newbie re-doing a rocking horse, advice and tips, please?

https://imgur.com/gallery/RWqZl So, I've been trying to get into this craft for awhile. :) Recently I found a wooden rocking horse at the thrift shop, for $10!! I am so excited, I race home every day now for this thing. It has to be pretty by Christmas for my godson as a 1st birthday/ Christmas gift (and before you Christmas birthday people ask: yeah, he's getting more stuff to keep the days separated but this can be for both imo). He is already a very boisterous little boy at 10 months, this horse has got to be tough. So if there's any tips about strengthening this, I would welcome them.

I took his legs and rockers off because they needed to be screwed on tighter and with better screws (the builder used drywall screws, I guess?), took off the eyes/ears/reins and started sanding him smooth. I think whomever made him was also a beginner lol, he was super rough, couldn't even 'pet it' without splinters, and kinda wobbly. Good bones though, I think.

My steps that I know so far now are: sand it until it's soft, stain it, screw it back together (I splurged and got some pretty brass screws for the visible ones) and use tung oil to finish it. I have minwax chestnut stain, some unknown number gritty as heck paper and some 'p220' paper, some minwax tung oil, and murphy's orange cleaner to wipe down as i go.

I have no access to power tools, outside of a borrowed drill, so my questions are:

-is my using some really gritty paper my dad had appropriate for shaping the legs better? is there a faster way, by hand? I am hoping to give him just a little bit more of a knee in the back but nbd if that doesn't happen.

-is sanding and tung oil the best way to get the high shine I want that will stay bright and clean? I was thinking sometimes when you use a finishing high gloss product -like those ones that are basically clear paint- it gets finger prints pretty easily, and i want to avoid that, for the sake of his mother's ocd. should i just forsake gloss and go matte? is 220 enough for that super-soft feel?

-whomever made it drilled the screws in really deep in some places, should I put putty down in the holes for when it's time to re-screw it so they sit flush this time? i want them to show. I was informed by the nice man at the store about screw sizing for when you replace them in the same spots, and I think that aspect is covered; I just don't want anything anywhere to be loose. The boy is very strong for someone who can barely stand up yet haha.

-do i need wood pre-conditioner like the stain says? can i just use some old English oil and call it good? what's this step about??

-if i sand the bottom of the rockers really well, that should keep their floors from getting scratched, right?

-should i paint the eyes (just using acrylic black paint, unless someone says to do otherwise) before i stain, or after? i don't want them to chip, i see this thing getting dragged around and probably hit a few times charging into battle haha

-i got these things that are basically hoops with screws attached (some sort of picture hanging do-dad i think) for attaching the reins better but the screw part is only about half an inch long. will that hold up to being tugged on? is there a way i can help those stay in better? put in wood glue or something first? worried they wont bite into the wood enough to stick.

thank you for your patience, I am bubbling over with newbie excitement over this. if someone has reputable links for answers, that would be really neat, too.

TL;DR newbie has a lot of questions about staining, putty and sanding and screws. thank you everyone!!!!!!

Posted Sep 12, 2016, 7:26 PM UTC

710
Cilad•

Where to start. Put (get ready for it) toothpicks in the screw holes with Tightbond glue. They will greatly strengthen the screws. Let it dry before putting it together. Drywall screws are actually good because they have coarse threads. The best thing you could do it glue it all together. That will last much longer. You screw it together so you can take it apart. Why bother. Just put it together well. You need wood on wood for the glue to work. i.e. no finish.

On finish. If it has some kind of finish like varnish etc, and it has splinters then you kinda need to start over on the finish. That is going to mean a lot of work. But worth it in the end. There are a lot of good natural finishes. I like shellac. It is naturally occurring. Tung oil works great too. But is a tad expensive. http://www.make-baby-stuff.com/natural-wood-finish.html You are likely going to need to stain it since it was finished before. Just use water based stain. Or, if you can find it aniline dye. The key to the finish is PRACTICE on something first. I'll say it again, practice.

Edit. Looking at the pic again, it really comes down to the splinters. You might get away with the scotchbrite sandpaper. And it doesn't have to be perfect. Lord knows a child is going to put a lot of wear and tear on it. Give it an antique look. And those plastic eyes are a choke hazard IMHO.

I have a big rocker from Harvard I sit in all the time. I have something like this on the bottom. It works. http://www.lowes.com/pd/Waxman-Brown-Square-Felt-Pad/3047456?cm_mmc=SCE_PLA-_-ToolsAndHardware-_-FloorProtection-_-3047456:Waxman&CAWELAID=&kpid=3047456&CAGPSPN=pla&store_code=2589&k_clickID=5b5ee93b-cf44-8989-12bd-00007b82c579

2
whatizzitOP•

Thank you for all your advice. The toothpicks idea makes a lot of sense, I will try it and be sure to let everything dry well. I was going to try and find some glue anyways on my next trip to the store; I still do want to use the brass screws in certain places simpler because I like the look of them, but gluing all the meeting points makes good sense too. There was no finish on it at all, it was just plain unfinished wood, it was barely sanded honestly. I haven't heard of aniline dye, I will look it up. What is the reason for using water based stains? Does it last longer? I have lots of wood I can practice on, I set some aside already for that, we have a good sized scrap pile here :)

The eyes are long gone, as it is the hot glue that held them :) I didn't think they looked too safe, myself, and they were turning yellow... Kinda creepy looking.

Good ideas, thank you. Writing it all down now :)

1
Cilad•

You have to think about little tikes gnawing on things. Or choking. The same with the little rope bridle. There are kid safe finishes out there. Tung oil, shellac etc. Have fun, is the most important part.

2
whatizzitOP•

thank you for your input :) i was going to go with rounded edges whenever i could, and make everything as soft as possible.. you're right, everything goes into this kid's mouth haha

1
I_Makes_tuff•

Here's what comes to mind for me:

  1. Using the course-grit sandpaper to shape the legs will work, but it might take a while. A rasp would be faster, but it will probably cost more than the $10 you paid for the horse.
  2. 220-grit should be plenty. Tung oil works fine but it's a little pricey. Shellac is great for toys because it gives a good shine, dries fast, and it's food-safe. It's basically a type of tree sap and they actually coat candy with it. It's not great for stuff that will get wet often.
  3. The toothpick in the hole trick is my jam.
  4. Pre-conditioner is useful for lighter-colored or soft woods in particular. It's not necessary, but it makes whatever finish you put on next look more even. If you're just using Tung Oil or something else to keep a natural look, skip the conditioner.
  5. Do you know what type of flooring they have? I have one of the newer laminate-type floors in my house and it never scratches at all. It sucks pretty bad when you drop something heavy with an edge on it, but I digress. If they are soft wood floors like in some older homes, it will scratch anyway. If they are solid or engineered hardwood, you might be okay if the floor is kept clean. Dust and random debris getting between the horse and the floor can act like sandpaper. Keeping it on a rug or carpet is the safest bet. Tiny cowboys fall off fairly often so it's not a bad idea anyway.
  6. I like googly-eyes, but that's just me. Epoxy will keep them from ever falling off. They could still break, but I don't think it's too likely.
  7. Can you replace the screw on your picture-hanging do-dads with longer ones? Half an inch does seem pretty short. Adding some epoxy to the screw first might help.

I like your brass screw idea, too. I use them in decorative stuff pretty often. Glue the joints first and you should be okay.

2
whatizzitOP•

Thank you for your long response! :)

  1. I did see rasps at the store and they looked like they ran for a bit more than i had left after buying the screws and stain and papers. I also wasn't totally sure that they were for wood, I've only seen my dad use them on plastic pipes or horse hooves (lol he's multi-talented).

  2. they use it on CANDY? that's so neat, i am going to look into that just because that sounds so weird :D 'candy coated pony' haha (i know, not really, but it sounds cool as heck). i bought tung oil.. it was literally one of two finishing options at my store (very, very small town with limited supplies, the other option was a spray can of stuff). very intrigued over shellac now though, i will keep an eye out.

  3. lol. okie dokie i will def try this now. 4.thank you for saving me some money

  4. they have a mishmash of flooring in their house.. i think i'll just keep an eye out for a cute rug for this kid. maybe green so it can be 'grass' haha

  5. probably going to paint some eyes on, or get my other half who is more skilled at painting to do it. the googly-eyes are cute... until they turn yellow... and then they're quite scary i think.

  6. I'm not sure about this still. someone said just use some wood glue in the holes to seal them in, but it still seems iffy. the screws are welded onto the hoops, so i cant detach them, and this is now my biggest question- how to attach reins in a way that is both sturdy and realistic? (i come from a long line of horse people and i just cant tack them on, it would just look so 'wrong'.) I will glue the joints for sure, it makes so much sense now that it's been explained to me. Truly, I've never built so much as a box so this has been a quick, steep learning curve. :) fun ride though!

Thank you, again, this sub has been nothing but polite and helpful, i really, really appreciate it!

2
I_Makes_tuff•

No problem. I love your enthusiasm. Ask your dad about attaching the reigns- I'll bet he has some ideas. Without seeing it myself, I'd default back to epoxy. The tung oil will look great.

I have twin 2-year-olds and they drag the rocking horse (it was *my wife's mother's grandmother's as well) all over the house. They don't ride it as much now that they learned how to use it as a stool, but it's still holding up. Your first project could become an heirloom!

edit: *My wife's, her mother's, and her grandmother's rocking horse.

It's 4th generation now, and it will be going into the attic pretty soon to wait for the next. There's also a matching rocking chair that they use to climb onto the changing table, throw the diapers on the floor, and remove every wet wipe one-by-one if I don't watch them constantly. Toddlers are terrible little people.

1
whatizzitOP•

twins! omg you lucky/poor guy! we have twin boys, my cousins, in our family, 10 years old now.. they're either teaming up for trouble or ratting each other out lol they crack me up. that's amazing that yours is that old, really cool. we don't have anything like that in our family.

my dad will have ideas, I bet you're right. I was hesitating going to him for help.. we both have strong independent streaks. but he might actually get a kick out me actually asking him for help on something to do with wood, idk :) we can bond while the wood bonds or something maybe lol (I think he would find this frivolous, honestly, "figures she would finally want to woodwork and it's a TOY", but maybe not?)

I hope my godson likes it & keeps it.. their family ran into bad luck a few years back, and lost a lot of heirlooms. I want to help my bff bring back the home-y feel to her house, instead of the craiglist feel (not a bad thing, but I know she misses her stuff). I hadn't thought of him using it to climb up on things but somehow as he's proven to be an athletic type already.. I bet he finds a way. :p he's not quite one, but I can see the toddler rising in his eyes now that he is weeble-wobble walking all over the place, and doing things like giving his dad's power rangers figurines to the fishies (seriously, they were tacked to the highest part of the wall, on a shelf. still don't know how he did it) and using the dog as an accomplice for getting into trouble. he's great, probably one of my favorite people ever, if only for the new expressions I've seen his parents make. Thank you again! :D

2
I_Makes_tuff•

I'm a stay-at-home dad and I alternate between feeling sorry for myself and lucky all the time so your "lucky/poor guy!" comment hit home. Thank you. They are usually either fighting with each other or teaming up to destroy the house, but I get the occasional "Love you, Daddy!" or something else that makes up for everything else. Send my condolences and congratulations to your cousins' parents.

Don't worry about your godson using it as a step stool. He'll get into plenty of trouble either way. I think it's really cool that you're taking on this project and I'm sure he and his parents will both * think see that it's a really thoughtful gift. Good luck and please post again when it's done. I'd love to see pictures.

edit: not think, see.

2