What is wrong with hard mode?

PTS

A simple question because I genuinely want to know.

If challenging is too difficult for people, why don't they want to play the game on hard mode?

You still get loot at the same (max) level as challenging, just less of it. You can still gear up through hard mode, it'll just take you longer. Is it too long? Do you feel as though you don't get enough loot? Is it boring?

What is it? I want to understand it because I just don't get why anyone who complains that Challenge mode is too hard doesn't just play a lower difficulty.

Posted Oct 14, 2016, 9:01 PM UTC

927
KittCloudKicker•

I wish I understood this too... Gear up at your own pace. What's so wrong with that?

7
Crusty_IrishmanCrusty_Irishman [Browncoat]•

Rewards. The level of rewards is too low on hard

4
mr_cartmanez•

That's reasonable. But then my next question is, since I see a chance in you to finally get a reasonable answer, what's with the recent push to make everything soloable and rewards as good as those in group content?

You can either check my comment history for an expanded question or try to answer based on these short notes:

  1. Why is everything expected to be soloable by anyone (except for incursions, of course. Those are just irrelevant and have no reason to be done beyond once) in a game that is always online and is about cooperation and group tactics at its core? Challenge mode, UG, hardest tasks besides incursions. All of these have become soloable, then one person comes out with a video arguing the point of that and gets a barrage of insults and death threats?

  2. How is it reasonable that rewards are same level (don't care that there are more rewards. It doesn't matter with the way RNG works)?

  3. What is there to progress to now that loot can be obtained from anywhere without ever stepping foot into incursions/harder content? How does progression look now compared to before? My understanding is:

Before: Missions to 30, hard/challenge to better gear score, incursions. UG mixed in there.

Now: Missions to 30, Missions after 30 on Challenge, fuck Incursions and UG because why bother when they are inefficient, artificially difficult and are basically what everyone complained about in 1.3 only now they can be completely ignored.

If you could give me your perspective, I'd be very grateful to finally hear something else besides "everything is soloable cuz I paid and that's how I want to play. Your group content becoming too easy ain't my problem, fucking elitist".

1
Crusty_IrishmanCrusty_Irishman [Browncoat]•

Well I like to be able to solo, but everything shouldn't be soloable, in my opinion. To a certain extent, at least half of the content should be soloable, because you do have that ability in the 1-30 build. Incursions - group only Weekly HVTs - group only Higher difficulty mission settings - group There should be elements for all to play this game. I do solo sometimes as well, however I have specific expectations on what I can and cannot do solo. Many of us do ... The most vocal minority do not. Certain areasshould not be soloable.

As far as the push for soloable content ... You start out solo in this game, the opening is predicated on a solo agent. The chopper crash cut scene - solo agent. The game is for 1 player; 2-24 on network. Making all content non-soloable would be false advertising. I Lone Wolf sometimes because I don't always have the capability to team up. I like to team up because I enjoy the camaraderie. I would like to be able to solo some content, but i too worry that most all will be soloable. Which defeats the purpose of teaming up.

Loot... If I'm playing hard content I should be gearing up for challenging (1.4 terms: tier 1 gearing up for tier 2 gearing up for tier 3 gearing up for tier 4), not just getting gear that is on my level. If I go into the 201-230 DZ, I don't want 182 weapons and 191 gear sets ... That isn't going to help me move to 231+, no matter how big my group is.

For the record, I agree with Skill Up. It shouldn't be a cake walk to go through a challenging underground mission easily solo.

7
mr_cartmanez•

Division you start solo. WoW you start solo. ESO you start solo. Yet, no one in these games besides Division is asking for same rewards in trivial solo content as end-game group rewards provide. Or calling those who reasonably argue for better quality rewards at highest difficulty "elitist". The difference here is that multiplayer has become meaningless, just like you said, since same rewards can be obtained in easier, solo activities.

I have absolutely nothing against solo play, as I've said multiple times. What I am concerned with is why do they get same quality loot? Why can't it be like Destiny or WoW where you start solo with choice to run as a group, get to end and end of rewards levels going up and have to move on to group content (e.g. Destiny stops at 340 for story content that can be soloed, 365 for strikes, 385 for Raid. There is of course PvP, but that's all group content. I'm sure we can agree on that).

With all that said, my final concern is what is there to progress towards? As shown above, in Destiny progression has a meaning. You progress to do end-game group activities that give better rewards in which you would be inadequate without some mid-level group action between finishing story and jumping into raid. Here, you don't need to do anything, but do missions on different difficulty levels and you still get best level gear available to you. This is what I have a problem with on top of what you said yourself - this approach defeats the purpose of team play which is the core concept of this game that is going to be lost. Never mind the fact that suddenly everyone forgot the main issue with 1.3 - inflated difficulty in unrewarding, repetitive activities and now it's fine as long as it's just half of endgame content (incursions/UG mostly).

Edit: a question I forgot, but find fitting and would like to ask, since we are actually having a meaningful discussion here so far. Why not make everything above hard have mandatory matchmaking? I know you said that all content should to be accessible to solo players, but that is already not true with incursions. With challenging and above, everyone still gets their whole game accessible to them (except for Incursions) and they can play it however they want - alone, together, blindfolded, hands tied, upside down, whatever they enjoy. And those who play it as it was advertised get that same content with another layer of difficulty on it that prepares them for Incursions with familiar maps, but need for tactical action and role fulfillment. The rewards can even be all the same, just stop it at 240 or something for Hard and go higher for Challenge/Incursions. Tell me what you think about this approach.

2
Crusty_IrishmanCrusty_Irishman [Browncoat]•

True (never played WoW or ESO) ... I can't say what those fans are or are not asking for. However, neither of those games are looter shooters, like the Division is. Division really is closer to D3 than the others. A lot of what you are reading around here is salt, and somewhat "elitist" views sometimes. Multiplayer isn't meaningless at this time, but it is coming dangerously close to it in the PTS (I'm not in the PTS, so I have no firsthand knowledge.

There should be equal loot to a certain extent - why are you going to punish someone who solos? I've read plenty of reasons why solo content should be available, hell I've even given it before. It's not going to be like Destiny or WoW because this game isn't Destiny or WoW. Destiny has a designated PvP, WoW is an MMORPG - Division has no designated PvP (only PvPvE) and it is not an MMORPG. Because of those reasons, you have to have a better balance with/for loot and NPC health/damage, you have to cast a wider net. However, greater difficulty should improve the rewards ... but until/unless you are going to create a designated PvP only environment, you can't have staggered rewards. There is a matter of fair play that must be considered as well.

Personally, I think (and hope for) some significant end game situations - something more than just the Incursions at hand. The "massive" raid ideas tht have been laid out before (the Intrepid and the Museum of Natural Science (?) ) are great end-game ideas that I hope we can see in some manner. Until then, it should be higher level content that encourages group play ... Heroic, for example, while scaled terribly should be group content while Challenging (for example) should be soloable, but near-lethal in doing so. However, the rewards have to be something other than "next level" gear ... because of the DZ problem. I am hoping that much of the "challenging" content issues are handled with the world tiers.

But the DZ gives us the problem ... if I run a bunch of endgame, high difficulty content (let's say I run Incursions at the highest difficulty) and I get "better" gear than a solo player gets from challenging content, and we meet in the DZ - then odds are I'm going to run through him. I'm not necessarily better than him, but my gear is. Therein lies the imbalance that fucks this game up. The DZ is a great idea, but the execution is horrifying in many ways. That imbalance throws everything off.

I don't like the "mandatory" matchmaking, because it does go against the "1 player" advertised capabilities. That said, going past a certain level of difficulty should be near-lethal for solo players. There are some who will still try (and succeed) to conquer that content. And if they succeed, they should be rewarded. But forcing someone to do what they may not want to (for whatever reasons - GS elitism, lack of mic, living conditions prohibit use of mic, etc). There has to be a balance.

4
WhiskeyrichPC•

Your original questions assumed certain leanings that are revealed here. I'm not judging, but let's be up front and honest. You feel that some content should be gated behind group play as it is in MMOs like WoW and GW2. (I've never played Destiny, being a PC player.)

I agree with your thought, but from a different perspective. I only play solo (99%), because I don't PUG and have 3 friends total in game. I do not feel like I am missing out by not doing incursions, especially after hearing comments from people here. All other content is accessible to me, just at normal or hard content levels.

There is one issue in comparing WoW, GW2, SWToR or any other MMO with The Division when talking about solo vs group play. MMOs or RPGs have huge amounts of content to explore and play either solo or in a group. There is a ton to do before you get to grinding things like reputation or mats. PvP areas are in completely separate instances (if you chose a PVE server)

The Division has an extremely small accessible map, with a decent portion dedicated to PVP/PK. So I have no issue locking the top difficulties behind group play.

Loot quality is a different story. Very high loot quality must be available to solo players or they will leave the game and move on to something else. Please note: this is one of the reasons why TD has lost so many players in its first 6 months.

My question back to you is, why should the best quality loot be locked behind group play? If I grind 10 hours to your 1 hour of group play, why shouldn't I have the opportunity to get the best quality of loot in game? Why is my time worth less than yours? And why do you care what level of loot I am able to get?

For all the haters: I am not suggesting loot be handed to me. I am suggesting that solo grinding should eventually equal group play.

edit: Both WoW and GW2 give the solo player the ability to grind or craft for high tier gear. As a matter of fact, in Legion one solo quests for their top quality weapon to begin game play.

edit 2: Sprint vs Marathon might be a good analogy to Solo grind vs group play. Both are hard, just in different ways.

1
BurningPlaydoh•

No, its really not.

0
Crusty_IrishmanCrusty_Irishman [Browncoat]•

In 1.3? Yeah it is ... 163s aren't worth it

1
BurningPlaydoh•

Why would I or OP be referring to 1.3? The question is why in PTS/1.4 people wouldnt just play Hard if Challenge is too difficult.

2
mr_cartmanez•

Challenge mode is too hard doesn't just play a lower difficulty.

Or plays it with a group as intended... I don't understand this recent push to make everything soloable and rewards for soloing it as good as the ones for hardest end-game content. Been looking for answers to that myself all day and just realized while reading your post that they should just lock anything above hard to matchmaking. Both no more cries for making challenging simpler and no more questions on why this game suddenly has become a solo shooter and not a co-op tactical online RPG it was advertised as.

4
thebestaround1000•

This.

Division is an online rpg made to be played with other people. If you want a single player game then go play one of the million single player rpgs.

0†
[deleted]•

[removed]

-1
R3g1st3rTh1s•

In 1.4? Nothing, I have mostly been playing PTS content on hard for this exact reason. Ofcause I have tried challenging in WT4 to see if I could do it, but for recreative play I'm happy free roaming or doing hard content no that I can actually progress, even if only slowly compared to doing challenging and heroic content, which I can still do in groups...

Personally I think the perfect fit is between week 3 and 4 iterations, but I'll live if week 4 is what we end up with, even if I want HOK, ammo and droprates from week 3.

My only gripe with the PTS still is that armor cap appears unreachable on gear alone and out of cover even when armor is rolled on all pieces and mods that can get it...

1
faern•

Because RNG, how you beat rng you get as much loot as possible and filter out the bad stuff. If you not getting as much loot as possible you are not progressing as fast you can.

Going by that logic why not nerf challenging loot, if they need BIS to complete challenging why reward them useless stuff?

1
manloveworldSmart Cover•

Because noobs get everything.

0