possibility of sanders presidential run

i want to start this post by saying up front i am not an american citizen but have been following the election closely especially in the last 2 months. this post will be at first just information showing its possible with sources linked in it and then followed by my personal analysis that will be marked clearly, in my personal analysis i will be trying to avoid political bias, not stating which candidate i'm rooting for, and am just trying to present possible outcomes from this. this is not meant to be for or against any candidate and i aim to have supporters of both parties not feel excluded or attacked. both links are videos so mobile users know, first is a time stamped youtube video for sanders endorsement of Clinton showing his exact words and the second is a 4 min video from msnbc talking about how Sanders does keep his votes on record.

first i want to address that technically Sanders never conceded his run for the democratic nominee. should for whatever reason Clinton drops out either by choice or is forced out sanders is the person with the next highest amount of votes from the convention. At the convention once all votes were in Sanders said

"I move that the convention suspend the procedural rules. I move that all votes, all votes cast by delegates be reflected in the official record, and I move that Hillary Clinton be selected as the nominee of the Democratic Party for president of the United States."

its important to note that he moves to have all votes recorded and on the official record, he moves to have her selected as the nominee but never concedes his votes to her or call for a vote by acclimation which would invalidate all the votes for him as well. the convention chair after he said this did say that he moved to have her nominated by acclimation however he did not technically release his votes.

so as it stands Sanders still has those votes. recently Sanders was meant to appear with Clinton at several events but after the tape of Clinton's remarks about his supporters surfaced those were changed to not include Sanders and instead Clinton will appear as planned just without him. Sanders in turn is going to appear in several swing states to campaign.

PERSONAL ANALYSIS:

with all of that information out there first off i did want to make sure people knew that i am in no way saying this will happen, in fact with it being October already i would put it at fairly unlikely. with Wikileaks set to publish up to 1 million documents relating to the election in some way, if those documents are damaging enough to Clinton(if they are even focused on her) then it is possible and depending on how damaging probable that the democratic party or Clinton could actually drop the Clinton campaign and be forced to either have Sanders run or hold a new convention with weeks until the election. obviously i see Sanders being selected as most likely.

If that came to happen then it would be a historic event, and would completely change the election for both sides. The Sanders campaign would have to run a blitz of media events, speeches, interviews. the democrats would have to find a way to release Clinton without hurting party reputation and somehow show unity(easiest to do if it is very damaging and they can disown her from the party, spin for unity around an independent publicly seen as not corrupted by corporations) and the Trump campaign who until now has focused a lot on why Clinton was poor decision and rarely on why Trump is best choice would have to refocus on Sanders. i want to note here i'm not explicitly saying trump is just running a negative campaign here but because he has never served in office they cant use the standard things such as previous votes in senate or other office to show history of supporting _____ issue, i am trying to remain impartial here again.

should Sanders be put in a position to run he starts out with a very large amount of younger voters which is a massive base because these are voters least likely to vote and as such when polling happens if they are called they will typically say they aren't voting and be excluded from the poll or that they are undecided or other and be placed into the uncertain voters. this is a market of voters that is hardest to reach and getting them to vote increases overall votes which means less ground to recover. On top of those voters the Clinton campaign has worked hard to secure the female vote which is larger than the male voting population and every election year since 1980 over 50% of the votes for Democrats have been from women.

I guess my closing words would be while i think this is an unlikely scenario, it is possible and if it came to happen i feel that the Democrats could recover from an October candidate switch if they spin it right. it would come down to how the Republican campaign talked about it and if they only focus on the switch and not the candidate it would be possible to recover. on top of that introducing Sanders late as a final observation in my opinion due to Sanders young voter support would reduce the overall amount of the "joke votes" where someone votes for something they dont think will happen because its funny, as was seen in the brexit vote.

TL:DR i know that was long bare bones summary would be Sanders did not concede the election and had his votes for nominee preserved, if Clinton were to drop out her votes are lost and Sanders is new nominee. Sanders and Clinton have distanced themselves with Sanders campaigning in swing states now while Clinton isn't with him. its possible to have the Democrats change candidates in October and still recover. all of this is unlikely but and interesting thought experiment.

i'm sorry for the length post but am interested in peoples opinions on this thought experiment.

edit: /u/ OMG_its_JasonE has pointed out my flawed assumption of the suspension of the rules, if that assumption is wrong the whole thing changes from Sanders being the de facto nominee to a possible one.

Posted Oct 4, 2016, 6:37 PM UTC · edited

07
OMG_its_JasonE•

You logic and reasoning have no bearing on the rules of the party. There is a rule regarding the replacement of the nominee after the convention. It states that a DNC committee will decide the replacement nominee. They do not have to take into account delegates or votes.

4
pei_cubeOP•

in his statement that i quoted Sanders moved to suspend all procedural rules which includes the two options that the party has when replacing a candidate. the party can choose to either give the nomination to the person with the next highest votes or to name someone of their own choosing however with the motion from Sanders to suspend the rules, the fact that no one objected and the cheering afterwards a traditionally accepted vote by acclimation in approval the party must rely on its bylaws which only state the candidate with the next highest votes is given the nomination or they may hold a new convention. new convention and primaries are too time consuming leaving only the appointment of Sanders as the nominee. a link to the full rules and bylaws of the DNC

0
OMG_its_JasonE•

http://tndp.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/2016-Call-for-Convention-5.22.15.pdf

here is the new rules, from 2016. Page 18 article G states "Filling a Vacancy on the National Ticket: In the event of death, resignation or disability of a nominee of the Party for President or Vice President after the adjournment of the National Convention, the National Chairperson of the Democratic National Committee shall confer with the Democratic leadership of the United States Congress and the Democratic Governors Association and shall report to the Democratic National Committee, which is authorized to fill the vacancy or vacancies. "

3
pei_cubeOP•

same page article J says

J. Motion to Suspend the Rules: The Chair shall entertain a motion to suspend the rules, which shall be decided without debate and which shall require a vote of two thirds (2/3) of the delegates voting, a quorum being present.

Sanders motioned to have the rules suspended agreed by acclimation. i think it would come down to interpretation what you linked has an article where they say who gets final interpretation, im not sure how it would apply to this. i feel the vote by acclimation was made, suspending those rules but i could be wrong here. what i am sure of is that in motion to suspend the rules almost all rules can be suspend except for bylaws and rules that would allow someone to vote who normally couldn't or a rule that allows someone to vote that without it they couldn't.

0
OMG_its_JasonE•

once the gavel closes the convention, the suspension of rules ended.

3