and ones that are way too long (almost 2 full pages).
I try and keep them short. Maybe 4ish paragraphs with 3 or 4 sentences per paragraph.
As long as you write a good cover letter, it's only going to help.
That is the key word here: good. You can theoretically help yourself, but you can also ramble on or come off arrogant and make one question whether they should even bother with a phone interview even if you looked promising from the resume alone.
I'm going to say yes. there are some places that only look at resumes with a cover letter. how important the cover letter is, is a different debate.
A cover letter is a key component for any job you ever desire or job you’re applying at because it is a written representation of yourself. If you have difficulties in writing I always suggest to consult a writing service that can help you with this problem because they are well trained and can write extremely well. A good one to start with is http://life-underwriting.com/proofreading-service/ and see the options they have for you
Unless your resume is your github or some other kind of work sample, always cover letter.
A general practice is to throw out all applications without one because their first impression was not being able to follow simple directions. It's also a pretty effective filter against application spamming and people who don't pay attention to detail.
A general practice is to throw out all applications without one because their first impression was not being able to follow simple directions
If you explicitly ask for a cover letter and they don't include one that is a useful filter, but if you don't ask for one and throw out potentially compelling candidates because you assume candidates will include one that is pretty stupid. There are a lot of recruiters that admit that they don't even look at them unless the specific client demands them. Unless the company is using an applicant tracking system that intentionally is very time consuming or you make little/no effort to advertise the job chances are you will get so many applicants for most jobs that they aren't going to have time to spend more than a minute or two on each applicant.
I'm sorry if context made it unclear (see again my reference to following directions and attention to detail), but I was referring to instruction to include a cover letter. Although, since it's very common and unless someone else here knows better, I don't think anyone has ever been penalized for including one without being told?
I just got an entry level IT Help Desk job with a small medical group with no Certs, no job experience and only an AA degree. I wrote a cover letter.
Write a cover letter for each application. Its worth it.