Adonis death = beginning of the end for griffith??

It just occurred to me that Adonis' death may have been where it all began, for Griffith's downfall.

Nobody remembers Adonis, he's never mentioned again, and his impact seems to be just a few hours of Guts feeling crappy, but he may be way more important for Guts' psychological makeup than you think.

This incident could be the underlying psychological root for Guts' deciding to leave the Hawks: this is where his decision to not fight others' battles, or swing his sword for someone else anymore comes from.

Of course it didn't help that right after, when he needed psychological comfort after murdering an innocent little kid, all he got was an indirect speech about how he was just used and not a real friend, but that was just the direction for his leave decision, the root is how bad he felt for murdering Adonis.

Additionally, Griffith got some karmic payback, since he smiled when he heard that not only Julius, but Adonis (next in line candidate for the throne) got killed.

Posted Sep 19, 2016, 1:59 AM UTC · edited

2716
Natswash•

I thought Adonis was symbolic of Guts killing what innocence he had left. After that he started really thinking about why he was fighting

30
ghostunit777OP•

Right, and that's ultimately why he left.

11
GreyNGroovy•

That makes a lot of sense

3
mikazee•

Both reasons could be true.

2
robotoboy20•

This is also a theory I hold. Up until Adonis's death Guts seems fine helping Griffith, and doing battle... He seems to enjoy slaughtering people, and enjoys the very aspect of battle being his only skill... it isn't until murdering a child that he seems to become more reserved and think less on the act of acting wildly... This can be seen when his actions during Griffiths strategies become more calm, and he actually listens, for instance the battle at Doldery - he actually sticks to the plan...

Griffiths words still echoed inside though, and he knew that Griffith didn't respect him or care that he had done something so horrible, and what it may have done to him.

When asked if he thinks Griffith is cruel for doing this - he dodges the question... because Guts does not want to think his friend a cruel manipulative user...

13
objective_apples•

because Guts does not want to think his friend a cruel manipulative user...

or himself as a pawn.

5
wow_kawaii_leonard•

That night is miura showing how causality works.

Little things that seem unrelated combine into larger events later.

Adonis was betrothed to Charlotte. Julius was heir to Midland, not Charlotte. So Adonis would be king after Julius, with Charlotte as his queen to maintain legitimacy. Not uncommon in agnatic succession.

Griffith was honest about his relationships with the Band of the Hawk only when he didn't know they were listening. Guts witnessed Griffith dismissing all the people who pledged their lives to him, including himself.

Killing Julius meant Adonis elevates in succession, but killing Adonis leaves the throne open to basically anyone that can create a tie to the royal blood. That meant Charlotte's hand in marriage, which Griffith had always made as his target. Griffith didn't plan on Adonis dying that night but he would have to do it eventually, no way Griffith would be king with adonis alive.

That overheard conversation led guts to think about what he wants in his own dream, to become Griffiths equal. However, it was the conversation and the revelation of Griffiths philosophy that led guts to leave, not Adonis. Guts was sent to kill Julius, and news hasn't reached yet about the assassination. Griffith was trying to enamor Charlotte to him, so its not because of Adonis.

Adonis is definitely important to guts in that short period of time. There's no indication that guts engaged in assassination before being sent for Julius, and who knows if guts has killed other child soldiers. But he feels a sort of kinship with adonis after witnessing Julius training Adonis.

It affects him not because of a personal connection but because of how integral Gambino was to guts formation.

11
[deleted]•

No I think Adonis was basically a tragic event but Guts would have continued killing/fighting for Griffith, had Griffith not treated the Band of the Hawk & Guts like underlings.

I think Griffith would never have asked Guts to kill a child, this was more of Guts' mistake than Griffith's. (not that Griffith isnt capable himself of killing a child).

The turning point was really Griffith revealing himself to Charlotte & being witnessed by Guts/Casca.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
FogOverLondon•

He always had that dangerous ambition, but you're right. Tangibly, that was the first big move toward his machinations that had significant ripple effects (for Guts, as well as plot/other people).

1
lucasnator2•

Its a nice theory but no. Guts left the hawks cause he wanted to fight. The hawks were about to live a peacful life as nobles. Guts wanted to constantly be in battle. Sure there were bits about not wanting to disapear under griffith. But theres that fighting is all he know its all he does. If guts had freetime hed probably be fighting.

-15
ghostunit777OP•

Guts had already made up his mind about leaving by the "Bonfire of Dreams" episode though.

Also, Guts declines to continue fighting under Griffith when Caska invites him to do so (after they make up by the waterfall).

And my point is kind of: Guts is fine with killing and wants to keep fighting, but he no longer wants to do it for anyone else. He wants to "fight his own battles".

If he ended up killing a kid again, he didn't want it to be because someone else told him to do it.

Guts just felt too dirty.

11
SITHISIT•

u/lucasnator2 got it wrong. It was explicitly made clear that Guts left the Hawks because of the events of that night.

Just before Guts left, Corkus chastised him for thinking he could ever reach Griffith's level and realize his own dream. The whole reason for Guts even wanting his own dream is because of Griffith's words.

Just before Eclipse, Casca told Guts if he is Griffith's friend he has to leave. Griffith even had an "oh-shit" look on his face when he heard this and realized how he fucked himself.

I appreciate your post, because up until now I didn't consider that Adonis alone is the reason for the Hawks' downfall. If he hadn't died, things might have turned out different, even if Guts overheard Griffith saying the same lines.

5
ghostunit777OP•

Yeah, and it's also not like Guts went "damn, I murdered a little kid, I gotta rethink my ways".

It was more of a "slow burn", that we don't see happening on screen, directly. And Guts himself might not have realized how influenced he was by that event.

So it's really up to imagination and interpretation.

3
lmyyyks•

There were some moments where Guts said Griffith was his .... (always got cut off here, but we can all guess the word is "friend", as Zodd had already said it out): first time fighting Zodd, during the Eclipse, etc. and that speech from Griffith posed a huge contrast. Guts had been putting his life on the line fighting towards his friend's dream yet that was one important thing in that friend talk (that disqualified him from being Griffith's friend, at least Guts thought). And Guts said he wanted to be Griffith's equal (to be regarded as his friend).

The friend comment from Griffith was fundamental to Guts departure and hence the Band's collapse, that I'm sure. However, Adonis' death might not have been crucial. It could at most add to that Guts killed an innocent kid for a friend who might not consider him a friend.

I think the story construction is a bit weak about this part. All the buildups to introduce the Adonis character who met his unfortunate end way too early. All these make some think that his death will have certain impacts on Guts/Griffith/story but no, no regrets expressed by Guts, no flashbacks, no comments, just another negligible collateral damage.

1
RopeADoper•

You're thinking of Zodd. Guts might be good at fighting and it's mostly what he's been doing his whole life, but he does it to survive, not for pleasure.

1