r/masseffect•
ExLenne

Question about the auto dialogue in ME3

Spoilers

I've only ever played Paragon/Paragade (heavily favoring Paragon) and even then I found it frustrating how Shepard would go on long tangents and give speeches without me having any control over the tone or content. That's gripe enough but there's also the fact that every bit of it is unquestionably Paragon.

So getting around to my question. I'm about to finish my current playthrough (first with DLC, really enjoyed it as an aside - loved Citadal especially) and am already itching for my next playthrough. I was planning on going Renegon/Renegade but my concern is was the auto dialogue paragon because of my morality rating or is there only one script regardless? Because honestly if my hardcore Renegade Shepard starts making these sappy speeches it'll completely pull me out of the game.

Thanks for any insight, I tried to look this up elsewhere but didn't have much luck.

Posted Oct 6, 2016, 4:19 PM UTC

15
mghjr6•

Auto-dialogue is just a break in the illusion. I really hadn't thought about it until recently, since I've been replaying. In the first game you don't actually have as many conversation choices as it seems; they just made it so that you were prompted every time Shepard had to speak. Most of the time the two options you were presented with in these scenarios led to the exact same dialog.

Long story short, they just cut out the cues for the player that made you think you were effecting the conversation. Two options, like "Really?" on one side and "Go on..." on the other, both took the conversation the same way. Once you realize that, you can see that it's been Auto-dialogue in certain points in conversations all along, but ME3 just removes the prompts.

2
srterpe•

This is true, but there is a powerful illusion of control there that I think many people preferred. I actually think the reason why they cut this out was to enable more advanced digital acting during conversations. If you look at ME1&2 most of the time people are statically standing, just facing each other, for long sections of conversation, which makes sense, because the scene is constantly interrupted by the need for the player to choose a dialogue continuation. In ME3 we have many more complex camera angles and movements during conversations because there is "more frame time" between dialogue continuations.

That's my theory anyway. Still felt like a loss of player agency.

1
mghjr6•

You're right, of course. The question, then, is was it worth it to make the game feel more cinematic? I suppose I never really thought about it since it didn't bother me, but it does seem to bother lots of people. It'll just come down to what a developer is trying to create.

2
HANDSOME_RHYS•

Renegade dialogues are supposed to be different from Paragon. Now I won't say that you'll find 100% different dialogues and different reactions to them from other characters but yes, it will be better than most other games. I would explain to you but it's a long story. For a shorter version, I can only say that despite BioWare being a AAA studio, there is only so much time you have to code all different outcomes (which can literally be in millions) and the intricacies you might be expecting may simply not be able to achieve in practice. These companies too have a limited budget and time and if they keep working in these million outcomes, the game would never come out for you to play, aside from the crazy salaries they'll have to pay the developers month after month.

1
magicwhistle•

Not sure either, but according to this old comment, the sections of "auto" dialogue change according to your Paragon/Renegade score.

1