r/gamedev•
lemtzas

The TowerFall artist is apparently making some pixel art animation breakdowns.

Posted Sep 26, 2016, 9:29 AM UTC

24520
wekilledbambi03•

imgur album I made of his gifs so far

27
lemtzasOP@lemtzas•

My man!

6
OnyxSola•

Saving this for later, could come in handy :o

1
adarias•

Very nice! Fundamental concepts framed well and easy to understand.

One extension :

You can totally have anticipation frames in attack animations, but they should be just as obvious as the main action, so the player knows he isn't idling.

You should also consider the input style. A character should be able to execute the move almost as often as the player can perform the input. If a move is executed with a single button that the player can mash, it should happen lightning-fast. Moves that take longer to perform should, by extension, take more work from the player, so they don't feel like the game is dropping inputs. This is also true for attacks with too much recovery, which creates the same problem on the other end of the attack.

A classic example is the hadouken. IIRC Ryu has at least 2 frames of anticipatory movement. But the hadouken also requires a specific sequence of inputs. Both the button sequence and the anticipation go a long way to making the hadouken feel more powerful and impactful than a regular attack, and contribute to its iconic status.

You can also substitute button-holds for input sequences. If the player doesn't hold down long enough, the character won't perform the skill, so mashing isn't an option. As anticipation goes, this gives you plenty of time for a "charge-up," and you know exactly how long you'll have to play the anticipation frames.

Of course, animation should always be designed to fit the playstyle and game mechanics. Adding weight through anticipation should not come at the expense of fun or feel, so use anticipation and other delays sparingly and deliberately.

7
deaf_fish•

I am wondering what the bars are above the frames and animation. They seem to be related to the frames. What are they trying to show?

3
grantmoore3d@GrantMoore3D•

They're representing the timing, position and power of the animation. It's just a simpler way to "read" how the animation is constructed from base principles so you can apply it to other motions or effects.

3
superdupergc@superdupergc/blackicethegame•

Nice! Also, Saint isn't the only Towerfall artist - Amora did a lot of work too!

2
lemtzasOP@lemtzas•

Ah! I didn't know.

2
TheRealSusan•

What do they mean by anticipation frame? Like a frame that queues while waiting to find out if a button press is either a tap or hold?

2
JSConrad45•

They mean windup animations -- like pulling the arm back before throwing the punch.

The assumption that this is universally a bad thing is driving me crazy. Because, y'know, nobody likes Castlevania, or Dark Souls, or Monster Hunter, or Street Fighter, or any fighting game ever, because they make the player experience input lag.

If your game is about twitch reactions, then the delay that comes with anticipation frames is undesirable. But if your game is about real-time planning and state management, anticipation frames are very important.

10
Moczan•

What driving me crazy is mixing anticipation with startup frames and startup frames with input lag. His animation still has 3 frames startup which is on par with many light attacks in Street Fighter. Also he doesn't say it's universal truth, it's a quick tutorial about minimal attack animation, in this case 8 frames and lack of anticipation is more than right.

6
JSConrad45•

There's no startup on his animation. In a fighting game, that first smear frame would be the first active frame of the attack.

2
Moczan•

If the 1st idle frame is played after button press it's still 2-frame startup (in street fighter games last startup frame = first active frame) assuming the smear would have active hitbox, not the next frame. It's all nitpicking at this point which we could do infinitely.

1
d4nace@danfornace•

Yeah I think he is wrong about windup / startup. You can do anticipation frames but make them snappier than recovery. Having a big windup pose for 3 frames before an attack feels better than just attacking imo. Even in a quick action that doesn't require startup for balance. It just gives the attack more weight.

He does have a point that many novice developers load up that time and attacks feel unresponsive. But avoiding a pose all together isn't the solution in my opinion. Just make the time it is on screen really short. You can also use that time to distinguish weapons / attacks. Lights have incredibly short startup while heavies have longer startup and deal more damage etc.

4
OnyxSola•

This is particularly true for fighting games. I couldn't imagine how a fighting game without any anticipation frames would feel - probably really responsive, but you'd lose a lot of the weight/impact of the move in the process.

2
Ravek•

Yeah it's weird. There's nothing wrong at all with attacks that have a large windup – like you say this idea is key to so, so many games. I struggle to think of any games with more than one attack that don't incorporate have at least one short windup, low damage move and one long windup, high damage or utility move. It's the most basic attack variety possible!

And none of this has anything to do with input lag. Yeah, you don't want to repeat the idle frame for 5 frames after the button press before anything else happens, because that would indeed appear as if there were input lag – but there's no reason you can't have a 5 frame windup if that works for your game mechanics. I assume that this is also what the artist is trying to convey, but it's not very clear from the graphic.

1
scobey•

Imagine if the guy swung back his arm before punching instead of immediately having his arm outreached; if the action doesn't happen with no delay it is jarring to the player.

2
jamiltron•

It depends on the game and the context of the attack. Take Dark Souls for example - the game is built around an requirement to understand the movement of combat, and all of the animations correspond the weight and speed of every attack well.

1
Goth_2_Boss•

Sweet! The design in towrfall is tops!

1