CMV: If a parent isn’t going to stay home with the child(ren) until they are school age, they shouldn’t have any.

I see there being zero positives for sending your child to daycare, and I find it to be morally wrong. When you send your children to daycare from birth to age four you are essentially handing off your child to people who make the minimum wage and will teach your kid whatever they were raised to believe; you are no longer a parent, you are a sperm/egg donor that spends 1-2 hours a night and weekends with a kid. If a parent isn’t willing to stay home with the child until they are four because neither are willing to give up career goals, then that couple should not have children.

The argued positives for daycare can easily be combated. Socialization? A stay at home parent has the ability to take their child to a park, bring the child to neighborhood friends or family, set up play dates, etc. It won’t slow them down to not start socializing until half a day preschool anyway. The parent will make more money, not have career bump? This is selfish. Do you think Susie cares if she has 6 American Girl Dolls or a K-mart doll? No, not really. She cares that her mom and dad are there every day. NOTHING replaces the care of a parent. If you are unwilling or unable to stay at home with your child, you shouldn’t have one; the child pays the price for you wanting a career too. If you “aren’t cut out to be/would be a bad parent” if you were a stay at home parent, then don’t be a parent at all. It’s a tough job and it’s not for everyone. Having someone else raise your child is ridiculous and selfish.

From an empirical standpoint, children who spend more time in day care at a very early age are more likely to develop behavioral issues that persist for years afterward. These include aggression and general disobedience.

As a society we watch movies and lament the children of the wealthy who are raised by nannies and never really know their parents. That is essentially what is happening today.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200505/the-trouble-day-care

Hello, users of CMV! This is a footnote from your moderators. We'd just like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please remember to read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! If you are thinking about submitting a CMV yourself, please have a look through our popular topics wiki first. Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

Posted Oct 14, 2016, 12:25 AM UTC

626
tomrhod2ƥ

It seems the study you're relying on has a detractor in another, much larger Norwegian study of 75,000 children:

When the researchers examined the sample using methods identical to those most commonly used in U.S. studies, they produced a similar link between child care hours and behavior. But the researchers took issue with the common approach, which is to compare children from different families who spend varying amounts of time in child care because of family choices. Although earlier U.S. studies using this method tried to control for parent and family characteristics -- such as income and education, mental health and intelligence -- the method leaves open the possibility that differences between families in areas other than child care choices are, in fact, the true causes of behavior problems.

Given the scope the Norwegian data, the researchers were able to compare children who came from the same families but who spent varying hours in child care, effectively resolving the issue of external influences. When they did this, they found no statistical evidence to point to increased behavioral problems. Siblings who spent more time in day care exhibited the same behavior as siblings who spent less time in day care, Dearing said.

In other words, the way the studies in the US work are possibly flawed. It's entirely possible that it's not day care itself causing the issues, but that children who are in day care more often in the US are from families that generally have greater issues with mental health and well-being. There could be multiple reasons for this, but -- speculatively -- children who spend the most time in day care are likely to be in poorer households because one or both parents (if they aren't single parent households) are working so much just to provide for the family. And children growing up in poverty generally have worse mental health.

Another study found the raw number of hours spent with children isn't as important as how the time is used. In fact, we're spending more time with our kids than ever:

Still, the amount of time mothers and fathers spend in child care has been climbing since the 1970s. Fathers’ time has nearly tripled from 2.6 hours a week spent with kids in 1965 to 7.2 in 2010. Mothers’ time with children rose from 10.5 hours a week in 1965 to 13.7 in 2010. In roughly the same period, the share of working mothers with children under 18 rose from 41 percent in 1965 to 71 percent in 2014.

There was one period of development where quantity did make a difference:

The one key instance Milkie and her co-authors found where the quantity of time parents spend does indeed matter is during adolescence: The more time a teen spends engaged with their mother, the fewer instances of delinquent behavior. And the more time teens spend with both their parents together in family time, such as during meals, the less likely they are to abuse drugs and alcohol and engage in other risky or illegal behavior. They also achieve higher math scores.

But it didn't take much, about six hours a week engaged in family time.

So a combination of factors seems to have influenced that study and others like it, and it appears "correlation doesn't equal causation" genuinely applies here.

24
Caffae•

∆ I really liked how you reference another study and I totally agree that "correlation doesn't equal causation" as studies are unable to take into account all the factors that could possibly influence a child's development.

3
tomrhod2ƥ

Thank you, though it's a pity u/negative_zone didn't respond to anything I wrote.

2
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to u/tomrhod (2∆).

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards [​](HTTP://DB3PARAMSSTART { "comment": "This is hidden text for DB3 to parse. Please contact the author of DB3 if you see this", "issues": {}, "parentUserName": "tomrhod" } DB3PARAMSEND)

1
nofftastic15ƥ

What if they're willing, but not able? Many parents don't send their kids to daycare for no reason, many of them do it because they have to go to work to support the family. It's not just selfish career goals, it's survival.

America's birth rates are already catastrophically low. If only couples who could afford to keep a parent home had children, the birth rate would fall even further.

19
FluffySharkBird2ƥ

What if the kid has special needs? I had a stay at home mom at the time who sent me to head start. Why? I needed to socialize with other kids more and I needed therapy for multiple problems. It helped me and it was just a half day.

It's good to have other adults in your kid's life who know more about kids that age than you do, since that's who they work with. The teachers could get a better idea than my parents what behaviors of mine were more normal and what were worrisome. They could tell how advanced my speech was supposed to be.

3
negative_zoneOP•

Child care in the US costs an average of $15000 per year, per infant. Most parents who choose this are not struggling significantly economically, because they could not afford it if they were. Parents who each make a very high income each are often the ones choosing daycare rather than having one parent stay home. In these cases, it would be completely possible for one parent to stay home, or work hours that allow for a rotating schedule of care for the child.

http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/27/why-rich-women-have-great-low-cost-dayca

As for birth rates, I think that we should be concerned with the well being of the children who already exist or will exist before we worry that there aren't enough of them.

1
nofftastic15ƥ

Most parents who choose this are not struggling significantly economically, because they could not afford it if they were.

It's simple math... Say one parent is making $30K/yr. This isn't enough money to support the family, so the other parent gets a job, and makes $25K/yr. Now they can't stay home with the kid, and $15K goes toward daycare, but the net income is $40K/yr, which is enough for the family to get by.

Sure, some people keep their jobs for selfish reasons, but you need to realize that you're judging a whole group of people who can't afford to stay home with the kid.

Yes, we do need to be concerned with the well being of the children who already exist, but if we're not simultaneously concerned with having more children, there won't be any more children to be concerned about... It's not a one-dimensional issue - you can't just ignore birth rates.

15
DragomairAsura•

What about after the 3-4 year period of joblessness?

How easy will it be for that parent to get another job at the same level as before?

1
garaile64•

Most parents who choose this are not struggling significantly economically, because they could not afford it if they were.

Birth control always have at least a small chance to fail. Many of these people won't abort their fetuses.
P.S.: or it's illegal to abort, depending on the location.

1
MurdochAV1ƥ

America's birth rates are already catastrophically low. If only couples who could afford to keep a parent home had children, the birth rate would fall even further.

Is this an issue in a country where population growth is still positive due to immigration?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MurdochAV1ƥ

?

Your source is showing the opposite of what you are saying. The annual growth of the US population is .7%, which is positive. In 2000, the US population was 282 million, and the population in 2016 is 318 million. The chart you linked shows that the rate of growth has not increased since 2000, but the population is still growing.

1
nofftastic15ƥ

Whoops, I misinterpreted that! My bad.

2
garnteller186ƥ

The article you cite quotes (and identifies as such) the vocal opponent to what the vast number of scientists in the field had found - that the impact of daycare is minimal.

You can look at the study that it's all based on:

https://www.nichd.nih.gov/research/supported/seccyd/Pages/overview.aspx

There is also a very evenhanded article in Slate. It talks about the pros and cons, which seem to be largely a wash.

Or you can look at this NIH study which concluded:

Children in exclusive maternal care did not differ systematically from children in child care.... The relations of child care variables to outcomes did not vary consistently as a function of family income, quality of home environment, child gender, or ethnic group.

The bottom line is that there is no clinical evidence that daycare is significantly harmful to children.

However, the impact of having higher-earning parents throughout their lives could be.

7
StratfordAvon4ƥ

So, your view seems to be particularly narrow in parts.

The argued positives for daycare can easily be combated. Socialization? A stay at home parent has the ability to take their child to a park, bring the child to neighborhood friends or family, set up play dates, etc.

This doesn't really replace the social development of child care. Young children need predictable routine. You are not always going to find the same kids at the local park and what if you don't have friends or family with young children?

Children need a lot of practice to learn to socialize. How to react when your friend takes your toy. How to react when your friend plays with someone else. If I spent 30 minutes every day shooting a hockey puck, will it make me a good player?

It won’t slow them down to not start socializing until half a day preschool anyway.

This is actually pretty false. Sure, they'll catch up eventually - probably - but the children that do the best in kindergarten are the emotionally and socially developed ones. That's great that your kid can read already, but he won't talk to other kids.

The parent will make more money, not have career bump? This is selfish. Do you think Susie cares if she has 6 American Girl Dolls or a K-mart doll?

Money doesn't just go to dolls. Two working parents can mean a better quality of life.

Wait... where are all the other benefits of daycare refuted? Emotional development, language development, physical development? Learning opportunities that only child care centres can provide? Are you not concerned about the whole child?

From an empirical standpoint, children who spend more time in day care at a very early age are more likely to develop behavioral issues that persist for years afterward. These include aggression and general disobedience.

I read the article you attached and was interested to note how his earlier findings were ignored due to "bad science". There was also the interesting note at the bottom that said the behavioural issues were noted by the parents. I'm sure there's some merit to his work, but there sure seems like some flaws, too.

Here is another study Its summary reads

The advantage of centre care was tested directly and was related to better cognitive and language development. The positive outcomes of centre care are bolstered by data that seem to indicate that more time spent in centre care and earlier entry into centre care may be positively related to children’s development. The centre care is associated with better early language development. Results were obtained after statistically removing possible influences of the overall quality of child care so that the effects of type of care could be viewed independently of its quality.

Other sources: Am Early Childhood Educator

6
empurrfekt6ƥ

If a parent isn’t willing to stay home with the child until they are four because neither are willing to give up career goals, then that couple should not have children.

What about parent who can't afford to not work?

What about parents who have extended family (usually grandparents) to help when they are working?

What about parents who stagger work schedules so they can usually be home, but have to use a day care 1 or 2 days a week?

3
negative_zoneOP•

So this CMV was mostly directed at parents who use daycare 5 days a week to watch their child when both parents are working standard day jobs. Obviously any harm that would be caused by this is greatly reduced if the children are at home with another family member or are only at day-care for 1 or 2 days. To clarify, if a parent or parents need to send their kid to daycare for the entirety of a work week until the children are of school age because they refuse to stop working, then they should not have kids.

-I will try to address the topic of economic need in another comment.

1
55555123698744ƥ

My parents worked when I was a kid. Because of that, they were able to buy a house in the suburbs, send me to a decent public schools, and were even able to send me to college. I am extremely glad that they did that, and am much better off.

As I kid, did I want my parent's love and affection? Yes, absolutely, and I got it. Love and affection are not the same thing as being around all the time. I actually enjoyed getting to play a bit without my parents watching. Did daycare shape my moral beliefs; not at all, especially compared to school. And why exactly should kids not learn anything about society's expectations and values in addition to the parents? And I didn't suffer in the least from aggression and general disobedience. Can you explain to me why it would be better off if I didn't exist?

3
55555123698744ƥ

You might argue you can't tell the way things are supposed to be from one case. However, as a general argument, look at how humans evolved: in bands of hunter gatherers. Two things about those bands: everyone has to leave and work if people are going to eat, fathers hunting and mothers gathering. Second of all, no family is isolated, everyone is part of the band, and the child grows about in society surrounded by other people.

Do you know how lethal allergies have become vastly more prevalent as kids are now raised is super-safe, sterile environments and immune systems that are supposed to fight germs go haywire at start attacking anything. I feel like your proposal to have kids continuously surrounded by their parents and not interacting with others on their own is the kind of the emotional equivalent of a clean, sterile room: good, but don't get carried away.

1
TezzMuffins5ƥ

Unfortunately for your point, you make an extremely refutable hypothesis: "I see there being zero positives for sending your child to daycare." This is impossible to defend. Normally daycares have 4+ children per worker. Encouraging a division of labor allows the parent of the child to make more income and have better career opportunities while maximiing the economic value of the caretaker. Individual parents with one child each probably will have to work minimum wage anyways because not many employers allow children at work. In fact, employers have a company or school-wide healthcare in order to maximize the economic output of their workers. This alone is a positive, which directly refutes your hypothesis.

On a more moral/sociological level, most research indicates that the natural survival structure for millions of years was humans lived in tribes. Mothers would give the child to elders who were too old to hunt or travel during the day, and the child would be raised by those elders in a division of labor while the parents do activities impossible for either the elders or the child. Eventually the parents would come back with food, feed the children and sleep with them. This is daycare at its most fundamental.

Also, the idea that the fact daycare workers make minimum wage has absolutely no rhetorical point and indicates some bias towards the qualifications or character of the worker that is alarming. As a minimum wage worker who wants to be a father, it's also vaguely offensive.

2
MMAchica•

Hey, I started Montessori shortly before I turned 3 and I loved it! Well, I loved it after I freaked out the first day but that's all part of the process. The people were really nice and we did a lot of fun stuff; lots of singing and duck-duck-goose type stuff that I wouldn't have gotten at home. They even had a fireman come and talk to us and they took us behind the counter at McDonald's to see what we were too short to see at the time. Formative stuff, man, formative stuff.

I freely acknowledge that I went to a really awesome preschool and that a lot of them are dumps run by uninterested minimum-wagers.

1
monsterbuttfart•

"If you are unwilling or unable to stay at home with your child, you shouldn’t have one; the child pays the price for you wanting a career too. If you “aren’t cut out to be/would be a bad parent” if you were a stay at home parent, then don’t be a parent at all. It’s a tough job and it’s not for everyone. Having someone else raise your child is ridiculous and selfish."

Having this strict criteria would deprive many children of being born. If a child who attends daycare doesn't kill himself, he's indicated a preference for living over not existing. Most choose to live. To deny someone existence out of concern that he/she may have behavior problems doesn't seem fair.

1
Pinewood742ƥ

Why does this stop at school age?

Doesn't your argument also apply to kids between the ages of 4 and 15-18(depending on parent's education)?

If you're not willing to stay at home and school your child, then you're just a sperm/egg donor and all that? Parents can teach their child 1 on 1 (or 1 on 4) better than the waste of time that is public school. Socialization? You've got boy scouts, 4-H, and the parks and the like that you discussed.

1
Pinewood742ƥ

The parent will make more money, not have career bump? This is selfish. Do you think Susie cares if she has 6 American Girl Dolls or a K-mart doll? No, not really.

No, but I imagine Susie will care that her college is paid for, that she has two parents who worked hard and saved during their younger years so they can retire when she's 15 and attend all of her high school basketball games. Whether Susie was in daycare or not is not going to matter 20 years down the road when they can help Susie out with a down payment on a house or 40 years down the road when they don't have to move in with Susie because they saved well for their retirement.

Granted, most of these things are achievable for a lot of households whether one parent stays at home or not (and completely unachievable for other households), but there are households (in the middle) where they would be financially stretched with a stay at home parent and unable to build meaningful wealth and it might be better for Susie in the long run if she goes to daycare.

Obviously, there needs to be a life/work balance here. Only 1-2 hours every night seems a little extreme. Most people aren't working until 7 or 8 (assuming 9 bedtime) every single day and I would agree that may be not good for a child. We're generally talking about someone getting home at say 430 so they have a solid evening to spend with their child. Or they work "9-5" so they can spend some quality time in the morning with their child.

1
kingpatzer16ƥ

You've noted only daycare.

Not all parents who continue working send their children to daycare. They may also send their child to be cared for by a retired relative, have a live-in relative, hire an in-home nanny or au pere, or engage in shared care responsibilities with another family.

Do you think all other methods of continuing working while having children are damaging to the child and immoral?

1
Gladix11ƥ

I see there being zero positives for sending your child to daycare, and I find it to be morally wrong.

Daycares exist in order so people can do it. It's a service. You can make the same argument about home schooling. "Parents who are not able to teach the kid themselves should not have the kid ...." It's just ridiculous train of thoughts.

you are no longer a parent, you are a sperm/egg donor that spends 1-2 hours a night and weekends with a kid.

Doesn't make any sense. Living with parents axiomatically means they will spend more time with the kid.

If a parent isn’t willing to stay home with the child until they are four because neither are willing to give up career goals, then that couple should not have children.

No it's because having another income is much more valuable than staying at home with kids. The daycare teachers won't teach the kids some revolutionary secrets. They won't corrupt the kids. Hell, I don't even remember most of my daycare. And the additional income of my parents allowed my family to have a family home. Without it we would still live in rent.

A stay at home parent has the ability to take their child to a park, bring the child to neighborhood friends or family, set up play dates, etc

What a coincidence. Daycare is full of children who are going regularly to parks and set up play dates.

The parent will make more money, not have career bump? This is selfish. Do you think Susie cares if she has 6 American Girl Dolls or a K-mart doll?

Suzie might notice not having a home.

NOTHING replaces the care of a parent.

Naive nonsense. Daycares and schools did that for hundreds of years. And guess what. Every society with those flourishes. And every society with parents having to teach kids everything stagnates.

the child pays the price for you wanting a career too.

What is better. A family where kid goes into daycares, but the family has no financial issues and has a nice home. Or family where parents just lost their house and car?

From an empirical standpoint, children who spend more time in day care at a very early age are more likely to develop behavioral issues that persist for years afterward.

Bullshit, citation needed.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1