r/Xcom•
Forefal1

[LW] Is battle rifle better than assault?

Long War

It seems early with 4 damage assault rifles, jumping to 5 damage is big. Does everyone go battle rifle early to get this? Curious what others might be doing.

Posted Oct 16, 2016, 2:39 PM UTC

2121
Paradigmist•

The loss of speed and aim penalty after moving make it situational, as it should be. I mostly save it for high-aim non-flanker soldiers that are my primary damage dealers -- mostly infantry.

18
Tadtiger13•

The aim penalty also applies after Light Em Up or Lock n Load IIRC, meaning the aim penalty hits infantry hard, especially OW infantry.

2
Paradigmist•

Yeah, but if you have high aim its not impossible to overcome. Shoot + Command/Psi/Suppress isn't a bad combo either. Especially if you're rolling critfantry, the bonus damage (possibly comboed with cover destruction?) is just too good to pass up.

Infantry are, in my experience, the only real non-flankers with decent enough aim to compensate.

6
Tadtiger13•

If I have a critfantry, I want them shooting at targets in cover twice (or three times) a turn. They need all the aim they can get. 1 bonus damage also isn't that much when you're using pulse.

1
Paradigmist•

Heavy rifles do 1.5 more damage on crit than assault rifles -- fired twice, that's a difference of 3 damage.

The first shot has the same accuracy no matter what, and I'll make the overgeneralization that a specced critfantry has about a 50% crit rate on unflanked, uncovered enemies. We'll let x be the expected hit chance (all modifiers except for the battle rifle second action penalty). I'm using average damage values from [this table](http://ufopaedia.org/index.php/Primary_Weapons_(Long_War\)). Let's do some math!

Ballistic: 2* (4(x/2) + 6(x/2)) = (5(x/2) + 7.5(x/2)) + ((5((x/2)-.05)) (7.5((x/2)-.05)))

solution: x = 0.625/2.5 = 0.25 (heavy rifles have higher average damage than assault rifles when firing twice if CTH>25%)

Laser crossover: x = 0.302

Gauss crossover: x = 0.35

Pulse crossover: x = 0.40

Plasma crossover: x = 0.45

Now, 50% crit chance is a pretty big assumption, but it's pretty clear from this table that the potential average damage output becomes cost-effective at a pretty low hit percentage. That crossover hit percentage goes up a bit as you increase weapon tier (because the increased crit damage goes down as a fraction of total damage), but it's still solidly below 50% even for plasma. You might be able to run the numbers for a lower crit% and find a different crossover point for lower-level critfantry, but I think these numbers largely speak for themselves.

3
UristImiknorris•

Early on, Shoot+Steady is pretty strong. It's my preferred tactic for the dreaded March Transport.

1
Scoobz1961•

No infantry leaves home without a battle rifle. You get free one tier of weapon upgrade for the cost of 1 mob and situationally 10 aim. I like to take executioner on infantry, which makes it even better. Its really great when floaters show up. Its even better once you have lasers as the upgrade to gauss is costly and your infantry start getting high hit percentages.

I wish Rocketeers could equip those two, the synergy would be phenomenal. Its already great with RfA medics.

7
Vironomics•

The battle rifle slows you down, and is pretty awful to fire after moving (-10 accuracy if you use your yellow move to shoot it). This means it really isn't good for moving to flank, which is an important early strategy. If you blow up cover, then moving to flank is less important, but the +1 damage is less relevant as well. So really, what the battle rifle is best at is putting shots into enemies behind cover, which just isn't what I want to be doing early game. Sometimes I'll put a battle rifle on an Infantry and have them shoot, then steady weapon. Even there, though, there's enough situations where I want to move my Infantry and then shoot that I've almost completely moved away from using battle rifles early.

It's a bit different when your troopers are more accurate and can sometimes afford -10 accuracy when they must move, but it's just not the sort of weapon I want to put on a squaddie.

6
HeiroftheVoid•

The problem I always ran into with them is that the damage bonus becomes smaller relative to the base damage as weapon tiers improve, so by the time I have a decent body of troops accurate enough to be conformable using it, +1 damage isn't all that much relative to the more-constant penalties.

5
Vironomics•

Heavy Laser Rifles are about the sweet spot, I'd agree. The damage boost is still meaningful vs. Mutons etc., and the innate aim boost offsets the accuracy penalty on moving. You're also more likely to have SCOPEs that can also work against that accuracy penalty. I'll usually build a single Heavy Laser Rifle, resources permitting, whereas I'll completely avoid any heavy rifles earlier or later.

5
HeiroftheVoid•

Yeah. I was thinking that if they got more damage at Gauss tier and up, they might be worth using.

I feel like the game shifts in favor of the extreme ends of the weapon scale towards endgame, especially once the plasma SMG increases the mobility bonus to +4. I've had scenarios where almost half by team is MECs, with a HEAT Gunner and everyone else has Plasma SMGs.

6
JoINrbs•

It's almost always better on any class which is going to shoot with a rifle regularly.

3
Blastom•

Depending on the difficulty. On brute and impossible, the +1 damage can greatly increase the chance to one hit a thin man and guarantee a kill on a sectoid. While on normal or classic, assault rifle's enough before laser.

2
Ornan•

I tried it out and tried to get into it but in the end I ended up deciding if I was going to use a gun that hampered my ability to move and shoot I'd use a LMG.

1
stephanovich•

I've never bothered to use it because of the drawbacks. The regular AR does fine for me.

1
GlasgowScienceMan•

I give it to infantry and maybe overwatch medics, but in most cases AR or carbine is your go-to.

1
gimrah•

I use battle rifle on infantry at ballistic stage. 3-5 damage going to 4-6 damage means your odds of one-shotting a 5HP floater (say) goes from 1 in 3 to 2 in 3, for example. Meanwhile your infantry still has pretty poor aim so it makes sense to use steady a lot and take fewer, better shots. Early on I also put a smoke grenade on infantry as another option instead of taking a bad shot.

But that's my only use. After ballistics I find the weight and loss of accuracy outweighs the decreasing relative damage benefit.

The exception could be all-OW medics with RfA. Trouble is I think that's a weak build: takes too long to get going and too situational when it does.

I actually really like carbines. I make OW rocketeers, give them a carbine, take the ranger perk, then you get a highly accurate assault rifle equivalent. I also put them on hybrid medics (who have RR and opp but no other OW perks).

SMGs for people that don't shoot much (engies).

So I only use assault rifle on infantry really.

1
CARDBOARDWARRIOR•

They're useful at the laser tech level because your soldiers will have enough aim when coupled with the laser bonus to offset the aim penalty. The bonus damage really helps against mutons, or on higher difficulties.

I retire them once the aliens start getting boatloads of innate defense, however. At that point in the game I'm usually starting to feel the mobility squeeze that comes with titan armor + tactical rigging, and plasma weapons should have been developed. I don't steady my assault rifles often, so the plasma battle rifle bonus doesn't do much for me.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-8