r/TibiaMMO•
Semth

Improve paladins without making them into mages.

So i was reading an older thread on here and a lot of people were either against or with the improvement of paladins in AOE. my stance is that paladins are the best voc for solo hunting and single target attacks(to a point) and are not meant for AOE style of play you got mages for that and adding AOE damage as good as mages will cause you to have an unbalanced system. what i recommend is this Paladins are known for single target and holly damage, they are not known for Aoe damage so how do we work around this? In order to prevent making paladins into tanker mages what i recommend is to strengthen their single target attacks. Higher level paladins should get a type of ammunition that wouldn't hit lower then a certain amount similar to what an sd does(should cost more or less the same) and the minimum hit should rely on distance+level. That way paladins dominate the single target attacks like they are known for. furthermore i believe paladins should also have a type of crossbow/bow or this can be a buff for a minute, similar to Intense Recovery that allows them to increase their attack speed, I was thinking of changing the cool down to 1 second instead of 2 2. be able to attack 1-3 monsters at a time. every archer in every movie in the world has been seen shooting two arrows at a time so why not in tibia. any more then 3 and we start to become tanking mages now lets move on to holy, paladins aren't mages but they do rely on mana for holly and as their main source of Aoe. what i recommend is we get an arrow which only has holy damage they would have the same damage as a drill bolt. or the idea i like better is i would like to "purify" any arrow to add holy damage to it. so i can get a holy crystaline arrow that would hit the same melee damage and add a holy damage. it would deal the same damage as exori san maybe take a the same mana to "purify" Second add a holly burst arrow with 4x4 field ( i would also change burst to the same) and allow them to hit similar to mas san. This way we have a slightly better Aoe but are still be paladins relying on our ammunition.[I am not a big fan of this as it does turn paladins into tanker mages but instead of runes its arrows so maybe its fine?] lastly maybe change the damage of burst arrows to the same as a drill bolt or bring it up to 37.

TLDR: 1 .An Ammunition that has a minimum attack similar to SD but has a higher attack since paladins are known for single attack damage and should be the best at it and should cost the same. 2 .A buff (similar to Intense Recovery) to increase attack rate from 2 seconds to 1 3 . The ability to "purify" ammunition that way any time of amo deals its normal melee but now also has added holy attack similar to exori san.holy crystaline arrow has a nice ring to it 4 . make a holy burst arrow that has 4x4 area field and increase burst to the same and make burst hit slightly higher, i was thinking increasing the attack to 37 attack instead of 27.

Posted Oct 5, 2016, 8:33 PM UTC

176
EnzemoMenera - Hail Vergrond•

I think one of the major things that we need improved is the consistency of DPS. When you can hit super low numbers and miss tons of arrows, even with very high distance fighting, it can get very frustrating. Mages are 100% guaranteed to hit their targets, as are Knights with their AOE spells.

3
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

i never missed an arrow as a 200 pally, but i do agree if we can get a higher consistency of higher damage that would be a great idea as well

1
Nexya•

You might want to put that in paragraphs mate.

Do excuse me if this come across as overly negative, just trying to repond... buuuut:

a lot of people were either against or with the improvement of paladins in AOE

I've yet to see a valid argument against improving paladins AoE. We shouldn't need to turn paladins into mages, but that's how tibia is developed. At high levels every vocation spamdrink manas and cast AoE spells. Unless the game drastically changes there isn't much options.

paladins are the best voc for solo hunting

No idea where you got that idea. Both knights and mages can get higher exp/h.

and single target attacks

They are not. SDs do more damage than arrows, even with the sharpshooter spell.

And while just increasing paladins single target damage might reduce the issues for PvM, it would cause huge balance issues to pvp. Mages trade off their low health for high damage, what would then be the point of playing a mage if paladins would do even more damage?

2
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

**Do excuse me if this come across as overly negative, just trying to repond... buuuut: ** nope i want to hear it all!

I've yet to see a valid argument against improving paladins AoE. We shouldn't need to turn paladins into mages, but that's how tibia is developed. At high levels every vocation spamdrink manas and cast AoE spells. Unless the game drastically changes there isn't much options. i agree i don't want to make paladins into mages, i just want them to able to stand as its own vocation not a middle between knights and mages. emphasizing on their 1v1 would be a great start

paladins are the best voc for solo hunting No idea where you got that idea. Both knights and mages can get higher exp/h. because paladins can hunt in every hunting spot mages and knights can. knights can't do that. I never meant paladins get can get the highest exp/h but have the largest variety of hunting spots.

and single target attacks They are not. SDs do more damage than arrows, even with the sharpshooter spell. single attack as in 1v1 and since they are known for that they should be able to hit the strongest towards a single target even if it cost a ton.

And while just increasing paladins single target damage might reduce the issues for PvM, it would cause huge balance issues to pvp. Mages trade off their low health for high damage, what would then be the point of playing a mage if paladins would do even more damage? trade off their lower health for high damage? with such a large pool of mana and ultimate mana postions, they are basically knights.

i suck at this formatting thing lol, also what about the other ideas of faster hitting buff or the "purifying" idea, any thoughts about that?

1
Nexya•

because paladins can hunt in every hunting spot

Fair enough.

single attack as in 1v1

Yes I understood that you meant it that way. Sudden Death runes still do more damage than arrows and it's mages that are known for high damage single target attacks.

mages are basically knights.

I'm not sure I agree with that. Both knights and paladins can outheal mages that spam ultimate mana potions. They are extremely durable, but so is every vocation.

"purifying" idea, any thoughts about that?

Enchanting but for ranged weapons, would be nice.

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

Yes I understood that you meant it that way. Sudden Death runes still do more damage than arrows and it's mages that are known for high damage single target attacks.

but isn't that what paladins are supposed to be known for?

as far as the pvp i never really played pvp outside of OT so i can't really argue there

1
Nexya•

but isn't that what paladins are supposed to be known for?

Nope? Mages have always done more damage, since the beginning of the game.

1
DiabloII•

because paladins can hunt in every hunting spot mages and knights can. knights can't do that. I never meant paladins get can get the highest exp/h but have the largest variety of hunting spots.

That's not true...

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

How so?

1
DiabloII•

You wont see level 200 paladin hunting hero fortress, oramond west, lizard chosens in dojo or lizard city. While 150+ ms/ed can easily make best out of these spawns avalanching. Annnndddddd you can easily find team hunt as druid/ek which opens up tons of spots but rp will have hard time finding one as its usually the last person needed for th.

2
TheSwedeIrishmanYour friendly neighborhood Statsman!•

and single target attacks They are not. SDs do more damage than arrows, even with the sharpshooter spell.

Maybe if you're level 100...

I just tested on my RP:

10:54 Kim Kong loses 581 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:54 Kim Kong loses 444 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:54 Kim Kong loses 514 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 424 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 522 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 534 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 513 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 401 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:55 Kim Kong loses 381 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:56 Kim Kong loses 358 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:56 Kim Kong loses 408 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:56 Kim Kong loses 401 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:56 Kim Kong loses 512 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 406 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 425 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 494 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 382 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 379 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 490 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:57 Kim Kong loses 334 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:59 Kim Kong loses 361 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:59 Kim Kong loses 438 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:59 Kim Kong loses 471 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:59 Kim Kong loses 402 hitpoints due to your attack.

10:59 Kim Kong loses 365 hitpoints due to your attack.

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

Are those your best hits, in pretty sure you didn't hit those numbers constantly

1
Nexya•

You replied to the wrong person but whatever.

Here is the thing, anecdotal evidence doesn't mean shit ever.

Anecdotal means = this one thing happened to me once and it doesn't match what you're saying so what you're saying is wrong.

Instead we use calculators to get average damage.

Paladin level 500, 130 dist. Mage level 500, mlvl 110.

Average SD damage: 784

Average arrow damage: 504, with sharpshooter 700. Before armor reduction

Huh that was a lot closer than I expected. Unfortunately paladins normally don't use sharpshooter when hunting and never when soloing.

Maybe if you're level 100...

Seeing as mages scales better than paladins, I don't know why you would rather want me to compare highlevel numbers than midlevel numbers.

1
TheSwedeIrishmanYour friendly neighborhood Statsman!•

Average SD damage: 784

In what universe does an RP SD 700+?

And anecdotal evidence normally means "this happened to me but ppl shouldn't expect it to be the truth" - however Tibia isn't exactly a "lucky of the dice" kind of game, it's all based on formulas and as long as you have the necessary situation to reach a certain amount of damage, you will reach that damage.

0
jphillips70•

Aren't mages dominating PvP now? What would be different than a pally instead?

1
Nexya•

Well, and I'm not saying pvp is balanced, but doesn't it make sense that the vocation with the least health does the most damage?

Perhaps if we at the same time gave paladins some major disadvantage, but I'm not into pvp nowadays and should be the last person to ask about this.

1
jphillips70•

Well currently it's the vocation with the least health is really the only player.

Knights and pallies are not good at dropping people. Well not as good as mages :D

1
BeeRayGun•

Paladin on a hardcore pvp world here, people suggest that I go to wars on my 160 Mage rather than my 380 paladin. That's how unreliable my vocation is in pvp

1
TargetGBSpinther•

Everyone would like their vocation to be buffed in some way. I do have little sympathy for the plight of the Paladin. They are high profit with the ability to hunt anything. Not only that they have always been single target high damage, if you want AOE play another vocation...

2
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

But that's not what I am saying, I just want to emphasize paladins single target attack

1
WhiteboydiggityManthrax | Secura•

As a lvl 130 RP with 109 in dist skill equipped with an Umbral Bow with the best ammunition available in the game, it feels kinda underwhelming to get single digit hits from time to time. The same damage could be dealt with a fist hit. Increase the minimum damage please

2
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

Yeah, with a better average would be great. Nothing worse then hitting low double digits

1
ICurshots•

Knights need the improvement their spells cost too much mana and the game play is basicaly spam manas in order to do one spell and hope that you dont die with a full pull.

1
Pointless341•

Or ability to use higher mana potions.

1
ICurshots•

Yup, i really feel weird about this, we are melee fighters but depend so much on mana and the abilities cost too much imo for what they hit. (im talking low knights 150 less dont know about higher level knights)

1
Pointless341•

I think the problem you have is that if you give knights higher mana potions they can wear energy rings and be even more unkillable in pvp at higher levels than they already are. But we need something man, I literally never stop hitting my mana potion hot key in battle.

1
ICurshots•

I hear you, we are the guys that go out with 700 manas for like 40 min hunts. Glad im not the only one thinking there is an issue with knights

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

whats the difference from uhp and ghp, knights don't have a large enough pool of mana to rely on it

1
little_rock•

that would be a problem with the best manas but i dont think strongs would make that much of a difference in pvp and are still a great improvement over normal ones

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

i think knights problem would be solved by allowing them to use higher mana potions, mana is mana.

1
TheSwedeIrishmanYour friendly neighborhood Statsman!•

Paladins needs to come online sooner.

Paladins are in my eyes, both PVE and PVP, useless until they pass 250-300. Before then, they are in this weird spot where they're not tanky enough to act as a secondary blocker (EK) and they're not strong enough to act as a third shooter (mage). They might be great solo hunters but as soon as they have to interact with other players, it becomes painfully obvious that they just don't fit in well just yet.

I think that giving them Ultimate Spirit Potions helped a lot but due to their cost there's definitely still something missing for the lower levels.

Perhaps making an Apprentice's Strike-esque spell for paladins that scales until level 200~ and then tapers off in favour for exori san/con, similar to how Apprentice's Strike is useless for high level mages (exhibit A, 504 MS):

11:15 A cyclops loses 20 hitpoints due to your attack.

11:16 A cyclops loses 13 hitpoints due to your attack.

11:16 A cyclops loses 20 hitpoints due to your attack.

11:16 A cyclops loses 19 hitpoints due to your attack.

11:16 A cyclops loses 15 hitpoints due to your attack.

1
C_Romines22Mage/Sorcerer of Anarchy - Aurera/Dolera•

If you want to use this as a comparison to sd's except you say even better, than the ammunition would have to cost quite a bit more than sd's.

Paladins are pretty fine where they are.

0
Nexya•

I'm not trying to bash you, just genuinely asking.

Don't you think it's a bit unfair that paladins do the least damage in group hunts, are the worst AoEers, don't have a crucial role at the same time that they aren't superior to any others when it comes to soloing?

1
C_Romines22Mage/Sorcerer of Anarchy - Aurera/Dolera•

I just genuinely don't agree. So why reply?

1
Nexya•

Maybe because this is a forum for discussing things? You made a statement without explaining your reasoning for it, of course people are going to question it when there's evidence pointing to the contrary!

In other words, you're full of shit.

1
C_Romines22Mage/Sorcerer of Anarchy - Aurera/Dolera•

Paladins single target damage high at almost no cost. Mages single target damage is great, at a high cost. Paladins are the most profitable solo vocation and are the most self sufficient. Mages don't get shit for exp solo if they have to provide their own cash without buying and selling coins. Paladins are valuable in team hunts with decent damage, and good secondary blockers.

You literally didn't back up any of your arguments with "facts" except saying they do bad damage and are bad bad bad. I don't understand how you're going to attack my thoughts when you literally did the same shit.

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

nothing is set in stone and these are just ideas being thrown around. only reason i say paladins should get the highest single hit among voc is because that is what they are known for. mages are known for the dmg in AOE and their numerous waves to inflict damage, knights can tank and cause high damage in aoe paladins are known for their 1v1 so why not allow them to hit the hardest during 1v1 and make it cost a ton of money so 1k arrows would cost you 100k or something

1
Nexya•

Whenever I use actual reason and logic to question you people who say that paladins are fine, they never reply.

Could it possibly be that you are aware that paladins are NOT fine but just want to keep them weak so you don't lose your advantage?

0
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

people say that if they would to change paladins to hit the best at single target pvp would not be fair but mages already hit higher and better at single target. i say provide an ammo that hits slightly higher then sd and paladins truly become the best at single target and be able to enchant ammo without reducing its attack like enchanting axes

1
C_Romines22Mage/Sorcerer of Anarchy - Aurera/Dolera•

Mages should do the most damage. Single target and aoe. That's why they have such a low health pool. It's high risk high reward. People always just want their vocation to be buffed.

-1
samirmok•

Highest damage single target, highest damage AoE and highest Heal. after lvl 400 you have 2k hp that you can fill all rounds, and any mage with gold can get there in less than a year. Where is the risk?

1
C_Romines22Mage/Sorcerer of Anarchy - Aurera/Dolera•

sounds like you're referring to botted mages to expect level 400 in under a year and auto heal, since they never die

-1
samirmok•

Exactly the oposite my friend, I dont think a botted char would be able to achieve that because it demands you to hunt in high danger places and be smart (and hopefully Cipsdoft would ban someone that uses bot for almost a hole year long).

Cyc (stealth ring) until 30 -> Spikes until 50 -> ormanod minos until 80 -> hero fortress/lizard city/ oramond quaras until 200. Feeling in danger? energy ring (I said "with gold", didn't I?).

There, you can get a lvl 200 playing solo in ~3 months. Repeat these last hunt spots(adding other solo areas like defia and oramond caves), teamhunt whenever the oportunity presents itself (being a druid that means every other day basically) and you get your other 200 levels un 9 months. Free tutorial, you're wellcome.

Now try something similar with an RP and tell me how that worked out for you.

0
Psych0_AsPacerian•

You sure it's not "people always just want their vocation not to lose it's advantages"?

This is how I see it should be:

  • RPs = best single target and decent healing with poor AOE
  • Mages = best AOE and great healing with very good single target
  • Knights = best tank and close range combat with poor healing
1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

well you see in order to be the best at single target we would have to be able to hit the strongest, I would agree if you say paladins are efficient at hunting at single target since it would be the cheapest. but get a paladin and a mage of the same level and a mage will always outhit the paladin. change that to favor the paladin and then paladins will truly be the best at single target and that is the point of this thread make paladins truly the best at single target. and i really want to be able to enchant my crystaline arrows to get a holy crystaline arrow lol

1
SemthOP205 RP 205 EK 100 ED•

high risk high reward? thats cute with a 10k mana pool you can use as health and pots having the giving you the ability to regenerate 1k a mana between attacks

0