Seeking resolve on possibly selling my first home.

Southern California, Inland Empire--(X-post from r/PersonalFinance) Pretty new here, I appreciate any advice.

My wife (28) and I (27) were lucky enough to have 10K from my grandpa to help buy a modest small house for $200K in 2012. After a basic refinance still owe 189K. Earning Roughly 70K combined pre-tax, things are still affordable and would be even more so without roughly 13K in credit card debt. We live within our means aside from an occasional dinner out, it's definitely tough to imagine paying down this debt by "grinding it out" or whatever is said about a strict budget. We don't yet have kids but getting close to wanting our first. While it's solid and affordable now, this house is not our forever home, let alone 10 years. My gut is telling me at least for this house in the area its in, is pretty close to the top of it's value. I know real estate is still rising and should continue, especially in so cal... but something has been itching at me for over 6 months and I think it's just THIS house/street. Just feels dull (all built in 1982 ish needing that full round of upgrades) and lacking higher potential compared to other areas IMO. Good commuting location and safe neighborhood seems to make the value.

Given these truths and my feelings, combined with the opportunity to sell now for ~$280K, how can I (or anyone for that matter) pass up the chance to set us up financially? Pay off all debt with at least 50K left, rent for a year or two, prepare to buy again when our income can get us into the home we want long term. My wife is a part time/program teacher who would nearly double her income with a full time job (was close this year but market still flooded) and I foresee opportunities for myself in the next year or so in my field as well. I mention this because some advice is to "roll the equity into another house" but personally I'd rather our income/location dictate our next house, not guessing and barely affording something and potentially create more debt.

It's hard not to equate this to being up big at the blackjack table, too good to be true. I don't like to keep pushing my luck when a sure thing can be locked in. It's our future we lucked into being able to drastically improve, and it's becoming really tough knowing when to pull the trigger. I've talked to almost everyone I know/trust and it's all varying opinions, so I figured I would put the situation into writing here.

Thanks for your time!

Posted Sep 14, 2016, 2:04 AM UTC

715
Tall_LA_Bull•

Ultimately, life is full of marginal decisions. That is, things that can go either way. This is one of those times, and just know that you'll probably be okay either way, if you and your wife both work really hard and don't do anything stupid.

When I think about these things, one thing I try to stay away from is guessing what will happen in the market. SoCal will probably keep going up, but in any given month it could go down, and eventually it will for a while. So you're right that there's value in locking in a profit.

My only concrete suggestion is that, if you decide to sell and rent for awhile, make a rule that you have to rent a place modest enough that you can ADD to your savings for the next house, not take from the savings to support your lifestyle. If you net $50k from your current house, and are able to add some to it, you will have enough money to make a downpayment on a nice home. Sitting out of the market for a few years isn't going to kill you, again, as long as you buy the right house and don't do something stupid.

Other than that, just make a call, execute your decision as well as possible, and focus on other areas of your life. Your wife getting a good job and you taking advantage of opportunities are ultimately going to make the financial difference, not whether you realize profit from a house now or later. Spend with discipline, earn at maximum, and enjoy life. You'll be fine.

6
roflatworkOP•

Wow thank you so much for the thoughtful reply... Going to read it a bunch I already know it. Really I do appreciate it. I've been starting to feel that way too.. It's basically a no lose situation. Could get semi burned either way but so true about our careers. Life can seem so crazy and these intense decisions but it's not all about that!

2
Tall_LA_Bull•

Usually when the huge moments come around, you are either A) Making a marginal decision with limited information, or B) Not in control at all.

What you control are the million little decisions in between. Go to the gym a thousand times when you don't want to and you will be in shape. That may or may not help you when it comes time that a car runs a red light and you have to jump out of the way, but it definitely won't hurt you, and those calls--the ones where you can do something that may help and definitely won't hurt--are the ones you wanna focus on. Everything else is guess work, including this. But you're right, it's a win-win. Those are the best kind!

5
aardyLender in Bay Area•

Sir or Madam, I am interested in your views on life and would like to subscribe to your newsletter or purchase your book!

2
Tall_LA_Bull•

Ha! I am, in fact, a writer, but of fiction. Thanks, though, that's a very nice compliment!

2
novahouseandhome•

I'm a little stuck on having $13k of credit card debt that you can't pay off and how that equates to "living within your means". not trying to beat you up, but there's a disconnect there. I'd personally focus on paying that debt off before making any other major moves.

4
iamdisillusioned•

Exactly and I'm having a hard time imagining that they can rent a place for much less than the cost of a 180k mortgage, even in the cheaper parts of SoCal.

3
roflatworkOP•

Well about 5 of it was carried from me over 5 years ago before we got married, and in hindsight of course we would have made sure all that was paid off before the house. Since, it's just increasingly difficult to say ok lets pay an extra $200 this month when it does get tight at times, my wife's checks vary and are minimal through summer. Just always focused on ensuring the house payment is going to be covered. So yes we could budget to the penny and it could be less stressful, but still seems it would take years to pay off. The opportunity is if this sale is worthwhile to reset in that sense, and plan for the future. But I do appreciate the comment!

2
greg4045Investor / Jack-of-All-Trades / Creative Finance Aficionado•

Just don't blow the 50k that you have left!! Hide it from yourself and buy again on the next downturn.

2
MessyEnema•

IMO, you don't live in your "forever" home until you have enough investments to warrant it. Your primary place of residence earns you nothing, it is purely a money sink.

Live modestly until your investments are rolling in and you can afford your "forever" home.

You say that both you and your wife are close to having decent increases in income, so live frugally, pay off the CC debt, then either:

  1. Smash down the current mortgage, or

  2. Save a deposit and buy another positively geared house in a developing area and put some tenants in it.

I'd go option 1, then 2 because there's nothing like the feeling of having no mortgage.

1
madfer•

DO NOT SELL AND RENT!!!

Dumbest idea ever.

0
roflatworkOP•

In any and all situations? I get that opinion, believe me that's what the major reluctance is, it's not the "norm" or usually advisable. But man for all the info/comments I've seen where renting in general in the right circumstances can be less of a financial burden/risk than owning It's hard not to think of playing it safe financially. It's just that dumb to get out of the real estate game because it's that certain to keep going up?

1
madfer•

No, but mostly in the urban areas of California in which your home would qualify. What happens when 2-3 years of renting turns into 4-5 years, and the market goes up 15-30% in one year.

Since you don't have a crazy income, you'll get priced right out of home ownership. This will be in addition to losing the tax benefits of home ownership during those years you decided to rent.

Growing up in the real estate business, I've seen this a lot over the years.

In most of California, renting isn't playing safe, it's throwing away your biggest asset and subjecting your future to certain COL increases and expenses that you likely won't be able to keep up with..

There is a very good reason why the net worth of the average homeowner is much higher than non homeowners.

1
roflatworkOP•

Man you really paint that picture of the worst case scenario pretty well. I suppose even if I don't foresee much more growth with this particular house, I need to fear the market going up as a whole. I've really been thinking just a year of renting and getting right back in, regardless of how much I like the next house. Even if I had to bridge the gap with a secondary income of my own, that's where I would rather grind to make it work out at that point.

The fear of losing this growth I keep seeing now as our nice lucky advantage at our age, while not being financially prepared for a major setback with the house or vehicle, or paying off debt before it becomes a scarier burden. There's also the (even if slight) possibility the market COULD plateau or drop some, making for a best case scenario. It's a gamble sure, not the hugest one in my mind though. In a sense it feels like a gamble to hold on and ride it out as well. It's really weird having a scenario where it's hard to know what's the more conservative or safe play. Again I do appreciate the advice, this is why I posted-to invoke all the right thoughts for myself and future.

1
madfer•

I know your current home isn't your end all be all home, but it's a big step up in that direction. Nobody, except maybe techies with huge company stock options are able to buy the final home of their dreams without owning something else first. It's the equity of that first or even second home that allows you to eventually get your final long term dream home.

You talk about a bridging that gap with a secondary income, if you have to.....what's wrong with doing that NOW to pay off that evil credit card debt? It's a lot less than the difference you will be paying to get that future final home. This is something else you should think about; if you can't work extra hard now, when you are young and strong, when will you be able to?

What I have described to you ISN'T A WORST CASE scenario, but one of the most likely ones. I grew up in the real estate business, and am now in my 17th year in this business. This is what I've witnessed personally over and over again many times in my life in California going back to the 70's.

I do wish you well, but don't throw away the value you have in your home just to pay for some other person's equity dream (renting)

1