Is it possible to conserve energy without conserving momentum?

Physics

I had a thought about the supposed reactionless drives that have been making headlines recently.

Using the center of the Earth as a non rotating reference frame, when a traditional satellite deorbits, its orbital kinetic energy and momentum is transfered to its exhaust.

Without that exhaust, where would the orbital kinetic energy of a reactionless drive go?

Just to be clear, I don't believe this drive actually works. The main focus has been on the violation of the conservation of momentum, but I think it would have to violate the conservation of energy as well in a classical sense.

Posted Oct 19, 2016, 5:39 PM UTC

49
MidtekApplied Mathematics•

Particle motion with energy conserved but momentum not conserved is very common (e.g., a 2-body Newtonian orbit, a simple mass on a spring, a frictionless roller coaster, etc.). Energy conservation arises from time-translation symmetry and momentum conservation arises from spatial-translation symmetry. Neither of those symmetries implies or is implied by the other.

2
Decaf_EngineerOP•

I'm referring to closed systems. Mass on a spring still conserves momentum because the spring is anchored by something that negates the change in momentum of the mass.

1
RobusEtCeleritasExperimental Nuclear Physics•

In general, any system symmetric under spatial translations will conserve momentum and any system symmetric under translations through time will conserve the Hamiltonian.

You can come up with situations where either one, both, or neither of the symmetries holds. But regardless, the EM drive doesn't work.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
RobusEtCeleritasExperimental Nuclear Physics•

It is possible to come up with a situation where energy is conserved but momentum is not. For example, a charged particle moving through a magnetic field (neglecting losses to synchrotron radiation, which make the particle lose energy).

Without that exhaust, where would the orbital kinetic energy of a reactionless drive go?

That's exactly the problem, the reactionless drive would violate conservation of momentum. If you want to reduce the energy of the object such that it eventually ends up back on the surface of the Earth at rest, you need to change its momentum somehow.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1