pr0me7heusEast Side - Majas Klika - Ariesgal's Husband•

19 votes and only 6 commenters : /

2
dhingusOPWest Side - the Khingus •

Please only answer if you either live in or plan to live in Endeavor.

Vote manipulation will not be tolerated (we're better than that anyways).

This poll will in no way decide the government of Endeavor, it is purely a survey.

1
Folters•

Straw polls are a ridiculously stupid way to do this, especially on a public subreddit.

2
dhingusOPWest Side - the Khingus •

Got a better method that doesn't involve voter registration and is extremely fast?

Edit: Down voting is not something I expected of our group.

0
Folters•

The same way we always done things. Aye or Nay on reddit until we have a better system.

1
dhingusOPWest Side - the Khingus •

This isnt an official vote nor is it intended to be one, when we do have a vote it will be on reddit.

1
JaB675•

I support it, and we need to get on with it already.

(I recently joined Endeavor)

1
tipperarytradSouth Side - Endeavor's Most Irish Pub Owner•

I don't support it. Keep the community running by common consensus and simple voting. Keep Dhingus or another elected suitable candidate to help resolve inner disputes and act as foreign representative. I don't want to see us bogged down in a load of unnecessary shit. We don't need the proposed hierarchical system.

1
Darkflame826East Side - Majas till I dye•

There are plenty of valid criticisms of the White Cross Council but to say it is more of a hierarchy than a literal monarchy is pretty ridiculous.

2
AerothersCascade/Endeavor - Soupist scum•

Actually it is. The monarchy peri suggests has a leader and everyone else. The white Cross council has multiple leaders and everyone else, hence more of a hierarchy.

1
tipperarytradSouth Side - Endeavor's Most Irish Pub Owner•

Monarch/Mayor the name isn't important. Someone with a history of effective hands off leadership is all we need. We can go the route of direct democracy.

1
AerothersCascade/Endeavor - Soupist scum•

Agreed, a mess of individual leaders who have no incentive to work together is the last thing I want. If they could pass laws by simple majority, and we're proportionally elected I could live with it, but as it stands it's silly

1
Darkflame826East Side - Majas till I dye•

I wanted to do a direct democracy to start with but people seemed just as mad about that. At least the faction lite RP thingy was fun and only 99% silly.

1
Folters•

I support this. This should be a prime argument why people should be against it.

1
AerothersCascade/Endeavor - Soupist scum•

I say we go with an elected mayor and pass laws by direct democracy up until and if we can come up with something more complex that's actually worth its complexity. The divisions suggested by the saprasana throw up more problems than they answer hence we should defer to something simpler in the mean time (a la pericorp and dhingus's suggestions)

1
Darkflame826East Side - Majas till I dye•

TBH I'm surprised and pleased to see how many support my fun, although admittedly a bit ridiculous, form of government.

I told people we could get a Libyan tribes RP going.

1
Jenny867fiveEast Side - Winner Volans' Best Garden Aug 2016•

I feel bombarded with all these gov't posts. I signed up for a monarchy under dhingus because I trust him and this is precisely the sort of crap that's avoided with one guy running the show.

Due to changes in circumstances, I understood that dhingus was going to choose several someones to be his seconds while he's occupied.

Gangs/warlords give us a selection of leaders who come together in the interim making some needed decisions without picking one individual to rule and provide play to get to know one another. With these interactions have come some more more familiarity.

It's a safe short-term choice imho that has allowed us to get to know each other and is not needlessly complicated. Mostly.

Dhingus you be choosing your seconds or what?

1
dhingusOPWest Side - the Khingus •

We've been planning the formation of a government since before the map dropped...

Anyways I don't have time to run the government anymore and the gang system- even if it is novel- is going to lead us to some trouble down the line.

Take a moment to read over the in progress constitution we've been hammering out. It's really solid and even includes aspects of the saprasana. (Insert link here when I get home from class).

As to the seconds, I've only had some three people apply- one of them not even personally applying. And nothing personal to the ones that applied I just was hoping there would be a larger/more experienced/not folters pool to choose from. I may pick one of the people but tbh I felt like it would be better to focus more on getting the constitution going than splitting hairs over picking a second that will be in the position for a very short period of time with how fast we are making progress.

2
pr0me7heusEast Side - Majas Klika - Ariesgal's Husband•

even if it is novel- is going to lead us to some trouble down the line.

What trouble? Its just representative democracy, one step removed from direct democracy you guys are proposing. The only function of the individual factions would be so that people can control who lives directly near them and how they build and have fun RP, there would be no other functional difference between the factions, so the whole point of it is just getting a council of leader together who can rule via law rather than the tyranny of the masses via direct democracy.

1
Callid13First Hearth- it builds more factories or it gets the hose again•

I don't support it. It is a (currently) very broken system. It could potentially be fixed, but its supporters seem opposed to do anything about it. After some lengthy discussions with them, it seems to me that this is effectively no government at all, especially as its supporters clearly state that the "solution" to any issue that shows up is to overthrow the very government they want to set up.

For the record, I don't live in Endeavour right now (as you probably know), but I have also not completely ruled out a return. Whether I do return depends, among other things, on which changes, if any, are made to the political system (rather unsurprising, as the political system had a role in me leaving in the first place).

Please do not misunderstand this as a "I will never return if!" kind of post; I'm not trying to threaten you guys, just clarifying where I stand.

0
dhingusOPWest Side - the Khingus •
1
AerothersCascade/Endeavor - Soupist scum•

Lookin good

1
AerothersCascade/Endeavor - Soupist scum•

Lookin good

1
Darkflame826East Side - Majas till I dye•

We are working on a compromise between the Charter system and the Saprasana system atm.

However, I have to say if you are more interested in the government of a place rather than in the place itself maybe you should focus on the location that is where you want to be.

Many people intend to live in Endeavor regardless of what gov it has because they are committed to the place and will work on making it their own regardless if they agree with the majority of the decisions.

1
Callid13First Hearth- it builds more factories or it gets the hose again•

I don't think location is of any importance, it is the people living there and the political system and the general organization and ideals of the town that matter. Except for the first one, all are currently to be determined, which is quite a critical decision as far as I am concerned.

You and others may have different opinions on what makes a town, but this is mine.

1