Despite being featured in a hype article, none of these are actually available on Future Site.

Despite being featured in a hype article, none of these are actually available on Future Site.

Posted Aug 24, 2016, 4:25 PM UTC

1915
Wizard37administrator•

I have CN2 and all missing non-English cards on my To Do list. CN2, releasing Friday is the most critical thing we'll be addressing, and then I'll be working from oldest to newest to address any missing cards.

We know you all want non-English Revised/4th/Legends and I will be aggressively working to add those as well. I hadn't forgotten about CE/IE as well, we have a running list and I'll be taking any reports of missing cards. Me and my laptop have a long date the next few weeks.

11
gumgodmtgOP•

The excuse is that they are not in gatherer, but it's pretty well known that gatherer sucks. I just find it interesting that no one bothered to tell the person writing the article.

I know this probably seems petty. It's great that they have expanded so much, but every time I heard them talk about this on the podcast, they talked like they have the best database of foreign cards anywhere, and it seems that is simply not the case.

Just in case they don't have a list going already. Sets that I've noticed are missing:

  • Judgment is missing Simplified Chinese.

  • All of the FBB and FWB versions of Revised and 4th edition cards seem to be missing.

  • Renaissance and similar foreign only sets are missing.

  • Italian Legends is missing.

  • Portal Three Kingdoms is only available in English

4
Wizard37administrator•

Our database is matched with Gatherer because that is what is most easily migrated over. Everything else I have to add by hand. I plan to do all of these and then some. They could not be added to the old site because there was no support. The article does seem poorly positioned, though all of the cards in it will be available for trade as soon as possible. I'll be working from oldest to newest so that we can get those dual lands trading!

6
gumgodmtgOP•

I'm sorry you have to do this by hand, I know I'm basically nagging at this point, but considering it was hyped up in the article I expected it to be available at launch. Overall I do appreciate what is here. I remember the days before all the art versions were available for Antiquities. The site has came a very long way, but there are still things I want.

1
Wizard37administrator•

This was completely avoidable or at least we could have properly set expectations ahead of the article and ahead of launch and those things weren't done. I'm not happy about it the same as you all aren't, but I will damn sure do my best to get it corrected as fast as I possibly can.

5
stitches_extra•

they're also missing some (but weirdly, not all?) of Collector's Edition

2
Little_Gray•

Not foreign but they are also still missing some conspiracy 2 cards.

3
another-reddit-guy•

Collector's Edition has been added by hand, thanks to the tireless efforts of Wizard37. Unfortunately, he only got to the middle of the M's before Future Site stuff pulled him away from the task.

2
stitches_extra•

ah, well, u/Wizard37, you have my thanks!

2
Wizard37administrator•

Thank you!

2
another-reddit-guy•

Literally the first thing I looked for when previewing Future Site was Italian Mana Drain. When it wasn't there, I figured "eh, they'll add it later", and chalked it up to the incredibly complex pricing algorithm.

It took me aback when I read that this wasn't even on their radar. I'm sorry, but Italian Legends is a pretty huge deal. There's this thing called the Reserved List, and hunting down Italian Legends helps to increase the supply of some pretty scarce cards. It isn't just "bling".

I don't want to hammer them too hard, because there's a million things to fix with the new site, but please, someone at Pucatrade put this on your to do list.

Incidentally, there's a site called magic cards dot info. It's pretty bold statement to say you have the most complete database of foreign language Magic cards without at least giving that site a look-see.

2
Insanious•

magiccards.info hasn't been updated since SOI and seems to have been abandoned sadly. So its great for older stuff but even EMN and EMA are missing. (I believe SOI is in, it might also be missing).

2
another-reddit-guy•

What? No more Magic cards dot info? Say it isn't so.

Pucatrade should purchase it with Pucapoints and then they actually will have the most comprehensive list of foreign language Magic cards ever.

2
neuro9000•

No BFZ full art Russian lands. Thats crazy.

0
gumgodmtgOP•

All the tokens seem to be English only for now as well.

1