"I wish they wouldn't use the term "Mormon militia". It implies incorrectly that the LDS Church was in some way connected to the horrible events of that massacre."
I typically avoid the KSL comment section, but curiosity got the better of me when I saw a story about the decendants of the Utah Massacre
My favorite comment: "I wish they wouldn't use the term "Mormon militia". It implies incorrectly that the LDS Church was in some way connected to the horrible events of that massacre. The members of the militia were also members of the LDS Church, but they certainly were not acting as such. "Thou shalt not kill" is something we take very seriously."
Posted Sep 12, 2016, 6:06 AM UTC
Unreal isn't it? The twisted thinking , that is. Of course it was murder! And it was an order from BY. Obviously so corrupt!
According to Blood of the Prophets by Will Bagley, there's evidence it absolutely WAS ordered directly by Brigham Young as a way to intimidate outsiders, including US troops, which were threatening to come into UT. He tried to organize an Indian massacre, but when the Indians gave up, the Mormons finished the job.
I read "Massacre at Mountain Meadows" a few years back, and they concluded that, while John D. Lee was definitely a fall guy for others higher up the food chain, it didn't go all the way up to BY. What did Bagley find for him to come to a different conclusion?
I liked Bagley's book but he takes the evidence a bit further in this instance than I think it can be. He reads between the lines in the the Haslam letter where BY says the "don't hurt the immigrants but indians will do what they will" as Young signalling to the So Utah leaders to finish the job (kill all the immigrants) and blame the Indians. That might be true but it takes a leap. First off the letter didn't get there til after the fact. Bagely does have a point though that if BY hadn't ordered the attack and the So. Utah boys were just running wild, then why did they bother to send a letter to SLC to ask Young at all?
Personally I think there's good bit of circumstantial evidence that BY might have ordered the attack but no smoking gun . He certainly didn't grieve fro or regret the event as he claimed publicly— as evidenced by his later ordering the destruction of the gravesite cairn or his protecting the perps for decades.
For me a big deal is the Sept 1 meeting in SLC with BY, Dimick Huntington and the tribal chiefs where Young gave the 'indians' all of the "cattle on the southern route"— BY, the indian commissioner, basically telling the tribes down south they could attack immigrants with impunity. Young had preached about using the Lamanites as "the battle ax of he Lord" in fighting the US troops for months and the idea was part of Mormon teachings even before the Mormons moved West.
In the end even if BY didn't specifically order the attack on the Baker-Fancher train he had taught the idea of using the Lamanites to fight against the US enough before hand to make his will known. Apostle George A. Smith had been in So Utah stirring up war hysteria and likely was sharing this strategy. Juanita Brooks rightly notes that even if Young didn't order the attack (she thinks the evidence didn;t support that) he and Smith bore responsibility for the attack in preaching violent rhetoric that precipitated the slaughter.
Parley P Pratt's wife appears next to Brigham just before the massacre, providing motive (Parley had just died, and she could relate the tale ). A rider is the dispatched south abd meets up with the Stake President who gave the order.
I wouldn't say "absolutely proves", it provides means, method and motive to a crime and pushes it from speculation to "plausible".
I have combined his time line with Juan it Brooks time line on my blog, ExploringMormonism.com
Agreed, its the timeline of events that is overpoweringly convincing that the orders came from the top.
First, ask yourself if dozens of faithful priesthood holders (not regular army or "militia" types but just ranchers and farmers) would willingly slaughter anyone but especially innocent women and children over some claimed water dispute.
Next, as Bagley shows, there are a few Utes there that have traveled nearly 100 miles as well as an organized group of attackers who organize, mass, equip themselves (including fake Indian costumes) and then travel from Cedar City 60 miles. Impossible that someone got pissed off on a Friday night and by morning this huge force was assembled and marching on Mountain Meadows. It is indisputable that someone was organizing this days prior who had command of a huge amount of territory and influence over people's actions.
No chance this could possibly be a "local dispute" The key is, as Mithryn notes, that this group of Arkansas immigrants was falsely painted by Young as the actual killers of Joseph Smith, spurred on by Eleanor Pratt, who had just returned to Utah due to the murder (in Arkansas) of Parley Pratt by Eleanor's estranged husband, who claimed she was stolen by Parley as a plural wife.
The only reason that makes any sense to me that regular members would be willing to commit such a gruesome atrocity without a second thought is the proposition that they were avenging Smith's death.
I'd give Bagley more credence on this one. He is likely more objective than the church sanctioned and endorsed ( and correlated) telling that tries to portray BY's hands as clean.
Briggy ran his territory with an iron fist. He had planned to cut off CA from the rest of the US blaming his inability to control the Indians...many of whom were members and more taking his orders.