Behdad Salimi was disqualified and stripef of his gold medal in Rio?
Does anybody know why? Saw this video earlier on. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O1Rt4fNOarE
Posted Aug 18, 2016, 1:10 AM UTC
Does anybody know why? Saw this video earlier on. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O1Rt4fNOarE
Posted Aug 18, 2016, 1:10 AM UTC
The reason is actually that when they throw the weight both arm must be straight. In his case the left are was bent. To me seems like a fair call
I agree. He bended his elbows... so the jury was right. However the fact that all 3 judges gave him white lights... it screwd him over because he had to run for the 3rd try... totally unprepaired. He didn't even have the time to wrap up his injured knee properly!
It's such a shame though! Lifting so much weight with a busted knee is mindblowing! He brought me back memories from the 1998 European Championship, when Pyrros Dimas competed with an injured hip.
And the fact he was struggling with 245 kg on the clean and jerk, tells me he wouldn't have gotten the gold. The Georgian, Talakhadze was lifting much heavier than that with little trouble. Maybe Salimi would have gotten a silver, maybe bronze, but not gold.
He would have gotten a silver if the lift wasn't overturned. He was way ahead of third place.
if you had actually watched him lifting you would've saw he wasnt struggling. it was easy as shit for him.
If it was easy he would have increased the weight for the next attempt.
[removed]
In snatch he was great, but the referees and jury rejected his clean and jerk attempts. Some say it was fair but some believe it was a mistake or even a conspiracy.
Ikr he broke the world record in snatch too.
The 2012 olympics got me into weightlifting because of Behdad Salimi among others. i watched all the men's olympic lifting matches this year and recorded the 94kg one but unfortunately didnt record this one because my hard drive was running out of space, otherwise id make a video pointing out what i saw, but ill try to explain.
to me it was a very obvious scheme by the olympic comittee. They pulled the same shit in 2012 in a wrestling match, I forget who the Iranian was, but they gave his competitor negative points for no competitive reason, more of a political reason it seemed like. (i remmeber the ref was french, if anyone wants to find this match)
Don't get me wrong, the Georgian lifter was very good and the crowd were very assholeish for booing but i still think the olympic comittee is totally corrupt.
The georgian lifter's 3rd lift was as good (if not worse) than salimi's first lift, yet he got 3 white lights and salimi got 2 red lights. also on his 2nd attempt i think they purposely made him keep the clean and jerk in the air and delayed the lights so that they could spread the blame between the judges AND jury, and also to make him too tired to even be able to attempt his 3rd attempt, which is exactly what ended up happening.
i dont think the georgian team was in on this, i just think the olympic comittee was staunch on preventing iran's success. they even tried to get rid of olympic lifting and wrestling after 2012 because russia and iran did so well and america did so shit (its true, go look it up), but too many people were against it for them to do it without seeming obvious.
maybe salimi would've got silver, maybe he would've got gold, who knows. he did have surgery and had issues, but he also broke a world record and did better than the georgian for snatch. the point is that nobody can know for sure, and for that the whole competition is trashed because now we dont know who actually would've won because of the corrupt officials.
either way, they both did a good job. i dont think iranians should blame georgians or the georgian team for this. the georgian lifter did get caught doping, but we dont know the extent of which any of these lifters dope, and they most definitely all take steroids to some extent. just very disappointing that the world's biggest sport event has become a shit show. i was so excited for this year's olympics but now i dont give a shit about the olympics anymore.
and btw they did the same shit in the group B with the syrian lifter, but the israeli lifter did just as shitty of a lift as the syrian, yet the syrian got 2 red lights and the israeli got 3 white lights. i didnt care about that because the israeli was weak as shit anyway, but just saying.
[deleted]
Behdad looked very good in the snatch, in fact he took back the world record from Lasha after it was taken from him a minute earlier. Because he had knee surgery for an ACL injury in training he sustained, he wasn't 100% in the clean and jerks and thus was struggling with even his opening weight. In retrospect he should have started bit lower in weight. But his second attempt at his opening weight looked good to the judges who gave it three white lights. It was then overturned by jury review afterwards which caused massive controversy. Most non Iranians agree with the overturning saying that his elbows were bent a bit in the jerk, but it is indisputably a "grey area"/debatable call situation since the original judges gave a good lift signal. Iranians obviously side with Behdad, as they should.