Engels on National Libertation

Posted Sep 16, 2016, 2:37 PM UTC

Posted Sep 16, 2016, 2:37 PM UTC
Yyyup. Man, did that dude ever fuckin hate Slavs.
"We repeat: apart from the Poles, the Russians, and at most the Turkish Slavs, no Slav people has a future, for the simple reason that all the other Slavs lack the primary historical, geographical, political and industrial conditions for independence and viability. Peoples which have never had a history of their own, which from the time when they achieved the first, most elementary stage of civilization already came under foreign sway, or which were forced to attain the first stage of civilization only by means of a foreign yoke, are not viable and will never be able to achieve any kind of independence. And that has been the fate of the Austrian Slavs. The Czechs, among whom we would include the Moravians and Slovaks, although they differ in respect of language and history, have never had a history of their own".
wewlad.png
Wait till you hear his astute observations about the Mexicans!
Who are the Turkish Slavs? Bulgarians and Serbs?
When the dude was doing his chauvinist rant he didn't make much sense lol.
I would say probably the Bulgarians and maybe the Bosnians. You could well be right though.
Engels' perceived racism towards the Slavs aside I believe he is making a very pertinent point about national liberation and what our stance, as communists, should be to it. That is, everything else should be subordinate to the class struggle, the struggle of the proletariat against the bourgeoisie is the most important struggle that communists should involve themselves in.
What makes you think national liberation itself isn't a part of class struggle?
Both Marx and Engels were very supportive of Irish national liberation from Britain, going as far as to say that British workers weren't free if Ireland wasn't free.
This was because at the time Ireland had just come from feudalism and as such they hadn't really adapted to a capitalist economy yet. They thought they could be revolutionary in comparison with the English workers and that Ireland was the weakest link in the British empire and that such a revolt could bring it down. The British empire was at the time the largest capitalist nation.
National liberation is an expression of intra-class struggle between two opposing sections of the bourgeois. The nation state is a form of bourgeois rule and any attempt to 'liberate' oneself from one section of the bourgeois in favour of another represents a break from the class struggle proper (i.e. the struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeois).
Any attempt to establish a new state that doesn't also attempt to abolish capital must be understood for what it really is: a bourgeois struggle. As communists we reject the struggle of the bourgeois against the bourgeois in favour of the struggle against capital.
Marx and Engels writings were written during a different time when the bourgeois in some areas of the world were still revolutionary. That is no longer the case. The working class must break with the backwards idea of nationalism at once.
Sections of the bourgeoisie can still be revolutionary in the context of a semi-feudal country dominated by imperialism. The national bourgeoisie has a dual character, one of which is to shed imperialist domination.
"Perceived"? He seems to have taken every opportunity to scoff at Slavic liberation movements in general, and by no means restricted his contempt to those instances when it conflicted with proletarian movements in the west. This is not a subordination of struggles so much as it is a subordination of entire peoples.
I don't think it's simply a perceived racism. He viewed Yugoslavs for example as an inherently reactionary people and was all OK with the idea of genocide against them.
Well that settles it. The Balkan nations will never escape the semi-feudal, absolutist yoke of the Austro-Hungarians, Ottomans and Russians. Above all else, comrades outside of West Europe must sit back and wait for the storm centers of revolution that is France and the UK to succeed./s
But seriously, I can't find it on the MIA. Is it anywhere online? Edit: Found it: https://marxists.catbull.com/archive/marx/works/1882/letters/82_02_22.htm
Again, I do not propose to go into the question of how the smaller Slav nations have come to look to the Tsar as their only liberator. Let it suffice that they do so; we cannot alter the fact and it will rest at that until Tsarism has been smashed; if there’s a war, all these interesting little nations will be on the side of Tsarism, the enemy of all bourgeois progress in the West. So long as this remains the case, I can take no interest in their immediate liberation here and now; they are as much our declared enemies as their ally and patron, the Tsar.
We must co-operate in the work of setting the West European proletariat free and subordinate everything else to that goal. No matter how interesting the Balkan Slavs, etc., might be, the moment their desire for liberation clashes with the interests of the proletariat they can go hang for all I care. The Alsatians, too, are oppressed, and I shall be glad when we are once more quit of them. But if, on what is patently the very eve of a revolution, they were to try and provoke a war between France and Germany, once more goading on those two countries and thereby postponing the revolution, I should tell them: Hold hard! Surely you can have as much patience as the European proletariat. When they have liberated themselves, ,Ion will automatically be free; but till then, we shan’t allow you to put a spoke in the wheel of the militant proletariat. The same applies to the Slavs. The victory of the proletariat will liberate them in reality and of necessity and not, like the Tsar, apparently and temporarily. And that’s why they, who have hitherto not only failed to contribute anything to Europe and European progress, but have actually retarded it, should have at least as much patience as our proletarians. To stir up a general war for the sake of a few Herzegovinians, which would cost a thousand times more lives than there are inhabitants in Herzegovina, isn’t my idea of proletarian politics.
In context it's not as chauvinistic. Starting WWI on the eve of a socialist revolution is kind of douchy. It's actually amazing how much foresight Engels had, like he predicted WWI./edit
Marx and Engels opposed the independence movements in the Balkans because it was tied to pan-Slavism and Russian expansionism. These pan-Slavic movements wouldn't lead to democratic revolutions, giving the subjugated nations independence and greater freedom for the developing proletariat(or a future proletariat) to fight onward to socialist revolutions, nor would it have struck a blow to colonial powers and aided revolutions elsewhere.
No, the Tsarist backed pan-Slavists would've aided Russia's colonial expansion into southeast Europe, the Middle East and India. More nations would've been subjugated by what was one of the most reactionary regimes at that time(a "prison of nations"). And the greatly strengthen Russian Empire would've been a reserve of reaction to crush potential revolutions elsewhere, both democratic and socialist. The complete opposite of national liberation.
However, Engels wasn't a complete Slavophobe. There was one Slavic nation where he supported national liberation, Poland. In this context, rather than aid expansionism of a colonial power, it would've struck a blow to Russian, and possibly German, colonialism. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1882/letters/82_02_07.htm Also see: https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1882/letters/82_09_12.htm
He was 100% racist towards Yugoslavs specifically though. In his text 'The Magyar Struggle', Engels describes South Slavs as thoroughly reactionary by nature, and finished by saying "The next world war will result in the disappearance from the face of the earth not only of reactionary classes and dynasties, but also of entire reactionary peoples. And that, too, is a step forward."
Engels was a week bit genocidey, to say the least.
Dude, I am one of those people who detests the so-called "national liberation" which is really the liberation of the national bourgeoisie, not the workers of the nation, but even I find myself on the side of national liberationists this time. I am a Yugoslav. I am no reactionary, I am not an uncivilized savage.
Yeah you know when the anarchist is more pro national than Engels, Engels is way off course!
It's good to remember that all "National Liberations" are not created equal. Fuck, Mussolini first turned from socialism to reaction by believing that socialism would only be achieved by national self determination. Let's look at Quebec: the Quebecois Minority in Canada has been marginalized since the British took over. When the question of national self determination first got popular in the 1960's, it was on a largely working class basis with slogans like "Masters of our own house" that reeked of class liberation. Now look at the parti quebecois, the only ones still pushing for a vote on the question. They're lead by the Quebecois bourgeois and fucking burqa baiting and pushing racist nonsense.
So yeah, it's a question whose answer is determined by the conditions at the time.
[deleted]
Ever embarrassing. Makes me wonder what kinda silly stuff I said in my private correspondence with comrades.
My reaction when I read Bakunin's anti-Semitic nonsense...
me too smh
While the racism is definitely shameful, I believe he does make a point in terms of national liberation struggles and whether we as communists should support them.
Yeah but he's super wrong there too.