CMV: If a parent isn’t going to stay home with the child(ren) until they are school age, they shouldn’t have any.
I see there being zero positives for sending your child to daycare, and I find it to be morally wrong. When you send your children to daycare from birth to age four you are essentially handing off your child to people who make the minimum wage and will teach your kid whatever they were raised to believe; you are no longer a parent, you are a sperm/egg donor that spends 1-2 hours a night and weekends with a kid. If a parent isn’t willing to stay home with the child until they are four because neither are willing to give up career goals, then that couple should not have children.
The argued positives for daycare can easily be combated. Socialization? A stay at home parent has the ability to take their child to a park, bring the child to neighborhood friends or family, set up play dates, etc. It won’t slow them down to not start socializing until half a day preschool anyway. The parent will make more money, not have career bump? This is selfish. Do you think Susie cares if she has 6 American Girl Dolls or a K-mart doll? No, not really. She cares that her mom and dad are there every day. NOTHING replaces the care of a parent. If you are unwilling or unable to stay at home with your child, you shouldn’t have one; the child pays the price for you wanting a career too. If you “aren’t cut out to be/would be a bad parent” if you were a stay at home parent, then don’t be a parent at all. It’s a tough job and it’s not for everyone. Having someone else raise your child is ridiculous and selfish.
From an empirical standpoint, children who spend more time in day care at a very early age are more likely to develop behavioral issues that persist for years afterward. These include aggression and general disobedience.
As a society we watch movies and lament the children of the wealthy who are raised by nannies and never really know their parents. That is essentially what is happening today.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200505/the-trouble-day-care
Hello, users of CMV! This is a footnote from your moderators. We'd just like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please remember to read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! If you are thinking about submitting a CMV yourself, please have a look through our popular topics wiki first. Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!
Posted Oct 14, 2016, 12:25 AM UTC
It seems the study you're relying on has a detractor in another, much larger Norwegian study of 75,000 children:
In other words, the way the studies in the US work are possibly flawed. It's entirely possible that it's not day care itself causing the issues, but that children who are in day care more often in the US are from families that generally have greater issues with mental health and well-being. There could be multiple reasons for this, but -- speculatively -- children who spend the most time in day care are likely to be in poorer households because one or both parents (if they aren't single parent households) are working so much just to provide for the family. And children growing up in poverty generally have worse mental health.
Another study found the raw number of hours spent with children isn't as important as how the time is used. In fact, we're spending more time with our kids than ever:
There was one period of development where quantity did make a difference:
But it didn't take much, about six hours a week engaged in family time.
So a combination of factors seems to have influenced that study and others like it, and it appears "correlation doesn't equal causation" genuinely applies here.
∆ I really liked how you reference another study and I totally agree that "correlation doesn't equal causation" as studies are unable to take into account all the factors that could possibly influence a child's development.
Thank you, though it's a pity u/negative_zone didn't respond to anything I wrote.
Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to u/tomrhod (2∆).
^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards [](HTTP://DB3PARAMSSTART { "comment": "This is hidden text for DB3 to parse. Please contact the author of DB3 if you see this", "issues": {}, "parentUserName": "tomrhod" } DB3PARAMSEND)