Why is there so much support for social democracy on /r/socialism?
[removed]
Posted Sep 17, 2016, 9:25 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted Sep 17, 2016, 9:25 PM UTC
There are those that see left populist / Social Democratic movements as playing a progressive role, in the sense that they build large working class bases of support that increase the potential for struggle and radicalization.
On the other hand there are just a ton of through-and-through liberals on this sub.
I think it should be okay to talk about social democracy and even support social democratic ideas, as long as we're clear that it's not the end goal. I'm not a socdem, but I support anything that supports the working class, tbh.
Utopian socialism unfortunately never died, and still has a strong presence here.
We're a big tent sub, which means we're necessarily going to have people with varying thoughts on revolution and levels of analysis. Many of the participants will unfortunately not have strayed far from the liberal propaganda they've been inundated with since birth.
Because many see any sort of program which benefits workers in the near-term, regardless of its revolutionary potential, as something to be worked towards, whether it be for an exercise in growing the base of the organized and potentially-radicalized working class which might be brought into the fold through other programs, or simply as a way to improve material conditions for workers in the present system.
Co-ops, labor laws, and welfare aren't socialism, but they help keep workers alive, able to organize, and marginally happier until the revolution comes.
I hope I'm not causing any trouble, I just want to know why a subreddit full of socialists supports capitalists, I guess.
Social democracy came about after decades of struggle by people inspired by Marxism and other socialist ideologies. To label these people as capitalists (i.e. the enemy) is not doing them justice at all.
Furthermore, at the current time in history social democracy was most definitely a greater force of good than full communism. So maybe a better question is the following: Since our desires for human progress are similarly based in leftist ideology, why would you support a sympathetic idea, which when implemented lead to failure or even horror, over a successful compromise?
REVOLT NOW WORKERS OF THE WORLD!
You can either support demsocs or wait for a global revolution. Those are really the only two pragmatic options.
"Pragmatism"? Lol.
Well only one of those is actually going to do anything productive, and its not the voting one.
So do you inherently oppose all reformist struggles (higher wages, public housing, etc..) and see no value in those things at all? What about the 8-hour work day, overtime pay, a national health service, etc..?
If your position is "revolution or bust" don't get upset when people call you an accelerationist, because that's ultimately what you are.
I dont oppose reform if they happen, but I dont really see the benefit in fighting for them either, at least as far as it "building socialismTM"
Also, accelerationism means that I put effort towards trying to make workers lives worse because I think itll ultimately make it better, it doesnt mean that I think a crisis in capitalism is what will lead to a workers revolution, in fact the guy you have as your fucking flair thought the exact same thing, so idk, maybe read a book by him.
Yes, I do think that capitalist crises will eventually lead to a socialist revolution, but the question is "what to do in the meantime?" and if your answer is "fuck all" then I'm sorry but that's just not good enough and will in no way ease the suffering of the working class until the system collapses again.
I'm honestly not sure what the best course of action is, given that I'm not terribly optimistic about reforms under globalized finance capitalism (capital flight/strike, etc..) either, but that's besides the point.
[deleted]
FYI Corbyn has declared himself a socialist and has debated at Oxford university on why socialism is the way forward - these are on YouTube
Firstly, social democracy can be a stopping point on the way to socialism. Many social democrats have this in mind, often if they are against a violent revolution or think that current political sentiment is too far away to realistically get he masses behind the socialist movement.
Secondly - however much we dislike it - we like in a capitalist economic system, and it's a moral imperative to have a progressive voice pushing for legislation etc to protect those most at risk. It would be arrogant and insulting to the most vulnerable, I think, to write off their present struggles until the conditions for a revolution arise.
I think it's possible to be a socialist in the long term and support social democracy in the short term
If it wasn't for the evil empire of the USA Allende would have pulled it off.
I hope this is satire.
Didn't you know that worker co-ops were socialism?