RanShaw•

There should still be puffins around, but be aware that they tend to fly out to sea during the day, and they're only really there early in the morning or late at night. We didn't know this, and went during the day (arrived there shortly before noon and were scheduled to leave at around 6pm), and saw a grand total of 1 puffin. Whereas other travellers we encountered had seen hundreds of them at around 10pm.

2
getthething•

Yes. I was just there two days ago. Around 6pm there was a couple dozen around the breeding area near the lighthouse. South side of the island. Look for this green hut on the hill.

2
ingliprisen•

I saw a good amount last week near Stórhöfði (southern end of the island). Check out the observation hut (not at the end of the road, but a hairpin turn or two before it). You have to climb up the stepladder to get through the fence. Alternatively, if you aren't as adventurous, you can open the gate to get through, I guess.

1
cygnenoir•

I was out there 2 days ago and saw several at dawn from the puffin observation hut on Stórhöfði. There is a big turnout to the right side with a gate, after you pass the narrow isthmus. Then you walk a bit down the path to a pale green hut (not visible from the road there but you should spot it on the right side of the cliff as you approach from the other side of the isthmus). They pop out of the burrows and wait for a few minutes at sunrise before taking off, but they aren't all out at once so it doesn't seem like a lot, but there are still a bunch. In about half an hour I probably saw at least 20.

1