[Ethics] IGN Sweden points out all the faults in No Man's Sky. Gives the game 9.9 rating anyway.
IGN Sweden's review of No Man's Sky appears, at first blush, to be brutally honest. Describing the game as "a fragile product which was not all that was promised", the author goes on to mention the game's "dubious" refresh rates, lack of multiplayer, monotonous game play and "code so fragile" the reviewer's own copy crashed at least 20 times, even with all the latest updates applied.
The game shows great potential but in its current state its barely playable for some and deeply disappointing for others. How then does the author justify the massive 9.9 rating at the end of the article? Well, "easy" game play for one thing. This is not a game in which you have to "git gud", or event a game that one can lose (or win). And despite its (somewhat fatal) flaws, the author genuinely appears to like the game - and that's fine. I want to make it clear that the reviewer is perfectly entitled to write from his point of view and he's certainly entitled to take the game's (albeit subjective) positive points into account when working out the score; scores are, by their very nature, subjective. 99%, however, is frankly taking the piss. This mostly appears to be a cynical attempt to 'correct' the metacritic ratings. If all those noted problems are genuinely only worth 1% off the final mark, how does any game ever not get rated 'Fantastic'?
Yes, the game had massive expectations to live up to. (When the Managing Director of a studio goes on US prime time TV and says "you can meet other players in the game" it will generate expectations). But despite the hype train, Hello Game's problems have been largely strategic. This is a small studio Indie game that has been positioned (by Sony) as a $60 AAA title. I don't think the backlash would have been anything like it has if they had sold this as an Early Access title for $20, for example. They also chose to write their own engine from scratch for their first major project, rather than use an existing, more mature, offering. This may explain why the codebase is so fragile and poorly optimised.
I would hate to see this become the new normal in so-called AAA titles. This should be a case study on how not to launch a game. IGN, it appears, doesn't feel the same way.
Posted Aug 24, 2016, 12:41 PM UTC