risik_•

I like the idea. I don't really understand what it means which is sort of confusing. Make sure that the space between the Popsicle and the x is the same as between the x and the 2. What does it look like in black and white? Logos should work in BW first, then color. Make sure it does. I'm also not sure what the x2 means? May need some clarification in your design. I like the illustration and color palette :)

3
FerralTupperwareOP•

I stream Smite gameplay, and my in game name is Puddingpops (hence the x2) Thanks for pointing out the spacing. The purpose of this design is just a stream icon.

1
quadrupleog•

I still don't get the "x2" - because its more than one puddingpop? why bit just have two puddingpops?

1
Official_JKDesignsGraphic Designer and Photographer•

OP this would work better with two vectors of pudding pops, but please don't copy paste and leave it, put some effort into changing it up slightly.

1
Seedpound•

an ad campaign ,fine--- but not a company logo. Mainly because x2 .Does this have anything to do with you company name ?

1
FerralTupperwareOP•

I stream Smite on twitch, and my Smite name is "Puddingpops," hence the x2. This is by no means a company logo, more like an icon or profile picture.

2
abstract_ideal•

I understand that the x2 means plural to you, since Puddingpops is plural, but only because you explained it. It suggested to me that there are 2 streamers on your channel, or maybe you stream two games at once. Why not x3? x4?

If you're trying to convey a message or concept through a logo, (in this case you're trying to represent your streaming name, and by association your channel), you want it to be immediately clear to most, if not all, who see it. Keep it simple.

Now if you want this as an inside joke that you'll need to explain forever, it's fine. But if you want your viewers to understand the logo and associate it with you instantly, you might want to rethink it.

1
FerralTupperwareOP•

I see what you're saying, and I have had to explain it a few times. I am also using this logo on a shirt at the Smite World Championship so people know who I am, and the shirt includes the name as well. Maybe if I also add a name to the icon it would be more understandable at first glance?

1
abstract_ideal•

Ideally, the logo should work without a name. I'm not even sure the name would help, as the Redditors here were still confused even with your name attached.

I'm all for standing up for your designs, but don't be afraid to make changes, take risks, and try out alternate designs!

1
Official_JKDesignsGraphic Designer and Photographer•

I would say even for a twitch logo.. Get rid of the x2 and put in another pop, perhaps even crossed over each other.

1