How Long Did It Take You to Find Your Sunscreen?

Discussion

It's one of the four products the sub recommends finding first, but I suspect many people, through sensitivities, needing sunscreens to meet several demands (no white cast, waterproof, wears well with makeup etc.), or plain laziness/lack of enthusiasm don't find a sunscreen as soon as they should. This isn't a recommendation thread, as there are plenty of great ones already, and if anything I'd lean toward not name-dropping, so much as a reminder for us all that even if you don't get it right the first time, you should keep trying. So how long did it take you in weeks/months and/or different sunscreen attempts?

Posted Oct 7, 2016, 12:51 PM UTC

1645
preciousia•
  • I have 10 kinds of sunscreen atm.
  • 7 new samples to try
  • 2 new ones coming from overseas (Uriage and Curel).

In search of the HG. It's not easy! There is no perfect sunscreen.

See my current sunscreen wardrobe: https://static.wixstatic.com/media/416007_611067711cb24f729bd0d316ef8c85ed~mv2.jpg/v1/fill/w_862,h_378,al_c,lg_1,q_80/416007_611067711cb24f729bd0d316ef8c85ed~mv2.jpg

Summer is coming ... I'm in Australia, the place with the highest per capita skin cancer cases. I'm fair and I burn easily. :(

15
Amandine910•

My honest answer will be obnoxious, but pretty much on the first try, and not AB.

To add context I should mention that I'm allergic to the sun. So sunscreen was always pretty important to me but so was physical coverage.

My first sunscreen was Olay Complete Sensitive SPF 30. I want to say I used it for the better part of a decade. I used to wear a sunhat (my mom is Filipino and has always been big on sun hats) and my dermatologist recommended adding a daily sunscreen with an SPF of 15 or higher. I saw this at the local drugstore and never looked back. I got so many of my girlfriends from college hooked on this bc it was convenient and provided sun protection without any of the yuckiness that was common with Western sun creams at that time.

10 years later I had sun poisoning from a Caribbean vacation. I asked my derm to rec a stronger SPF. He knew I was already using Rx creams for acne and fading spots, and he suggested Elta MD UV Clear SPF 46. It was love at first use. The ingredient deck was amazing AND the formula was so amazingly cosmetically elegant.

I want to say I've been using the Elta for 8-10 years. I think its stupid expensive for a sunscreen, but I don't need a separate moisturizer and its my one-and-done product when I'm in a rush.

In the last 2 years I've been playing with AB sunscreens sheerly for the purpose of skintertainment. I know that's kind of stupid, but I crave variety. So I picked up the Biore Watery and Perfect Milk SPFs. I like to swap them on days when I need something more mattifying than my Elta or when I'm in the mood for their rose scented goodness to give me a pick me up.

7
satisphoriaOPNC42|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|UK•

Obnoxious and non-AB is also welcome, because that is an enviable sunscreen journey. Two sunscreens you used for about a decade each? That's amazing! Congratulations on finding something that really worked for you. I think you've chosen your skintertainment options well, and at least you've stuck to just two extras rather than skipping your tried and true one entirely, it sounds like you've thought through them as purchases and how you use them :)

2
simushahin96•

Hi! Do you use the non-tinted or the tinted version of the Elta MD sunscreen? I'd definitely like to try it some day but keep putting it off because I've read reviews of where the non-tinted version leaves a bit of a white cast, and my skin tone doesn't do too well with tinted sunscreens.

1
natara4NW50|Pigmentation/Pores|Combo|UK•

Ugh this makes me want to go back to using EltaMD I feel like my PIH just faded better when I used it and since it's physical, no wait time! I'm trying to circumvent its price by using a niacinamide serum and seeing if that makes a difference but it might be inevitable that I go back

Reading what I wrote sunscreen never sounded so dramatic!

1
Amandine910•

Personally I think the lactic acid in the formulation has a greater effect on PIH. But lactic acid is my miracle product for fading hyperpigmentation. Niacinamide is definitely a favorite, but I don't find it as effective as a stand alone product.

Maybe try incorporating lactic acid into your routine before going back to Elta? I agree that it's quite pricey, especially for the size.

2
natara4NW50|Pigmentation/Pores|Combo|UK•

As fate would have it I have a 5% Lactic Acid product from DECIEM's The Ordinary. Great I will try that and see what happens! Thank you for the insight! I never noticed that Elta had lactic acid!

1
Milkyway2306NC25|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|SE•

Luvkily the 1st one I got worked for me. But it was definitely not the first thing I bought.

5
lgbtqbbqNC20|Acne/Pigmentation|Oily|US•

Not too many- Hada Labo UV Creamy Gel is my HG but was discontinued (I have 2 bottles of the new version on the way!) Biore Watery Essence is my mostly-HG just not quite as perfect as the HL. I've gone through countless tubes of the Biore since 2014 when I discovered it as my HG.

I had to go through about 5 western sunscreens first though. Luckily, the main reason Asian sunscreens are more elegant is that they contain alcohol AND my skin tolerates alcohol very well. I think that people who struggle with finding a good Asian sunscreen most likely can't tolerate it as well and they find even the ones that feel good can irritate/dry them out :(

But inititally I did go through some sunscreens from Neutrogena (didn't break me out but felt awful and stung my eyes), Elta MD (so expensive), MD Solarsciences (similarly expensive and unbearably greasy.) Those were so unpleasant so when I tried an Asian sunscreen (first Nivea Sport Gel, which is awesome but only SPF 33, and then the Biore, and then the HL) it was like I'd "come home."

3
adinghy•

Honestly? I lucked out. I bought the Biore UV gel after reading that I should be wearing sunscreen everyday and have used it ever since. I have tried a plethora of others but I just get worse CCs from them all and have always gone back to my bae

3
redpen27Dullness/Pores|Dry|US•

Have bought 7 different kinds of sunscreen so far. (Much mockery/confusion from boyfriend that I keep receiving more kinds of sunscreen and not finishing them.) Still nothing I can even stand to use on my face daily (drying, sticky, too light-reflective and makes me look like I'm wearing a weird mask...). I have EXTREME HOPES that #8 is going to be The One.

2
renvoir•

some say 8 is a lucky number, so fingers crossed for The One!

1
cicada_song•

Honestly? Trial and error. I am over 2 years in now and still dabble with it looking for a better thing. Cosmetically elegant vs coverage? Add oily skin, hot and humid and very sunny climate... and my skin flushes when exposed to sun even briefly..

Practically, I like it to be on Amazon (prime preferably). I buy one to try, if it's not great I use it on my neck/chest/arms. Rinse and repeat

Edit: I tried at least 5 for face and same for body, lost count after a while. I lucked out with my first but it got discontinued, been stumbling around since

2
TitanchainRedness|Dry/Dehydrated|US•

It took me five different ones. I've found my usual wear and body sunscreens for summer and winter, but I've only found the waterproof one for summer. I can't seem to find one that doesn't budge in winter without drying out my skin to the point where I'm too scared to sweat because that means wearing it. T_T One of my winter regular HGs was discontinued and I haven't tried it's "replacement" yet to know if it will be good, but my stash is about out, so that will happen soon.

2
ExpectoPropolisAging/Pigmentation|Normal|US•

I bought two different kinds from the same brand for my first AB sunscreen purchase. One was just meh and the other works so well I haven't bothered looking into anything else. I still take note of highly praised products, but seeing how difficult it can be to find one for so many makes me less adventurous with sunscreen.

2
ktrowsNW15-20|Aging/Redness|Dry|US•

I started on AB about five months ago, and I actually just found my HG recently! It's only the third one I've tried, surprisingly. I expected to have a much harder time finding one that was perfect, but I got lucky and stumbled across a thread that described everything I was looking for. I never thought a person could be this excited about sunscreen. My husband thinks I'm crazy.

1
icedbergsPigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Which one is it?

5
hibaobao•

Honey, I still haven't. I can only use mineral filters, but everything so far has been too drying or cakey. It came really close with the Josie Maran sunscreen, but the scent is way too strong.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Sirah81NC20|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|FI•

Not many. First AB sunscreen was great and the experience has only gotten better since then. Out of the ones I've tried maybe 2/8 were not favoured for some reason, and only one is under suspicion of causing pimples. IDK if it makes sense for me to comment on this thread as it's so, but well, I already did.

1
satisphoriaOPNC42|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|UK•

Your comment is totally welcome, I was hoping for a range of responses. Not everyone will struggle to find a sunscreen, and that worry that it may take a while shouldn't put people off starting the search, because it could go well like it did for you or it might be informative about ingredient sensitivities or get people to think about what's in their makeup etc. I just wanted to have a place where we could have a range of voices: those who succeeded right away and those who took longer to find one (or several to cater to varying needs) but continued the search.

3
araindayNC20|Pigmentation/Redness|Dry|CA•

Even before I discovered this sub, sunscreen has been one of my staples for years. I have tried many (Western and AB) over the years; I've never been without some SPF in the last dozen years. I usually have 3 on rotation. My skin has changed over the years as well and now I have rosacea flareups and dryer skin so I need something that is more moisturizing, less alcoholic, and now keep one physical/inorganic on hand for bad skin days. I also have separate body one, usually Western from LRP or Ombrelle. For face, it keeps changing and will probably continue. I like the choice in AB sunscreens. I don't think or need one HG AB facial sunscreen especially since they reformulate often. Trying out and finding a good few brands or line works for me.

1
travelstoinfinityNC42|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|US•

My skin is sensitive to chemical sunscreens so I've been on the hunt for a good physical sunscreen that leaves a minimal white cast. The closest I've gotten to an HG is La Roche Posay's Antihelios Mineral sunscreen which barely has a white cast but ugh the price tag. One day I'll find something affordable that doesn't make me look like a ghost.

1
Almondbitters•

Over a year. Probably closer to 15 months? I typically only try a new one when my current sunscreen runs out unless the product is doing terrible things. I had to try four sunscreens over June and July because I was very allergic to one, one managed to run and irritate my eyes for 8 hours a day despite claiming sweat/water resistance and one gave me lovely oil clogs (on top of rubbing titanium dioxide on everything I love). I was only spared because my current HG came in from Beautius. I might look for a sunscreen that's better for more indoor days at some point but it'll probably be something from the same line.

1
slappy_chan•

I've tried about 4...the 5th one turned out to be the one :))

1
Fasi_Lunari•

I've tried 3 so far. 2 chemical 1 physical. I prefer the physical one over the other two, but don't love how it sits under makeup so I'll probably keep trying.

1
LolaBleu•

I actually found one - Mizon UV Mild spf 35 pa++ - with my first AB haul, which was kind of amazing considering I'd spent more than 10 years trying to find a US/Euro sunscreen my skin could tolerate and getting only cystic acne and contact dermatitis for my trouble.

Anyway, that one was too emollient and not high enough spf/pa for summer so I switched to MISSHA All Around Safe Block Essence Sun spf45 pa+++ for the summer, and it instantly became my HG. I'll have to wear a heavier cream under it during the winter because I find it very slightly drying, but it's so worth it for such a protective and cosmetically elegant sunscreen.

I do have two other sunscreens:

Goodal UV Mild spf 50 pa+++

Bare Minerals Prep Step spf 50

I haven't tried the BM yet, but the Goodal I have to treat with caution because it can be clogging, though I can get away with wearing it if I'm extra diligent about cleansing.

1
romanstigen•

Just got my first Korean sunscreen (Secret Key's Snail Repairing Sun cream) and I must say I'm impressed with how well it melts into my skin and how silky my skin feels afterwards! It's nothing like the awful sunscreen my mom used to make me wear as a kid.

1