Something to spice up a new playthrough?

Console so no expert mode....

I'm looking for a challenging run that would make you approach things from a new angle. Hardcore is out because I kinda want to make a nice house revolving around the run theme.

It would sorta be like Yrimir and his hagrid playthrough. I'm not a bad player so challenging is great!

Just please no use only sword. I'm looking for a theme, not just a challenge. (I can use just a sword but it's not a basis for a house idea)