Help! My insurance rate just doubled (monthly). WTF?!

I have a 2014 Ram 1500 and a 2016 F-150 insured with Geico. Up until this next month's payment, my monthly premium was only $301.xx -- Next month it's $654.xx. How in the hell?

I called Geico and they said a recent total (not my fault, but filed on my insurance) and a small parking incident in 2014 is the cause.

What are my options? I need full coverage on both. The F-150 is a lease.