r/Dogtraining•
ecle

Demand/Frustration barking when I leave the room (but NOT when I leave the house)

We have a great pyrenees mix puppy (16 weeks) that will bark/scream/scratch at door etc. when one or both of us leave the room and he can't come with us. He even does it when he can see me (like I am washing my face at the sink and he is on the bed--he will be barking because he isn't with me).

I have a puppy cam, so I know he does not do this when we leave the house. I feel like, therefore, it is not separation anxiety, and it is demand or frustration.

What can we do?

We have tried :

  1. Distraction. Giving him a chew works until he finishes it. $$$ though because he finishes most puppy chews very quickly. Longer lasting treats like bully sticks and stuffed hooves are expensive and we like to save those for when we are leaving the house.

  2. Waiting. We do always try to wait until he is in a break in barking (usually a second or two) to come back into the room. However, it isn't really practical to wait until he settles down longer to come back because he doesn't settle down. If we wait long enough (45 minutes or so) he will eventually get himself so worked up that he pees a bit or finds something to destroy (and keep barking).

  3. Crate. The person who had him when he was a small puppy (inappropriately at 7 weeks old) crated him pretty much 24/7 so he hates it and messes it. He will hurt himself trying to break out, so we puppy proofed the kitchen instead (he is potty trained now so it works fine).

  4. No/ehh ehh. Doesn't phase him, and I suspect reinforces the behavior with attention so I stopped weeks ago.

I've had a GP before so I know the breed wants to watch its flock, and is a barker, but this is a whole 'nother level compared to that puppy.

Edit: I searched for similar threads, but they all seem to be focusing on dogs being upset when the owner leaves the house. When we leave, pup just goes to sleep or calmly plays with his toys.

Posted Sep 14, 2016, 6:43 PM UTC

213
Veeks•

Sounds like barrier frustration to me. Is he crate trained? If so, do you practice crating while you're at home?

Edit: I'm dumb and just noticed #3. Look into Susan Garrett's Crate Games. You can teach him to either love the crate, or apply the same concepts to a room with a babygate or something.

3
MichaelMoniker•

I know your situation is when you're in a different room not when you leave the house, and you're not using a crate, so I know it's a totally different situation, but I'll tell you something that worked for me and maybe it'll help you. Maybe not.

We had a pup who would destroy his crate when we left. Chew and bite the bars. Pull, jump around. Bark like crazy. The only thing he didn't do was mess anywhere. The thing I found that worked (so far) has been the energy level when we leave. Specifically, we put him in his crate, and then just sort of act like normal, almost ignoring him, for a few minutes until we leave. We don't throw him in, rush around and rush out the door. It's all very quiet and calm. He's been great ever since and we have to be less and less careful every time we leave.

I don't know if this info helps since you said he does it even when we can see you. Maybe he senses the fear? Sorry I can't be more help. Good luck!

3
megerrolouise•

Similar problem with my rescue dog. I'm still a very novice owner, and I definitely didn't "fix" the problem, but I can tell you about my experience!

She hated being left alone - barking, whining, peeing, etc... I decided something needed to be done, and read one training strategy that said you should separate them from you when you are still home and they can still see you. So I blocked her in the bathroom with a suitcase where she could still see us. Horrible horrible advice, bad bad mistake. She is a pretty quiet dog, but she barked LOUD and NONSTOP for an hour until we caved and let her out. So I just let her do her thing. She follows me around and I don't stop her. It isn't any inconvenience to me, after all.

Problem was, she still barked when I would have to actually leave. I asked my neighbors how long she was being noisy (I live in an apartment), and they said she only barked 5 minutes after I left - so it wasn't separation anxiety. Crate training fixed this problem, but only when we cover the crate with a towel so she can't see us.

She doesn't follow me around as closely as she did before. If she is nice and settled in a sleep spot, she doesn't seem to care as long as I leave the bathroom/bedroom door open.

2