Would you trade our much improved defense to have Stafford repeat the 2011 season?

Had a buddy ask me if I would give up Ziggy and Slay to see Stafford throw for 5k and 40 TDs again. And you know what? Given the current state of our division, yes. I think we could finally win the North with Stafford having an MVP type season, and we have better pieces to survive shootouts than back then.

While that probably wouldn't get us to the Super Bowl, I'd take just wining the division and building on that success. Thoughts?

Posted Sep 7, 2016, 3:05 PM UTC

614
J_KMOS•

No, I think Stafford is better today than he was in 2011

12
thabe331•

Completely agree.

He was full on gun slinger in 2011. He also had 16 interceptions that year. The 5 games having jahvid best as a home run threat is very underrated for how much it helped the offense.

Stafford now has begun to play much smarter and while his TD's have not reached the same level, he does not need to constantly throw the ball because we're in such a massive hole.

Mentally I don't think that Matt will get to the point he was at in 2012 when he couldn't knock himself out of the bad QB spiral in the second half. His focus is much better now.

With a defense who can keep games close, it lets stafford be capable of winning games at the end, something he is very good at.

8
sosuhme•

Honestly, all you have to do is go back and watch Stafford's highlights through the years to see his progression. In 2011, they lived and died by the big play. He wasn't particularly accurate most of the time, and got bailed out by receivers quite a bit (although they also led the league in drops, so it evens out). He was a blunt object.

You see the accuracy and nuance of his throws improve year by year. That the offense as a whole sucked didn't mean he wasn't improving through the "bad" years. He was.

2
MyTigerIsReal•

I'm really interested to see how the offense pans out this year. I know we've all been saying that the Lions success begins or ends in the trenches -- and that's true -- but it will be interesting to see how Stafford does with a complete array of weapons in our WR corps.

If they can get open, and if Stafford has the time, this is going to be an explosive year.

2
thallusphx•

All i''m going to say is don' get ur hopes up.

2
mxtrav•

He also had 16 interceptions that year.

Worth noting that 4 of those were in one game, in Chicago with a broken hand (or something of that sort if I remember right).

Jesus Christ I just looked at the stats of that game and he had 63 pass attempts. I hope we never throw it that much again.

2
Funnypenguin972016•

Ziggy and slay are our 2 best players on this team. Not having them would absolutely kill our defense and it would be a bottom 5 one. I don't want Stafford slinging for 5k yards; that would mean we aren't running the ball nearly enough. If we want to be a playoff contender we have to have some form of a run game.

5
teddybenchwarmer•

I'd rather have the 2014 Defense with the 2016-17 Matthew Stafford. That combo would win Superbowls.

5
lionheart-1010Megatron•

Yea, pretty much this. It was so frustrating, seeing what used to be a top 10 offense degrade into some conservative, dink and dunk bullshit. If the offense had stayed top 10, that's a superbowl team.

3
AnEvenHotterPotato•

Ehh. I've always been bigger on defense than offense. I'd rather have a great defense, which not only limits scores, but also forces turnovers so that the offense has an opportunity to run a 4 minute offense and score. A 5k season may look nice. But if you're playing from behind every game and constantly relying on 2 minute offense it can lead to unsuccessful and erratic performance.

Edit: Stafford is my qb1 and golden is my flex so I would definitely be ok with 5k 40td though.

3
mxtrav•

we have better pieces to survive shootouts than back then.

Not without Ziggy and Slay.

1
thallusphx•

I think the hidden question you're asking is would you rather have Scott Linehan or Teryl Austin.

And I would rather have Teryl Austin.

1
Spartanonymous•

Many people don't realize this but A big part of the reason Stafford had such a big season in 2011 was thanks to the defense, the defense created lots of turmovers, and lots of turmovers gives Stafford more chance to rack up stats. Schwartz didn't care about how many yards we gave up, he was Ted to create I receptions and keep the opposing team from scoring Touchdowns, and also stopping the run, so he did care about yardage but only rushing yardage in that he wanted to force the other team to pass. Look at other seasons, turmovers, interceptions especially are a very telltale sign of how good a team is. If they have more interceptions than the opposition they are usually the winning team more often. Aside from points allowed, nothing else is more closely related to if a team wins than winning the turnover battle.

1