r/GolfGTI•
brett2396

Good deal on a Mk5 GTI?

2006 it's going for $6500, 125k miles. it has service records, buyer says nothing is wrong with it. is this a good deal or should I avoid? considering checking it out. it's in a nice neighborhood not from a ghetto somewhere. any advice would help!

Posted Aug 31, 2016, 10:51 AM UTC

311
kizzlebizz•

Seems about right I guess, maybe a bit high. What's the nada/kbb on the car? Right off the top of my head, I'd say aim a bit lower than that.

For reference, I picked up my 07 GLI about 4 months ago for $8k. Full bolt on car (FMIC, DV relocation, turbo back exhaust, intake) tuned, 89k miles, 6 speed, in amazing shape.

2
brett2396OP•

yeah it's like $1500 over market value. I'll see if I can work down the price

3
kariudo•

Two things that are important: 1) has the timing belt been changed yet? if not expect about 1200 bucks for that if you dont know someone who can do it 2) has the cam follower been checked and changed. the extended warranty on that only goes up to 120k, cheap part, but if it failed and damaged the cam lobe then you need a new HPFP and the camshaft replaced and thats gonna cost you probably 2k+. So, be prepared to do the timing belt right away, and maybe talk them into letting you spend 15 mins to pull the HPFP off and check the cam follower. (Its really easy to do)

The rest of the price really depends on the overall condition. If the car is in excellent shape it could be a good price, but if the paint is blah, the wheels are scratched, and the plastics inside are shitty then... not so much. OH and look closely at the headliner. if its starting to sag anywhere. it should be tight to the board all over (check under the sun visors and around the overhead console), if its starting to sag at all or separate at all.. walk away or be prepared to spend up to 1500 bucks dealing with replacing it unless you want to do it yourself (and the part is still like 500).

2
techuck_•

+1 for headliner and timing belt pricing. I forgot about that. Mine was sagging around the rear dome light when I purchased and I used that for $$$ negotiation.

To add to the cam follower/HPFP. The '06's (or at least mine) used a solid formed fuel like instead of the flexible line like 07+. The solid lines make this a real b!+©# to change/inspect, so OP don't expect this to take less than an hour the first time. I inspect mine often, have made a special triple-square tool, and still is a headache. Getting it off is fairly easy, but back on is not fun...just trying to avoid a fuel leak nightmare or pissed off owner if he did agree to let you inspect.

2
brett2396OP•

thank you also you guys are a huge help!

1
brett2396OP•

see this is why I came here there's always a ton of stuff to learn from everyone! thank you I'll have to put this all in a bunch of notes when I go to check out the car! wouldn't want to get put into a shitty situation if I missed anything like this. thank you!

1
DoubleSlapDatAss•

I bought a 2009 GTI in May for $14k, 27k miles

1
brett2396OP•

not bad but that's way out of the price range I'd be looking at

1
DoubleSlapDatAss•

Just giving you a look at just how drastically milage can affect price

1
techuck_•

IMO, this could be a good deal if maintenance was done 'by the book'. I would ask how recently the timing belt was changed, if you get a confused look, that's easy leverage for knocking a good $500-750 off the price. By VWs suggestion, that should be changed every 6k miles, so could be (over)due.

1
brett2396OP•

awesome thanks for the advice I'll definitely ask the seller

1