Suggestion Box v6 - M-m-m-multi Kill!
Hey there!
It's been a while since we've had one of these feedback sessions. For a couple reasons... I've actually been busy (selling my soul to The Man, I'm afraid), and the rate of feedback had dropped considerably. Figured nobody wanted me hassling them for non-existent feedback constantly!
Since the last one...
We've acquired a new moderator - u/et1337 - who will hopefully have the free time of 10,000 men.
The Posting Guidelines (from the sidebar) haven't changed in...well a long time. Six months or so. I won't post them here. Let us know if they aren't up to snuff.
Flairs have been updated. See below.
We're looking to merge the Daily Discussion thread with a sidebar reminder, to accommodate mobile users who cannot see the sidebar. They easily miss the sweet wiki links and our rules.
/u/et1337 is looking to get a Tech Tuesday/Thursday started, dedicated to technical/programming tidbits and questions. See the comments for more information on that.
As usual, let us know of your woes in the comments below.
Some specific questions:
- Any opposition to the Daily Discussion thread merge? Should we even still have a Daily Discussion thread?
- Are any of the flairs overkill? Unclear? Missing?
Flairs
I've recently changed a few things about flairs.
First, there is now an author-customizable Weekly flair. With it, you may set your own weekly thread flair text. All other weekly thread flairs have been dropped in favor of this one.
Second, hover-descriptions have been added to all flairs. It shows up on all pages, as well as in the flair selector, and should provide some explanation to all the flairs. Let me know if that's terrible.
Finally, the entire flair list has been reworked. Here is the full list:
- Weekly (user settable)
- Informational Flairs
- Article
- Video
- Tutorial
- List
- Postmortem
- Game Release (this is the only entry in this category)
- Inquisitive
- Question
- Discussion
- Survey
- Meta
- Announcements / Immediately Relevant
- AMA
- Gamejam
- Stream
- Assets
- Source Code
- Announcement
Let me know if the list sucks.
Are any of these unclear? Are any overkill? Should any be added?
Posted Aug 18, 2016, 4:08 AM UTC
I think there are a lot of posts that should be culled completely, especially low effort posts. Here are a few topics that I don't think are useful to r/gamedev anymore.I think these should be limited to the daily discussion thread.
The List:
Are there any specific posts that you guys find annoying that you would like to see removed? Or that should only be limited to the daily discussion?
I agree with all of that. I would like to add that if a user posts a question that could be easily answered by the FAQs in the sidebar, then they should have to explain why the FAQ wasn't sufficient.
I think we've been pretty lax on that lately... Too lax.
Maybe it's just my circle of friends, but most devs I talk to have become more and more uninsterested in r/gamedev, myself included. Most of the posts nowadays are mostly chit-chatting (which should be in the daily discussion thread), or posts motivated only or mostly only by self interest (feedback posts, releases, questions, etc...). There are a lot of posts that are mostly duplicates of older posts, for example this one, which comes up like once a week under some variant.
Some of the questions feel a bit like they're practically asking you to make the game for them. Also, I think there should be a rule that you should tag your question as solved once it's solved.
I remember the one time I tried to post something on here. I was asking what people's opinions were on the importance of your game's Steam 'banner' (what people see before clicking your game), whether it would be best to show polished art, or a gameplay oriented screenshot... A mod quickly deleted my post stating it was "too simple a question with an obvious answer." Needless to say I'm rather jaded nowadays when I keep reading the most basic of questions which any decent developer should know the answer to on here, sometimes with hundreds of upvotes. If you're still asking yourself whether it's easy or not to get into mobile gaming industry, then you probably should be looking for a different career.
Maybe it's more of a problem with Reddit. I generally don't care much for submissions on here that are below 200 posts or so.
Aside from that... I agree with your list.
As a general sort of agreement with your initial sentiment, I've had a love-hate relationship with r/GameDev for about three years now. There was a several month period where I unsubbed and just didn't even bother coming here because I was that disgusted with the overall quality of the posts.
It might be unkind to say, but the vast majority of serious, commercial game developers I know ask me why I even bother coming here. They have a point. This place is populated by people who predominantly 1) do not appear to make games, and 2) do not make games for a living but want to pretend and give advice like they do.
r/GameDev, for at least the last three years, has been an absolutely miserable resource for anyone who wants to make games for a living. At this point I don't believe you can change the user base much. Too much inertia, and it's not even clear to me that (you? we?) would want to. Maybe it's okay given age and size that this sub caters mostly to new developers who are attached to their phones and never see the sidebar.
I came back here with one very focused goal in mind, and that was to talk to newer game developers. I don't comment on high voted posts, I come here and check the new posts feed for anyone who seems legitimately interested in game development with sincere questions and answer them as best as I am able, my own time and experience permitting.
I think at the end of the day it comes down to expectation, and it took me a while to confront what was in my face but I no longer expect r/GameDev to cater to or help me in any reasonable capacity. But this sub did provide some help to me 4+ years ago when I was new, and I think it can continue doing that in the future.
I'd like to add that repetition is not necessarily a bad thing: not everyone sees a thing when it's first posted. I haven't seen a truly unique post in this sub for years.
(Edit: I forgot to mention that I'm still salty that this is the top voted post of all time in this sub.)
I agree, but at one point it was at least a good resource for hobbyists "legitimately interested in game development with sincere questions."
I think the focus has shifted too much toward people trying to make games for a living (and mostly failing). I would be happy to see us shift back toward hobbyists, because right now this place is all about Kickstarters, marketing, and sales numbers.
Was it? I came in four years ago and got some really bad development advice on here. The highest value I got out of r/GameDev was the developers I met, and subsequently followed on Twitter, and Screenshot Saturday - which at the time was not inundated with games and you could actually get some minor feedback from week to week assuming you posted early enough whenever someone started the thread.
No comment on whether it would be better if shifted back toward hobbyists, but it's not clear to me how you would enable that short of banning discussion of business or marketing, which frankly seems like a death knell for the subreddit as a whole.
As of the time of this post, the top 25 threads as sorted by Hot fall into these rough categories:
7 related to some sort of commercial release, crowdfunding, or sales/marketing analysis.
16 about some aspect of technical development or design.
2, uh, stuff 1) like 2) this.
It has been my observation that r/GameDev is rarely about the business/marketing side of game development; This is a more recent development.
For example, of the current Hot posts 26-50, only one has anything to do with business or marketing.
The problem, I think, is that many hobbyists want to transition to commercial but don't know how to or who to ask for advice. This subreddit has a distinct smell to it of inexperience leading the inexperienced.
Ah. I'm reminded of something now.
Something that's come up in the past is setting up a more advanced flair system. A sort of "badge" system that could be used to identify those with experience, accomplishments, high activity in the sub, etc. It was previously abandoned because, without some considerable dev time dedicated to it, it would have to replace the current flair system. It would also require a lot of work verifying the claims of those requesting badges.
Among the potential badges discussed were ones for those who have publicly released a game (or work at a larger studio), have worked in a particular game-related position, or have achieved some landmarks in sales.
Do you believe there would be value in such a system? What badges/verifications do you think would be of the most value?
While I think there is value in such a system, I think it also misplaces value onto factors that are not necessarily relevant to specific topics.
For instance selling 100k copies of a game versus 1mm doesn't necessarily give you insight on how to struggle as a starting developer, especially if you started in an established studio. Similarly going from AAA to indie doesn't mean you have no insight on technical or design difficulties on your first indie game.
Moreover I think such a system would be suggestive of "real" versus "fake" developers, which would be contrary to what you'd actually want out of something like this.
That said a very basic system such as:
Student.
Hobbyist.
Commercial/indie.
Commercial/AAA.
Might lend some insight into where the poster is coming from when they speak on topics. A student hobbyist is likely less authoritative on selling games compared to a Commercial/AAA developer, for example.
I don't particularly feel that the milestone/landmark concept adds much to this.
<3
Jesus that's our all time top? :(
Yes.
That seems to be a bigger trend. :(
Visibility in the daily discussion thread is kinda poor, and pretty much always has been. Deciding what's "chit-chatting" and where to draw the line is...fuzzy, and has gotten us in trouble in the past.
Yeah... To be fair, the top level Feedback/Release posts were specifically a request in this entire transition, and we HAVE been strictly enforcing the participation aspect. I am not sure if it is doing what was intended.
Yes. We should be much more strict in enforcing the FAQ rule, and promote the ability to edit the FAQ. Perhaps reduce the restrictions in editing it? (currently at 185 days of account age)
Yeah. Perhaps an effect of beginner questions that are overly broad?
If that was before 6 months ago or so, that was when our rules were much more strict. If it was more recent than that... I don't know what to tell you. Sounds like it would have been an error on our part.
I think it's less "if you're still asking yourself..." and more that there are a lot of people posting questions like that here that are just now starting to look into it. I think, as with many things, it's really hard to tell what's legit and what's not before you've done the legwork.
It could be. I think that since we've opened up the rules we've gotten a LOT more posts hitting the front page per day, but they're a lot broader and the quality varies a lot more. I think most of these beginner posts have not made it very high in votes, or stayed on the front page for very long. And, perhaps even if they have, that means they're valuable to the community?
It might be that r/gamedev has become the entry rung on the ladder and a higher rung is necessary to distill the things the more seasoned devs are interested in?
The type of post I hate seeing the most here are the low effort ones that go like this:
I would really like to see those posts removed.
We used to require they be for a post-graduate degree, or messaged us in advance. This eliminated most of them.
Perhaps we should return to that.