Blow-in insulation over batt insulation?

I have a ranch home with batt insulation in the attic. It is very under insulated. My air conditioner runs constantly and cannot keep the house cool. I have a family member in the remodeling business who says I need to remove the old batt insulation before blowing in the new. I have a friend who used to work for an insulation company. He said I can blow over top of the old stuff. I'm torn. I would rather blow over top the old stuff because it's less work. What is your opinion?

Posted Sep 5, 2016, 4:45 PM UTC

178
tuctrohs•

Blowing over the top is fine and effective. The only thing is that you probably also want to air seal, and that's a lot easier to do if you remove the insulation first. What I did was remove the insulation where it was in bad shape or where it was covering what I wanted to air seal, and left it other places.

Edit: Also good time to check whether you have mice living there. And if you find bats, definitely remove the bats.

4
vtslim•

I removed old insulation, put down an entire thin layer of spray foam to air seal, and then put batts down on top. OP could definitely do blown-in on top of that, or just in place of the batts (after air-sealing), but definitely agreeing that step 1 is to air seal.

2
DeadFamilyMan•

How did you go about removing the old insulation?

1
themadmasher•

I would assume by putting it in garbage bags if it was battery. They make giant vacuum suckers for blown.

2
Sands43•

The batts can stay. But use caulk or expaning foam to seal any penetrations in the ceiling drywall. Ensure any light fixtures are at least IC (insulation contact) rated. Ideally also AT (air tight) rated. If not AT, then there are egg carton "houses" you can put over them. Or make boxes out of foam board to seal them up.

These things: http://www.finehomebuilding.com/2013/07/11/recessed-can-lights

Also caulk or exp. foam any drilled holes in stud walls where wires run.

Also make sure you have soffit baffles to ensure insulation doesn't clog up the soffits.

While you are doing that, there are online calculators to make sure your attic is properly ventilated. Ensuring proper airflow is probably a good part of the issue.

2
Doc-Rush•

Not a pro but this is what I've found in my research: you can get nearly all of the benefits with a moderate amount of effort doing the following.

Map your interior. Find all the lights and fans, can lights, smoke detectors, door bell wiring, everything you can spot that might make a hole through the ceiling. Go to the attic with caulk and great stuff foam and seal all the holes in the junction boxes, caulk around any gaps. If your can lights are rated for insulation, great, if not, build barriers around them. Chase wires around, look for where they go and seal where you can. You'll likely get most everything if you're thourough.

If you have soffits, buy some foam board and build up a protection wall for the soffit vents, you don't want to cover the soffits with insulation. Just place the foam board along the rafters where they meet. Again, I'm not a pro, but this will work for my attic and soffit vents. It could be different for yours.

Go buy the 12 bags of blown in insulation to get the free rental at your local big box and have fun. Make sure to not blow insulation over your soffit protection barrier. From everything I've gathered, do not remove the existing insulation unless there is a good reason like mice. Also, a key sign while you're crawling around up there is to look for localized dirty insulation, as it likely points to an air leak.

Oh, and have good lighting. I'll throw a plug in for r/flashlight . You want to see what you're doing.

2
latuk•

I have put blown in cellulose over fiberglass insulation in my home and it made a world of difference. Blown in cellulose will seal better than blown in fiberglass. Look up the Colorado Insulation Study on internet for cellulose vs fiberglass insulation differences.

2

Blow-in is a nightmare to work around if you ever need to do something in the future. You can add another layer of insulation perpendicular on top of the existing bats.

1