r/eu4•
HenryEV

Could someone help explain why I am losing nearly every battle?

I am pretty new to this game. I decided to play as the Ottomans, because I heard they are good for beginners, and I don't really understand how battlers work. I am currently at war with the Mamluks, and they are completely destroying me in every battle, and I have no idea why. I read that a good composition for armies was enough infantry to fill the front line, enough artillery to fill the back line, and around 4 cavalry, so that's what my armies mostly were. Yet I would be defending in a favorable position with a general and a mamluk army that was much smaller and that was just infantry and cavalry would destroy me. Why is this? We had the same military tech last I checked, so I have no idea why they keep crushing me.

Posted Aug 24, 2016, 3:58 PM UTC

110
vetgirigMaster of Mint•

Very good explanation of battles: http://imgur.com/a/l6Gai

2
THTIME•

Do you have low morale before a fight? (The little bar beside the count on the right of the units) That should be pretty well full before initiating a battle, or at least close to it if they are demoralized and you're looking to clean up.

Wars and fighting take a bit of getting used to with all the bonuses, right kind of generals for the job, stack structure and terrain. It would help to get a picture of the before, during and after for a visual representation.

Stack structure is the first killer, basically I stick around 4-6 horses, and 2.5x-3x the amount of infantry until cannons are well and developed and then I shoehorn just the right amount to get the full attacker bonus on sieges (changes depending on the walls).

1
HenryEVOP•

I always make sure my morale is full before starting the fight.

right kind of generals for the job

How much of a difference can this make? I have just grabbing a general and assigning it to some random army hoping that it will help.

I stick around 4-6 horses, and 2.5x-3x the amount of infantry until cannons are well and developed and then I shoehorn just the right amount to get the full attacker bonus on sieges

I will try this next time. Thanks

1
THTIME•

How much of a difference can this make? I have just grabbing a general and assigning it to some random army hoping that it will help.

Big difference, shock is huge in the early game probably the most beneficial stat line. I always RR bad generals with early siege which isn't as helpful.

1
HenryEVOP•

Alright, thanks. Does that mean that when you get to pick one of two or three types of unit, you should always go for the one with the greatest shock stat?

1
NoobSniperWill•

cavalry should have higher shock and infantry should focus on fire

1
scotsoeStatesman•

I'd put more infantry than just enough to fill the front line. You want to make sure you always have a full front line, even after taking losses.

Late game I'll usually go with 16/4/12, because they can easily be split and reformed into identical stacks of 4/1/3 or 8/2/6 for sieging or whatever. It may not be the most effective, but it's very efficient.

Another thing to note is that early game it can be good to have a higher ratio of cavalry than just a few per battle. They're OP at the start, but the game buffs infantry much more quickly

1
DUDE_R_T_F_M•

If you could post a screenshot of a battle on day 1, it would help us figure it out.

1
HenryEVOP•

I will try to, but I will probably have to start a new game later and lose another big battle.

1
chronicalpain•

cause you are playing on speed 5. if you play on speed 1 and pause, you can not lose

1