Is a SMaSH still a SMaSH if I add some oats to the grain bill?
I plan on brewing a few SMaSH recipes but was wondering if I can add oats and it still be a SMaSH since technically oats aren't malted.
Posted Oct 17, 2016, 1:48 PM UTC
I plan on brewing a few SMaSH recipes but was wondering if I can add oats and it still be a SMaSH since technically oats aren't malted.
Posted Oct 17, 2016, 1:48 PM UTC
If you want to introduce one specialty malt or adjunct in addition to your single (base) malt and your single hops, then "brewing on the ones" may be a more suitable concept for you. http://www.ahaconference.org/wp-content/uploads/presentations/2012/1616-17%20Brewing%20on%20the%20Ones%20-%20Drew%20Beechum.pdf
That was a good read! Gave me something to think about for my first 2017 brewday. Thanks!
Then it would be a SMaSHaO wouldn't it?
I'd say it's not, since that would be a TMaSH hehe.
Just add 4 more malts and turn it back into a SMaSH.
DMaSH, since we're talking tuples here.
I see a whole new array of creative *aSH and/or *a<letter to refer to a number here>H beer titles soon :P
On that note, a Single, Sex/Sep-tuple malt / Single, Sex/Sep-tuple Hop can also be a SMaSH and that would be a bit rediculous :p
Strictly speaking: No. SMaSH is defined as 1 malt and 1 hop and no other "major ingredients." Basically nothing other than finings, water chemistry, fermcap, Irish Moss etc. Essentially nothing that's going to contribute any flavor or fermentables of its own. Even toasting or otherwise modifying a portion of the malt would make it not-a-SMaSH in the eyes of most.
But unless you're entering it into a SMaSH only competition or something who cares?
Assuming you're only adding 5-10% the oats would likely have a small overall impact on malt character and hop expression if you're just doing this for ingredient testing purposes.
SMaSH is just a conceit for encouraging people to keep things simple to let the base ingredients come through. You can use it as a tool as you see fit.
I'm calling the police.
Nope. Most would agree:
Okay then. I'm new to the concept of a SMaSH so I was curious about how strictly defined it was.
No, the concept of smash is that the flavor comes from one variety of malt and one variety of hops. Fruit, oats, wheat, rye, etc break that concept.
ok cool, thanks for clearing that up :)